Theater Review: ‘Promises, Promises’ Is A Winning Time Capsule - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1336531

Theater Review: ‘Promises, Promises’ Is A Winning Time Capsule

icon 6 Photos

author on Mar 13, 2017

Michael Disher” and “musicals” regularly belong in the same sentence. Fortunately for him—and us—he has ample talent to ply his passion locally with two gifted performers, Shannon DuPuis and Darren Ottati.They are the two winning stars of a bright and ultimately upbeat production of “Promises, Promises” that lives up to its name in its current production at the Southampton Cultural Center.

Under Mr. Disher’s electric direction, the swinging period piece from the 1960s retains the zippy verve that surely Neil Simon, who wrote the book, and Burt Bacharach and Hal David, who wrote the music and lyrics, intended.

No doubt about it, the plot line is smarmy: Guy trying to get ahead at a huge insurance firm lets married executives use his “bachelor pad” for trysts with “girls” who work under them, to use the vernacular of the times. He’s promised a kick upstairs in return. Trouble is, the girl who ignores him at work is not only the very one he has a crush on, but she’s in love with a serial philanderer, the slimy villain of this story. Of course, they use our protagonist’s place.

Yes, the women are treated as eminently replaceable with tomorrow’s younger, thinner version.

Yes, the vibe reflects the era before feminism and corporate rules about sexual fraternization.

Yet.

Under the direction of the nervous, edgy Mr. Disher and his ever-appealing two leads, the tawdriness of the setup falls away. It’s a romantic comedy with doors that open and shut as in farce, and you know it’s not going to end like a dark Swedish drama. Sit back and enjoy the getting there—especially the music, for the songs are the thing: Eighteen bouncy pop tunes, not counting the overture by the six-piece orchestra off stage, with catchy but repetitive lyrics, propel the story forward.

Mr. Ottati’s rich and resonant baritone wowed us last year in a concert version of “South Pacific.” Here, as the hapless but likable schlemiel Chuck Baxter, he has real acting duties as well, for this is the whole script that was on Broadway—and Mr. Ottati’s undeniable charm seduces us from the first time we meet him. We want to cheer for him at every turn. He addresses the audience throughout, and we know that he’s not a conniving jerk. He’s a sympathetic everyman.

As she was in “South Pacific,” Shannon DuPuis is once again the object of his unrequited affection, and here, as executive dining room hostess Fran Kubelik, she is delightful. Ms. DuPuis’s strong, modulated voice commands the room, but this role let her acting chops shine. By turns she is perky, distraught, resigned—a winsome waif hoping marriage comes with love.

Edna Winston as the sexy and addled barfly Marge MacDougall, who opens the second act as she comes on to Chuck, is superb. In the past, I’ve wanted to see Ms. Winston let it rip—as she always seemed to be holding something back—but here she gives a boffo comedic performance, coy as a cat, arch as someone who knows the score.

Jack Seabury is first-rate as J.D. Sheldrake, the sleazy boss. His robust voice has given him the leading role in numerous musicals elsewhere. His duet with Mr. Ottati, “It’s Our Little Secret,” is splendid. Josephine Wallace as Mr. Sheldrake’s truth-telling secretary has a good turn as the woman who’s been there, done that.

Several in the cast of 16 do double duty in the chorus, not only singing but dancing, where they are under the direction of Mr. Disher and Ms. DuPuis. Okay, it’s not Broadway, but the pair put the chorus line through their steps to engaging effect. With her extensive dance background, Ms. DuPuis grabs your attention whenever she’s in the mix.

The sets are minimal—six cubes, a platform, six chairs, two doors—but it all works. This production also has screens off to the each side with graphics that announce the scene changes. Sounds simple, but they add a pleasing lagniappe.

Amanda Jones, an East Hampton native and voice and piano teacher, was the musical director in recent productions at Southampton Cultural Center and elsewhere locally. She is rarely singled out, but she and the five other musicians deserve attention. They provide live music from behind the curtains.

Others in the production are: Richard Adler, Toni-Jo Birk, Julie Crowley, Bethany Dellapolla, Dane DuPuis, Sheila Engh, Brianna Kinnier, Geoffrey Milton, Tom Rosante, Lon Irving Shomer, Christina Stenkewicz.

“Promises, Promises” premiered in 1968 on Broadway, eight years after the Oscar-winning movie “The Apartment,” on which the story is based. “The Apartment” is a mordant take on the situation; the film might be more realistic, but for the winter blahs—a mid-March blizzard is heading our way as I write—this production is the tonic. It will leaving you remembering why “I’ll Never Fall in Love Again” and “I Say a Little Prayer” were such big hits in the Sixties.

That is, if you are old enough to remember the Sixties.

“Promises, Promises” runs Thursdays at 7:30 p.m., Fridays and Saturdays at 8 p.m. and Sundays at 2:30 p.m. through March 26. General admission is $28, or $15 for students under 21. For tickets and more information, call 631-287-4377, or go to scc-arts.org.

You May Also Like:

Hamptons Comedy Tour Returns to Bay Street Theater October 25

The HA HA Hamptons Comedy Tour returns to Bay Street Theater on Saturday, October 25, at 8 p.m. for its third annual showcase of high-energy stand-up comedy. Produced by Paul Anthony and the Long Island Comedy Festival, the tour presents a comedy experience unlike traditional club shows. Using a showcase format, the evening features multiple headlining comedians performing shorter sets — giving audiences a fast-paced lineup of both nationally recognized comics and emerging talent. “Our mantra this year is simple: Keep Laughter Alive in ’25,” said Anthony, who also serves as the evening’s host. “We’re proud to partner with Bay ... 22 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons International Film Festival Announces 2025 Award Winners

The 33rd Hamptons International Film Festival (HIFF), presented by Artemis Rising Foundation, has announced the ... 21 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

National Theatre Live To Broadcast ‘Inter Alia’ Starring Rosamund Pike

National Theatre Live will broadcast “Inter Alia,” a new play by Suzie Miller, on Friday, ... by Staff Writer

Nina Yankowitz: Six Decades of Art Without Borders at the Parrish Art Museum

Spanning six decades of work, Nina Yankowitz opened “In the Out/Out the In,” her first ... by Frankie Kadir Bademci

The Whole Self - a Powerful Prescription: Social Connection

The Best Medicine 
You’re Not Taking   What if your doctor offered a prescription that ... by Jessie Kenny

One More Blood-Sucking Weekend With 'Dracula'

Just in time for Halloween, Center Stage at Southampton Arts Center unveils “Bram Stoker’s Dracula,” ... by Staff Writer

‘Second Skin’ Now on View at SAC

“Second Skin,” a group exhibition exploring the intersection of art and fashion, opened on October ... by Staff Writer

'The Thanksgiving Play' Explores the Difficulties in Telling Someone Else's Story

Whose job is it to tell our ancestors’ stories? If you’re of European heritage, you ... by Annette Hinkle

Westhampton Beach PAC To Host One-Night-Only ‘Secret Cinema’ Screening

The Westhampton Beach Performing Arts Center will present a special “Secret Cinema” screening on Saturday, October 26, at 1 p.m. offering audiences a unique opportunity to experience a film without knowing its title until the opening credits roll. For just $5, moviegoers are invited to take part in what WHBPAC describes as a “cinematic trust fall.” The film has been carefully selected to deliver an atmospheric, gothic-style experience — more psychological than gory, and far from a typical slasher flick. The screening promises a moody, artful narrative that aligns with WHBPAC’s commitment to high-caliber, thought-provoking cinema. “This film is more ... by Staff Writer

Explore the Cosmos at The Church With ‘Stars,’ Narrated by Mark Hamill

A galaxy far, far away comes a little closer to home on Saturday, November 1, as The Church hosts “Stars: The Powerhouses of the Universe,” a mobile planetarium experience narrated by actor Mark Hamill, known worldwide for his iconic role as Luke Skywalker in the “Star Wars” films. Presented in collaboration with the Suffolk County Vanderbilt Museum, the immersive program will be shown twice — at 6 p.m. and 7:15 p.m. — inside the main hall at The Church. The show, suitable for both kids and adults, explores the lives of stars — from their formation and evolution to their ... 20 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer