Sag Harbor 'Half House' Leads To Dispute Between Owner And Village Architectural Review Board - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1404081

Sag Harbor ‘Half House’ Leads To Dispute Between Owner And Village Architectural Review Board

icon 3 Photos

author on Jan 23, 2017

Jermain Avenue is one of the many tiny, tight-knit neighborhoods in Sag Harbor with residential houses resting close together. But one house on that road has a little more breathing room: 136 Jermain Avenue, also known as a “half house.”

The two-story, three-bay frame house was originally built in 1854 and was 1,606 square feet, with a recent addition bringing it up to a current total of 2,195 square feet. When current owner Julian Ellison purchased the property in March 2015, his intent was to renovate the house by adding a new driveway, new windows, new foundations, retaining walls and a swimming pool, along with replacing the addition that was not part of the historical footprint. He also had the intention of retaining some of the original elements of the property, including the clapboard sidings, side-gabled roof, six-over-six wooden sash windows, molded door surround, and the entrance hood where the date 1854 is branded.

“He just wants to have a house that a family can grow in,” said Alex Kriegsman, Mr. Ellison’s attorney, who was hired after Mr. Ellison ran into some roadblocks with the Sag Harbor Board of Historic Preservation & Architectural Review, referred to as the ARB.

According to legal documents filed in State Supreme Court on November 30, Mr. Ellison’s plans were first presented to the board on April 28 of last year after he submitted a certificate of appropriateness—as required by village law—16 days before. Represented by architect Anne Sherry, Mr. Ellison’s plans were criticized for being too large of an addition to the property, including doubling the size of the house’s second floor, despite Ms. Sherry saying it was within the limits of the village zoning code.

When Ms. Sherry returned to the board on May 12 with a 3D model of what the property would look like after the renovations were added, as requested by the board, the board reiterated that the renovations were too large for the aesthetic of the neighborhood. This claim was repeated again when Mr. Ellison, Ms. Sherry, and Mr. Kriegsman appeared in front of the board again on June 9, this time asking for specific problems with the plans and being given little explanation.

Ms. Sherry and Mr. Kriegsman approached the board three more times with new plans for the renovations each time—on June 23, July 28, and September 8. On all three occasions, little leeway was gained.

“We asked the board to articulate what they didn’t like about it—they refused. Their village attorney [David J. Gilmartin Jr.] advised them to do so, they refused,” Mr. Kriegsman said. “The board members made the same disparaging remarks as we tried to resolve this.”

Anthony Brandt, the ARB chairman, said he could not comment on the application because it is the subject of a lawsuit. Mr. Gilmartin could not be reached for comment.

According to the State Supreme Court filings, the ARB had many issues in their dispute. For example, at the June 9 meeting, board members used both the preamble to the village zoning code and the standards of the U.S. Secretary of the Interior to reinstate the problems with the renovations, but could not point out specific points of both examples that negate the proposal.

At the July 28 meeting, the board compared the proposal to the original historical building despite village code requiring them to compare it with the current structure that had the non-historical addition on it.

On December 1, State Supreme Court Justice Joseph C. Pastoressa issued an Order to Show Just Cause to the Village Board and the ARB. This order aned the board’s denial of Mr. Ellison’s application for a certificate of appropriateness on both July 28 and September 8, approving the applications from both dates, and declared a recent law regarding gross floor area, determining the size of a house based on the lot of property it’s on, to be “invalid, and void.”

Village Mayor Sandra Schroeder had no comment on this order.

You May Also Like:

New Build In Bridgehampton Sells For $10.5 Million

The sale of a new build in Bridgehampton that went into contract just one week ... 12 Oct 2021 by Staff Writer

New Contracts For Hamptons Home Sales Down 49 Percent In September

Newly inked deals for single-family home purchases on the South Fork were down 48.7 percent ... by Staff Writer

Rebuilt And Expanded Bridgehampton Residence Sells For $25 Million

A rebuilt and expanded 1902 ‚Äúcottage‚ÄĚ on 2.3 acres in Bridgehampton with access to Sagg ... by Staff Writer

Three Lots In Northampton Shores Hit Market As A Package Deal

In the exclusive 100-year-old Northampton Shores community in Noyac, stone and bronze sculptor Robert Hooke’s ... 5 Oct 2021 by Staff Writer

Southampton ARB Seeks To Landmark Powell Avenue Home

A split Southampton Village Board of Architectural Review and Historic Preservation has started the landmarking ... by Brendan J. O’Reilly

CPF Raises $144.7 Million In First Eight Months Of 2021

Revenues for the Peconic Bay Region Community Preservation Fund were $144.74 million during the first eight months of 2021, double the total during the same months last year. In August alone, the CPF brought in $13.45 million, a 20.5 percent year-over-year increase, according to the office of New York State Assemblyman Fred. W. Thiele Jr., which also noted that in the last 12 months, the CPF has generated $211.9 million. Each of the five East End towns maintains its own CPF, which is funded through a 2 percent tax on real estate transactions. The home-buying frenzy spurred by the COVID-19 ... by Staff Writer

Governor Has Until October 9 To Sign Or Veto Community Housing Fund Bill

The State Legislature sent Governor Kathy Hochul a bill on Tuesday, September 28, that would ... 29 Sep 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Waterfront North Haven Postmodern Sells For $7 Million

A waterfront shingled postmodern in North Haven recently sold for $7.08 million after last asking ... by Staff Writer

Thiele’s Law Passes; Landlords May Collect Rent For Whole Summer Upfront

A new state law has clarified that deposits and advance payments for seasonal rentals are not subject to caps, which means that landlords can collect rent for an entire summer upfront. Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. penned the legislation, which Governor Kathy Hochul signed last week. It was designed to make clear that limits imposed by New York State’s Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019 only apply to permanent housing, not to vacation rentals. Prior to the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act, it had been common practice for East End landlords require a single payment for the ... 28 Sep 2021 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Waterfront Traditional In North Haven Sells For $12 Million

A waterfront home in North Haven sold last week for $12 million, a record for ... 21 Sep 2021 by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what‚Äôs new, click ‚ÄúStart the Tour‚ÄĚ to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
‚Äúcontact/advertise‚ÄĚ link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend