Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1344233

Kathleen Madigan: Not Your Average Bartender

icon 1 Photo

authorJack Sullivan on Aug 11, 2015

From tending bar to entertaining millions on Netflix and HBO, Kathleen Madigan has earned her spot in the comedy world, bringing her Irish candor and quick wit to every performance.

The Southampton Press caught up with the comedian before she takes the stage at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor on Monday night.

The Press: How did you first get involved in comedy and when did you know you first wanted make a career out of it?

Kathleen Madigan: I just went to an open mic night in St. Louis for fun one night. I worked at the bar next door, and we went over there instead. Me and this other bartender, Mike, did open mic nights for fun. It just sounded like something fun to do. I didn’t plan on being a comedian.

It was sort of like a goof-off thing. I bartended, which was the same thing, almost, you just poured drinks, too.

The Press: Do you have a writing process?

Madigan: Stuff just happens and I write it on a bar napkin. If you found my purse, you’d think that I was a crazy person. There’s a word on there, like “Amish” or “Flight 370.” Things either happen, or I think of things and then write down the word and remember them later. I am capable [of writing], but I don’t like to do it. I am friends with Lewis Black, and Lew writes books. And I call it writing jail because you’re all alone. I would go crazy. I need to be out doing stuff and around people and see what’s going on. I really don’t love the general public, but I miss them if I’m not around them.

The Press: Who are some comedians who you find particularly inspiring or funny?

Madigan: Lewis Black makes me laugh. Ron White, Daniel Cash, kind of the usual suspects. Jim Gaffigan always makes me laugh. There’s a ton of people. I gotta say, considering all the comedians there actually are who can do an hour and actually get paid for it, I like 70 percent of them. I would pay to go see them. There are only a few who I don’t particularly get, but it’s like music. I don’t really listen to country music, but clearly it’s a popular genre.

The Press: How do you prepare for a show?

Madigan: It’s all in my head. People think, “How can you remember that?” I always say, “If I gave you one sentence to remember, and then next week I said a new one, you could do that. It’s a slow build, but you know it because you do it every night. You just keep adding and adding. I have chunks, and other times if I look at my napkins, I say, “Ok right, right.” It’s a free flowing structure, but there’s no real order.

It’s also depending on where I am, if I’m in the south or someplace offbeat. Eugene, Oregon, is a strange place. There, I start with that. It’s usually just about stuff that I noticed around the area. Oregon is a very strange place. They know they’re weird. The slogan in Portland is, “Keep it weird.” Well, job well done, because it’s just weird.

The Press: Do you know what you’ll talk about during your Sag Harbor performance?

Madigan: I honestly haven't thought about it yet. I'll think about it, probably that afternoon. Maybe there will be stuff about the Republican debate. I'll probably take a look at my napkins.

Kathleen Madigan will perform on Monday, August 17, at 8 p.m. at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor. Tickets start at $69.50. For more information, call (631)-725-9500, or visit baystreet.org.

You May Also Like:

Eugenics Casts Its Long Shadow Over Long Island

Most of us know that eugenics, the pseudoscience designed to “improve” the human race, might ... 17 Nov 2025 by Joseph Finora

Jazz Night: Live to Radio at the Masonic Temple

An evening of world-class live jazz will take place at the historic Masonic Temple in Sag Harbor on Friday, November 21, at 7 p.m. The performance will be recorded for future broadcast on WLIW-FM, an NPR affiliate. The event will feature pianist and composer Steve Sandberg, bassist Pete Swanson and tenor saxophonist Ken Fowser, with Claes Brondal on drums and serving as master of ceremonies. Sandberg is known for his fusion of jazz and world music traditions, bringing rhythmic complexity and harmonic depth to his performances. Swanson, a veteran of New York’s improvised music scene, bridges straight-ahead and avant-garde styles ... by Staff Writer

Peconic Ballet Theatre Presents ‘The Nutcracker’ at WHBPAC

Clara’s Nutcracker doll will transform into a prince who leads her through a snow-covered forest and into the Land of Sweets in Peconic Ballet Theatre’s production of “The Nutcracker.” The performance features the Sugar Plum Fairy and other classic characters from the traditional holiday ballet. Performances will take place at the Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center on Saturday, December 13, at noon and 5 p.m., and on Sunday, December 14, at noon and 5 p.m. Tickets are available at whbpac.org. Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center is located at 76 Main Street, Westhampton Beach. by Staff Writer

Jennifer Cella Performs 'Absolute Adele' at The Suffolk

The Suffolk presents “Absolute Adele” with Jennifer Cella on Saturday, November 29, at 8 p.m. ... by Staff Writer

Hamptons Festival of Music Debuts Holiday Salon Orchestra Concerts

This holiday season, the Hamptons Festival of Music presents its salon orchestra for the first time during the holidays, offering a combination of live orchestral music and seasonal poetry readings. On Thursday, December 18, at 6 p.m., the performance will take place at Springs Community Presbyterian Church, 5 Old Stone Highway, East Hampton. On Friday, December 19, at 6 p.m., the concert will be held at St. Luke’s Episcopal Church, 18 James Lane, East Hampton. The concert will include Torelli’s Concerto Grosso in G minor “Christmas,” Vivaldi’s “Winter” from The Seasons (with soloist Garry Ianco), Corelli’s Concerto Gross in G ... by Staff Writer

‘The Great American Soulbook’ Shakes Up The Suffolk

The Suffolk welcomes back “The Great American Soulbook” on Thursday, December 11, at 8 p.m. ... by Staff Writer

Annual Small Works Holiday Invitational at Kramoris Gallery

Romany Kramoris Gallery will present its “Annual Small Works Holiday Invitational” from November 22 to January 18, 2026. The group exhibition will feature more than 40 local artists showing works sized 20 inches by 20 inches or smaller. An opening reception will be held on Saturday, November 22, from 3 to 6 p.m., with additional open house receptions every Saturday throughout the holiday season from 3 to 6 p.m. Participating artists include Michael Albert, Jude Amsel, Karen Amster-Young, Adriana Barone, Lois Bender, Joyce Brian, Christine Cadarette, Linda Capello, John Philip Capello, Casey Chalem Anderson, Lucille Colin, Thomas Condon, Quincy Egginton, ... by Staff Writer

Holiday Magic and Dancing Snowflakes: HBTS’ ‘Nutcracker’ Hits Guild Hall

The Hampton Ballet Theatre School will present its 16th annual production of Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky’s ... by Staff Writer

'Fahrenheit 451' Heats Up the Bay Street Stage

As we, the denizens of the 21st century, sit at the cusp of the 250th ... 16 Nov 2025 by Annette Hinkle

A Celebration of Memory and Magic: Capote’s Christmas Stories Revived on SAC Stage

Truman Capote, a longtime Sagaponack resident, left a lasting legacy on the East End. As ... by Staff Writer