'My Fair Lady': Why Wasn’t Julie Andrews In The Film? - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1338917

‘My Fair Lady’: Why Wasn’t Julie Andrews In The Film?

icon 1 Photo
By Lorraine Dusky on Aug 11, 2016

The original Broadway production of “My Fair Lady” in 1956 starred Julie Andrews, a frequent visitor to the Hamptons and the mother of one of the founders of Bay Street Theater, Emma Walton Hamilton. While Ms. Andrews performed in the theater to acclaim, when Lerner and Loewe sold the movie rights to Warner Brothers, Jack Warner wanted someone better known to American audiences in the role of Eliza. Ms. Andrews had not been in the movies before.

Audrey Hepburn got the part; because her voice could not carry the songs, the impeccable Marni Nixon dubbed the singing, as was common then. Ms. Andrews went on to star and sing that same year, 1964, as Mary Poppins in the movie of the same name.

When the Academy Awards were handed out the following year, though “My Fair Lady” won eight Oscars, including Best Picture, Best Director and Best Actor (Rex Harrison, reprising his Broadway role), Ms. Andrews took home both the Golden Globe and Academy Award for acting, beating out Ms. Hepburn. That same year, 1965, Ms. Andrews starred in “The Sound of Music.” Her ability to star in a movie was never doubted again.

Ms. Andrews, 80, is currently in Australia where she is directing a production of “My Fair Lady” to open August 30 at the Sydney Opera House.

Despite the success of the film, Lerner and Loewe did not like it. In the agreement with theaters when “My Fair Lady” is staged, the film is not to be mentioned or credited, but a nearly forgotten 1938 film version of George Bernard Shaw’s “Pygmalion” instead.

The satirist Shaw would be amused.

You May Also Like:

Women And Their Art

In “The Curator’s View,” an illustrated talk at the Parrish Art Museum on Friday, February ... 22 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Soul Spectacular Courtesy Of The HooDoo Loungers

The HooDoo Loungers have been lauded as the go-to party band of the East End. ... by Staff Writer

Artistic Residents Welcome

The Watermill Center is now accepting applications for its 2021 Artist Residency Program. The program ... 20 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Inside The World Of Booksellers

Antiquarian booksellers are part scholar, part detective and part businessperson, and their personalities and knowledge ... 18 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Entries Welcome For Guild Hall’s Annual Members Art Show

For 82 years Guild Hall has reserved space in its exhibition schedule for the annual ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Gallerist To Shut Her Doors

Janet Lehr has announced she will be closing her East Hampton gallery, Janet Lehr Fine ... by Staff Writer

Monsters Run Amok In ‘Matinee,’ A Cold War-Era Tribute

In the 1993 film “Matinee,” director Joe Dante pays homage to William Castle, the master ... by Staff Writer

Finding The Many Layers Of Black History

“Black art has always existed. It just hasn’t been looked for in the right places.” ... by Michelle Trauring

Do Another Trick, Grandpa!

Guaranteed to make grandparenting even more fun, Allan Zola Kronzek’s book “Grandpa Magic” is sure ... 17 Feb 2020 by Staff Writer

Dance Troupe Revisits The Tragic Story Of Four Little Girls

It’s written on his face. It moves through his chest, his arms, his legs. It ... by Michelle Trauring

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported