East Hampton Town: Shark Attack Party In Montauk May Be Canceled; Host Disagrees

authorColleen Reynolds on Jul 2, 2013

A party estimated to draw nearly 4,000 people to the Montauk Yacht Club this weekend, will—unless a contingency plan appears quickly—likely be canceled, because of a lack of parking, according to East Hampton Town Councilwoman Theresa Quigley. However, the yacht club maintains that the show will go on.

The “Shark Attack” party, a fundraiser for the Montauk Playhouse, won Town Board approval last month to take place on Friday, July 5, and Saturday, July 6, but it subsequently came to light that its plan to use Rita’s Stables for parking is unfeasible because parking is not allowed there, Mr. Quigley explained in a phone interview on Tuesday afternoon.

The Town Board announced that afternoon a special meeting to be held at 10 a.m. on Wednesday morning in the Town Hall meeting room on Pantigo Road to discuss the application.

Town Clerk Fred Overton said the board might rescind the resolution allowing the party if the parking issue is not addressed to the board’s satisfaction.

“It looks like the permit will be pulled, unless they have another option that we don’t know about,” Ms. Quigley said. “Why the heck was this found out after it was approved? I can’t answer that.”

Lloyd Van Horn, the general manager for the club, and his attorney, Tom Horn, said late Tuesday afternoon that they have new parking, planned at a large field on Montauk Highway in Amagansett, that has many advantages over the previous plan. These include better visibility and a capacity for more cars.

The party caused some concern when it came up before the board on June 20 because of its size. The same event, held last year at Rick’s Crabby Cowboy Cafe in Montauk, was shut down after an estimated 2,000 to 2,500 attendees turned out for the event, which was intended for 800 guests.

This year's event is expected to sell out, Mr. Van Horn said, adding that 2,300 tickets have already been sold.

You May Also Like:

WATCH: Local Matters: East Hampton

The “Local Matters” series, a special five-part set of Express Sessions events, continued on December ... 14 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Tree-Cutting Begins at Napeague, Buckskill To Clear Fire Roads

Fire management plans have begun taking shape in East Hampton Town, particularly with extensive clearing ... 9 Dec 2025 by Jack Motz

Larsen, Democratic Leadership To Lower the Temperature After In-Person Meeting

After an in-person meeting, East Hampton Village Mayor Jerry Larsen and the town’s Democratic Committee ... by Jack Motz

Oyster Bay Breaks Down Twice in Montauk, Still on Track for Completion by Close of Dredge Window

The dredge Oyster Bay has broken down twice in Lake Montauk Inlet, but officials expect ... 5 Dec 2025 by Jack Motz

Three Mile Harbor Road Workforce Housing Plans Dropped Entirely

Private developer Kirby Marcantonio has dropped plans to build workforce housing on a slice of ... by Jack Motz

Conversation Over Raising ADU Caps in East Hampton Starts as Changes Remain in the Pipeline

A string of changes to loosen restrictions on accessory dwelling units will go back to ... 3 Dec 2025 by Jack Motz

Suffolk County Searching for Solutions to Meschutt Beach Vehicle Overflow

Suffolk County is searching for a solution to the chronic overflow of cars at Meschutt Beach County Park during the summer season. On sunny summer days, the throng of beachgoers that flow to the only bayfront county-run bathing beach on the South Fork quickly fill the beach parking lot. Later-arriving cars soon begin to line the roadsides of the access roads and take up parking spots that are intended for boat owners and guests at the nearby Shinnecock Marina, which the county also owns. Last week, the Suffolk County Legislature approved $250,000 in funding for the Department of Public Works ... by Michael Wright

Years-Old Dream of Memorializing the Swamp in Wainscott Returns to Limelight With Town Board Support

Back in the limelight is Tom House’s years-old goal of building a memorial to a ... 2 Dec 2025 by Jack Motz

Three Mile Harbor Road Development Plans Spark Skepticism on East Hampton Town Board Over Employer-Owned Housing

What was meant to be a discussion of rezoning a slice of land on Three ... by Jack Motz

East Hampton Town Democrats for a New Town To Get New Name After Dems Send Cease-and-Desist Letter to Larsen

With a cease-and-desist letter in hand, Mayor Jerry Larsen’s East Hampton Town Democrats for a ... by Jack Motz