Publication: The Southampton Press

Dogs have their own language and culture, local expert says

Jul 7, 08 9:41 AM  
Recommend
Comment
Email this article
Print this article
Get news alerts
RSS Feeds
Share

“Do you speak dog?”

Those are the words that Phillip Levine hears each time he meets a new four-legged friend. Observers, on the other hand, might just hear a bark or a playful growl.

“They say this to me,” maintains Mr. Levine, who fancies himself a “dog whisperer” of sorts, and who can often be seen on Main Street in Southampton Village, and elsewhere on the South Fork, with his German shepherds relaxing on the hood of his white SUV. “Dogs have their own language and organizational structure.”

Mr. Levine explains his understanding of canine language this way: “Imagine you’ve been in a foreign country for five years, and no one speaks English. Then, you’re at an open market, and you hear it spoken. You’d immediately perk up and [be] drawn to it. It’s the same way with dogs.”

Mr. Levine is the owner and founder of Companion Dogs Ltd., an East Hampton-based company whose philosophy is: “You don’t have to have special needs to have a special dog.”

Though he trains some dogs to be search-and-rescue canines, and others so they can work with the disabled, most of Mr. Levine’s clients simply want a responsive, loving dog that can be a part of their lives. “A companion,” he adds, pointing to his company name.

Mr. Levine says he is primarily a “teacher-trainer” of dogs, and that most of his clients simply want the companionship of a “well-mannered and properly civilized dog.” Hey says that each dog is unique, and that there is no “clean slate” upon which you can design a dog’s personality or behavior.

Mr. Levine says he “teaches-trains” dogs at any age and can work at owners’ homes or, in some cases, has the dog live with him during the “teaching-training” phase. He says he only works with a small number of dogs at a time, as the work he does requires a great deal of attention and effort. “This is something you can’t crank out,” he says. “This is a concentrated effort.”

Every once in a while, Mr. Levine will take in a stray and, when ready, will place that dog with the appropriate family. He says a good portion of his business is selling dogs that have achieved a higher elevation of training and cultivation. “It’s not inexpensive,” he says. “But you can either buy a Ford or a Ferrari.”

Mr. Levine believes his ability to relate and communicate with dogs is a God-given gift that he has had for his entire life. “I’ve always struggled to be understood,” he says. “But I’ve always felt that I was able to understand dogs, and that they understood me.”

He considers himself a student of dog culture—a culture that, he explains, is instinctive and primarily sensory. “We know that dogs perceive things with their eyes and ears, but understand things based mostly on their ability to smell.”

Though he is a lifelong pupil of dog culture, Mr. Levine quickly adds that he will never fully be able to comprehend it. “Just like I may speak enough Japanese to function in their culture, I will never be fully able to understand it, because I’m not a native,” he says.

Mr. Levine says his grandmother was the first to recognize his special gift with dogs, and it was she who encouraged him to nurture it. “She told me that God gives everyone a gift,” he says. “But that you have to be able to recognize it.”

Through the benevolence of a neighbor, Mr. Levine began taking in stray dogs when he was 7 years old. Growing up in Queens, he says, his mother would never let him have a dog. “She grew up in the Depression and had to wait for the dogs to leave the garbage cans so she could see if there was any food left,” he says. “So she had a bad association with dogs. But that’s changed now that she’s older.”

Mr. Levine credits the neighbor, Mrs. Brissman, for cultivating his gift. When strays would wander onto his street in Queens, he would take them in and keep them in her garage. “There I would teach them and socialize them,” he says. “I would bring them back to health and then sell them.”

At first, Mrs. Brissman subsidized Mr. Levine’s business practice. But eventually, using money he collected from selling dogs, he was able to sustain the business on his own and pay for the cost of food and veterinary care. “Mrs. Brissman provided me the opportunity to realize my calling in life,” he says.

Mr. Levine explains that the major difference between dog culture and human culture is that dog culture is innate, whereas human culture is learned. “Dogs are not random creatures,” he says. “Nor are they simply composites of behaviors imposed upon them.”

Add a comment

Jul 15, 08 1:15 AM
Dear Southampton Press –
I am the author of THE DOG BIBLE: Everything Your Dog wants You to Know” and the host/creator/producer of DOG TALK, a weekly hour-long live call-in show broadcast from WLIU on the Southampton campus. And the dogs of the East End – were they able to talk – would want you to know that they were distressed to find your newspaper heaping praise on this dog trainer whose tactics for publicity at the expense of his dogs are highly disturbing and have made him infamous to the ... more
tracie hotchner (Bennington VT)
Jul 15, 08 6:22 AM
According to the recent popular science book The First Word, dogs do not have anything we could classify as language.

TEFLtastic blog- www.tefl.net/alexcase
Alex Case (Tokyo)
Jul 15, 08 11:11 AM
Shame on the Press for giving this man coverage! This man is known for his unconventional and UNKIND training. Tell your reporters they should do more research before writing stuff like this, it's embarrassing.
Lori Gonzalez (Bridgehampton)
Jul 15, 08 2:29 PM
I can only speak from personal & professional experience, which Ms. Hotchner may or may not have, that Philip Levine of Companion Dogs, is not only an extraordinary dog trainer, but an amazing person to boot. Mr. Levine was given the task of finding our family a Weimaraner puppy almost 4 years ago. The dog he found through his may professional leads has turned out to be an outstanding dog in every sense. We worked very closely with Mr. Levine over the course of the first 2 1/2 years, receiving ... more
margie bono (sag harbor)
Jul 15, 08 2:31 PM
Well said Tracie!

EDITOR WHY are you promoting this animal hater's business here?????
DogLover (Wainscott)
Jul 15, 08 4:13 PM
I can also speak from personal and professional experience with Mr. Levine.
The fact is that Mr. Levine trained my dog with me from a pup.
The fact is that he at no time mistreated my dog.
The fact is I have never seen him mistreat his dogs (who helped to train mine throughout the process.) I have seen his dogs kiss him and be affectionate with him. I have seen his dogs respect him, and obey his commands. I have seen him be steadfastly patient with his (and my) dogs, and praise ... more
Fred David (Bridgehampton)
Jul 15, 08 4:20 PM
Whether this man is a good trainer or not doesn't matter to me, Fred.

What the REAL fact is, he makes large dogs sit on top of a hot car roof in the blazing sun to promote his business.

The fact about that is, it's cruel. Don't think so? Sit on the roof of your car in the blazing sun for 4 or 5 hours and get back to us.
Whatever Fred (Bridgehampton)
Jul 15, 08 5:17 PM
It doesn't matter if the man is a good trainer? Does it matter that the man loves and respects animals?
"Whatever" is exactly they kind signature I would expect. But since your so bent on this before you run to some other "cause" don't worry too much...if those animals were in any danger or discomfort I assure you Mr. Levine would have them secure faster than you could form a thought. And as far as safety goes, I'd choose to be under his care ahead of yours any day.
Enough is enough.
Fred David (Bridgehampton)
Jul 15, 08 7:52 PM
This comment has been removed because it is a duplicate or contains inappropriate content.
leslie edwards (Sag Harbor)
Jul 15, 08 7:52 PM
It is with great sadness that I feel compelled to answer Ms. Hotchner's letter to the editor of the Southampton Press. Since she has written "The Dog BIBLE" she is promoting herself as the authority on dogs and their behavior.
One would assume, as an authority on dogs and someone who presumably loves dogs, that before she vilifies someone she ought to know that what she is espousing is the truth.
What she has written about Philip Levine is an out and out lie. I have had a professional ... more
leslie edwards (Sag Harbor)
Jul 15, 08 8:09 PM
I've worked with Philip Levine for a long time. I can tell you from personal experience, there was never a time when his dogs or anyones elses in his care, sat on a roof in the hot sun. His dogs are better cared for than most children. I can actually say for a fact, hot, sizzling, roof? Are you kidding? He wouldnt put his dogs in harms way for a moment. Fred knows, as well all of us who have put our dogs in his care, its Phil love of dog culture that has helped us keep our dogs safe. "Whatever fred"? ... more
E Hurley (Sag Harbor)
Jul 16, 08 9:28 AM
Ms. Hotchner, you are quite wrong and your impassioned emotional attack upon Mr. Levine is both unwarranted and unjustified. I came to know Mr. Levine through a friend who has two of the most amazingly content and loving German Shepherd dogs I had ever seen. Four years ago, we were in search of a dog for our son. Not only did Mr. Levine find a wonderful dog for us, but his work with her, and with us, has been a blessing. Mr. Levine's kindness and sensitivity to his dog and our dog, as well as ... more
Richard Hansen (Dix Hills)
Jul 16, 08 10:34 AM
My grandmother once told me that there are people who “ RUN OUT TO RIGHT FILED TO CATCH AN OFFENCE.

It’s remains remarkable to me that there is always one in a thousand who will see something negative while all others who are looking at the same thing, will see joy, contentment and peace.

I once explained to Ms Hotchner after having been approached by her on an East Hampton street , that my dogs were perfectly happy and content. I explained to her then, that I would never, ... more
Philip Levine (East Hampton)
Jul 16, 08 10:57 AM
We've seen this atrocity go on for years. Believe what you want to believe but you will never convince me that your dogs are 'happy' or 'content' sitting on the roof of your car promoting your business.

Any animal lover knows this is wrong.

LHO (Bridgehampton/ Manhattan)
Jul 16, 08 11:04 AM
My dog, Riley, and I have had the pleasure and honor of working with Mr Levine for 2 years after we adopted Riley from a shelter where he was considered an unadoptable dog. Over the past 2 years Riley has been looked after at Philip's home many times and he has been pleased to sit up on the roof of his car - which he considers a thrill since Esther is his best friend. Riley does not have to be asked to jump up, he loves to go there. When Philip arrives at our house Riley gives him a greeting ... more
Lindsey A Matheson (Sag Harbor)
Jul 16, 08 11:20 AM
Far be it from me to suggest that someone who feels she has to mention her book and talk show twice in the same letter - and the first time in full caps lest we miss it - may be more interested in garnering some publicity of her own than in making a serious point.

But, back to the serious point. Anyone who has seen and interacted with Philip's dogs during one of these sessions on the roof knows that these dogs are neither hot nor uncomfortable. They do not pant, they do not have long ... more
Dr Joe Zammit Lucia (Sag Harbor )
Jul 16, 08 11:40 AM
Over the last fifteen years, I've had the privilege of having Philip Levine work with four of my dogs. I'm now proud to call him a friend and have watched with awe as he worked his miracles on my beloved dogs: two standard poodles and two German Shepherds. I've known his last three dogs, Martha, Esther and Ida and seeing them go through every day as utterly contented, nurtured, well-behaved, enthusiastic working dogs is truly extraordinary. Philip teaches dogs to be civilized and he shows their ... more
Julie Sayres (Los Angeles/Shelter Island)
Jul 16, 08 7:41 PM
TO PUT IT QUITE SIMPLY, PHILIP LEVINE IS THE BEST DOG TRAINER , AND THE MOST KNOWEGABLE PERSON ON DOGS THAT I EVER MET!!! I HAVE HAD THE HONOR TO OWN ONE OF PHILIPS TRAINED DOGS, SHE WAS FULL OF LOVE FOR PHILIP AND EVERYONE ELSE, SHE WAS A PERFECT COMPANION IN EVERY WAY, I COULD NOT THINK OF OWNING A DOG IF PHILIP DID NOT TRAIN HER. I HAVE KNOWN PHILIP LEVINE FOR 35 YEARS, AND NEVER HAS HE LEFT HIS DOGS IN THE SUN OR HEAT , CHECK IT OUT , NEXT TIME YOUR OUT PUT YOUR HAND ON THE CAR AND SEE FOR YOURSELVES. ... more
just alan (olive new york)
Jul 16, 08 11:35 PM
11:32pm Wednesday OP: 36 BB:17

You're going to lose, my friend.
Ollie (Southampton)
Jul 17, 08 11:13 AM
My family and I had the pleasure of working with Philip Levine and his dogs,at home and out in public. When we first got our German sheppard Conan,he was a hand full; we knew that we needed help. We tried a few trainers and they told us to either put him down or get rid of him. They didn't take the time to work with us or Conan; they spent all of 5 min with us. that's when my son came home and said he saw Philip in Sag Harbor. we got his phone number I called him and he came to our house to meet ... more
Lili (Sag Harbor)
Jul 18, 08 11:55 AM
I don't normally get involved in these types of dialogues but I need to make an exception for this situation. I know both Ms Hotchner and Mr. Levine. Ms. Hotchner has strong opinions on canine care and maintenance and it is sad that she needs to take this venue to express them. Mr. Levine has been instrumental in helping my rotti/Shepard mix (now 16 yrs old) through her "terrible twos" stage and even more importantly he helped me understand my dog. He has been known to me for over 15 years and ... more
Into the Woods (Hampton Bays)
Jul 22, 08 11:02 AM
Dear Editor:

I was astonished and appalled by the comments made in a recent Letter to the Editor about local dog trainer Mr. Levine. I have known Mr. Levine on both a professional and personal level for more than a year and, like his many loyal clients, I have nothing but respect and admiration for his training techniques and for his obvious love of animals.

My golden retriever, Bailey, and I work with Mr. Levine extensively. Time after time I have found Mr. Levine’s innovative ... more
Leslie Kaminoff (Hampton Bays)
Jul 24, 08 9:58 PM
I am another staunch supporter of Philip Levine. We met more than a dozen years ago on the street in Southampton, when his dog Martha was in her prime. As a consequence of that chance meeting, I and my family and friends have acquired six remarkable dogs through him. My husband and I own two German Shepherd dogs who receive no end of accolades for their fine behavior and sensible demeanor.

As noted by several of Philip's satisfied clients, his primary work is with dog owners--educating ... more
Judith Segal (Oyster Bay Cove, NY)

Add a comment