Police / Police News / 1587134

UPDATE: Hampton Bays Man Charged With Stealing Car, Leading Police On Chase Near Campus

author on Mar 29, 2013

UPDATE: Tuesday, 7 a.m.

A 21-year-old man who allegedly stole a car last week in Hampton Bays and led police on a short chase before jumping from the vehicle while it was still moving, leaving it to crash in a creek in Shinnecock Hills, was arrested on Monday by Southampton Town Police.

Authorities have charged Carlos Garcia of Hampton Bays with third-degree grand larceny and third-degree burglary, both felonies, following an investigation, according to a press release.

Police did not say where Mr. Garcia was arrested, where he had been hiding or what led them to him.

Authorities said Mr. Garcia stole a car from Union Street in Hampton Bays at 8:22 p.m. last Thursday, March 28, and was spotted a short time later by Stony Brook Southampton police officers near the Shinnecock Hills campus. After leading police on a brief chase, he jumped from the car while it was still moving, near the intersection of Middle Pond Road and Dellaria Avenue, and then fled the scene on foot.

Multiple police agencies, including K-9 units, assisted with the ensuing search but the driver eluded pursuers.

Police said the burglary charge stems from another investigation into the theft of a cellphone from the AT&T store on Montauk Highway in Hampton Bays that occurred in August. They said that investigation helped lead detectives to Mr. Garcia.

Mr. Garcia was processed and held at Town Police headquarters for arraignment.

ORIGINAL STORY

The driver of a stolen car eluded police following a massive search in Shinnecock Hills Thursday evening that included Suffolk County Police helicopters and K-9 units.

According to police, a car was reported stolen from Union Street in Hampton Bays shortly after 8 p.m. on Thursday. Stony Brook Southampton police officers spotted the car a short time later on Montauk Highway near the college and attempted to pull it over, but the driver fled, leading police on a short chase before jumping from the moving car near the intersection of Middle Pond Road and Dellaria Avenue in Southampton.

The suspect, described as a man in his late teens or early 20s with a light complexion, fled on foot, while the car crashed through a split rail fence before crashing into an anchor post in a creek that connects to Middle Pond, near the end of Dellaria Avenue.

The Southampton Town Police Department, with the assistance of the Suffolk County Police Department Aviation Unit, the Suffolk County Sheriff’s Department K-9 Unit, and the Southampton Village Police Department, conducted a search of the area, but the man eluded police and remained at large, police said. New York State Police also sent two patrol cars to assist in the search.

The Southampton Town Police Department Detective Division asks that anyone with information on the incident to call police at 728-5000 or 702-2230, or the Crime Tips Hotline at 728-3454, or send an e-mail to crimetips@southamptontownny.gov.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Community Packs a Truckload of Holiday Cheer for Families in Need

Southampton Town residents have once again shown their generosity by contributing to the Southampton Town ... 12 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

'Brazen and Notorious' Drug Depot Was Run by Riverside Man From His Home, District Attorney Says

Southampton Town Police have arrested an elderly Riverside man who they say was running a “walk-up” drug distribution business out of his house on Old Riverhead Road. John Woods, 83, was arrested by officers of the East End Drug Task Force last Friday, December 5, and charged with two felony drug possession charges. He was arraigned in Southampton Town Justice Court, but the charges will be referred to the Suffolk County district attorney’s office to seek a felony indictment in county criminal court. Police said they had been getting numerous complaints from residents of his neighborhood about drug use on ... 8 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Police Announce 2026 Civilian Academy

The Southampton Town Police Department will launch its 2026 Civilian Police Academy on January 15, ... 5 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Town PD Hits Record Staffing Level To Meet Demands of 'Police Service'

The Southampton Town Board last week approved — and applauded — the appointment of Alonso ... 2 Dec 2025 by Michael Wright

Riverhead Man Charged With DWI After Multi-Car Accident on CR-31

A Riverhead man was charged with DWI following a Saturday evening crash that sent five ... 30 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Immigration Enforcement Sweep in Hampton Bays Causes Panic Among Undocumented Workers

For Erik, the morning of Wednesday, November 5, started out like many others in the ... 25 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Police To Offer Civilian Academy Starting In January

The Southampton Town Police Department will hold its 2026 Civilian Police Academy starting in January. The academy offers a unique opportunity to see and experience what police officers do on a daily basis. All Southampton Town residents are invited to attend the specialized training at police headquarters. Developed to bring the community and the department that services it closer together, the academy aims to open up the lines of communication and build trust between the police and the community. There is no physical component to the program. Participants will gain insight into the laws of arrest, search and seizure, use ... 24 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Westhampton Post Office Worker Charged After Interfering With ICE Detention on November 5

A Westhampton Beach woman who works for the U.S. Postal Service was arraigned on federal criminal charges on Thursday, November 20, after Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers say she interfered with the detention of a man believed to be an undocumented immigrant on November 5. Tamara Mayorga-Wong, 57, of Westhampton Beach was arraigned at the federal court in Central Islip on Thursday and released on $50,000 bond. The ICE officers who arrested her on November 5 claimed that Mayorga-Wong came out of the Westhampton Post Office on Mill Road, wearing her Postal Service uniform, on the morning of November 5 ... 21 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Update: Missing Man Found Safe

UPDATE: Police reported on Friday, November 21, that King was located safe. ORIGINAL: Southampton Town ... 17 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Federal Immigration Sweep Shakes the East End | 27Speaks Podcast

 On Wednesday, November 5, ICE agents swept into Hampton Bays and Westhampton, setting upon ... 10 Nov 2025 by 27Speaks