Pierson Boys and Girls Run Well in Losses to Bayport-Blue Point

icon 6 Photos
Pierson seventh-grader Evelyn Rizzo.  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson seventh-grader Evelyn Rizzo. CASEY FINELLI

Pierson senior Sara O'Brien.  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson senior Sara O'Brien. CASEY FINELLI

Pierson's Riley Simmons.  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson's Riley Simmons. CASEY FINELLI

Pierson freshman Lincoln Fischer.  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson freshman Lincoln Fischer. CASEY FINELLI

Pierson's Jaxson Schuman.  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson's Jaxson Schuman. CASEY FINELLI

Pierson sophomore Josie Mott  CASEY FINELLI

Pierson sophomore Josie Mott CASEY FINELLI

Casey Finelli on Oct 15, 2025

Last week’s tri-meet against Bayport-Blue Point and Southold marked the beginning of a new era for the Pierson boys and girls cross country teams. A new course was implemented at Mashashimuet Park in Sag Harbor and new faces are stepping up for the Whalers.

Despite both teams losing their respective meets on October 7, viewers got a glimpse of what the future could hold for them.

Head coach Yanina Cuesta was pleased with her girls’ performance at the park.

“They’re a strong team,” she said of Bayport. “I knew it was going to be a tough race. It was going to be us being healthy and pushing really hard.”

Seventh-grader Evelyn Rizzo dusted every other girl at the meet, posting a time of 19:38, finishing ahead of second place Isabella Klein by 30 seconds.

“Obviously, Evelyn is kicking butt,” Cuesta said. “She’s a seventh-grader and very, very competitive. She’s making the rest of the team competitive as well.”

“It feels good playing at the varsity level,” Rizzo said. “I like to compete with the older kids.”

Senior Sara O’Brien, who Evelyn regards as a mentor on the team, finished the race in 20:49, while sophomore Josie Mott ran a 21:52 to round out the top three for Pierson. Other finishers included Bennett Greene, who finished in 22:49, Maggie Greenwald, who finished in 24:29, and Olivia Stiglitz, who crossed the finish line in 25:08.

As for the boys, they picked up the pace compared to previous meets, with every single member of the team setting a new personal record. Coach Paul Stoutenburgh is ecstatic about their potential, coaching a group with only one junior, the rest being sophomores or younger.

Stoutenburgh replaced longtime Whalers’ coach Joe Amato this season. Amato had initially retired from coaching before heading up the Westhampton Beach boys cross country program.

“I’ve always had a passion for running.” Stoutenburgh said. “This is my first year coaching cross country, and so far it’s been a blast. We have a small, but dedicated and hardworking, group of boys this year. We’re a relatively young team, who have all shown great sportsmanship, dedication and high potential for running performance.

“I’m very lucky to have Quincy Renaud, a junior, returning for another season of cross country,” he continued. “We recently welcomed sophomores Shayne Schroeder and Zach Browngardt. We have three freshmen on board — Riley Simmons, Lincoln Fischer and Jaxson Schuman — and we’re also excited to have eighth-grader Leo Mogavero running with us.”

Freshman Riley Simmons did the heavy lifting for the Whalers in last week’s home meet, finishing in 17:52.

“It was a really hard race.” Simmons said. “I was really tired from the invitational last weekend, but really it’s all a mental game. Midway through the race, my body felt horrible, but I told myself to push through. I set a new PR today, and that’s all I can really ask for.”

Fischer (18:57) and Schuman (19:17) rounded out the podium for the Whalers. Other finishers were Renaud (22:29) and Schroeder (23:32). Browngardt, Mogavero and sophomore Ben Ezeir (who’s out due to injury) did not compete.

The new course was another element of last week’s race, but, generally speaking, it got the thumbs up from everyone.

“The coaches liked a 5K, so that we could keep 5Ks across the board,” Cuesta said. “I worked really hard to try and keep most of the course that we had, but extended here and there so that we could make it a full 5K. It took me four tries of running and biking the course to figure out how to make it fit.”

Coach Stoutenburgh is also adjusting.

“The new course has worked out very well,” he said. “It’s more intricate, with more turns than before. However, no one has made a wrong turn and the course allows viewers to see much of the race.”

You May Also Like:

Rizzo's Top-20 Finish Earns All-State Honors at Cross Country Championships

Evelyn Rizzo capped her breakout cross country season with an 11th place finish at the ... 18 Nov 2025 by Drew Budd

Rizzo Dominates State Qualifier, Continues Breakout Run as Teammates Also Punch Tickets to States

Off cross country courses, Pierson’s Evelyn Rizzo appears to be a typical, unassuming and quiet ... 11 Nov 2025 by Drew Budd

Rizzo Leads Pierson Girls Country to Second-Place Finish at Division Championships

Evelyn Rizzo appears to have a competitive streak in her. In the only other meet ... 29 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Football Avenges Last Year's Playoff Loss at Hills West; Cook Leads Mariners Cross Country to First Win; Hampton Bays Girls Soccer Tallies Two Wins

Bonac Football Avenges
Last Year’s Playoff Loss The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team defeated host Half Hollow Hills West, 35-10, on Saturday afternoon, on the same field the Bonackers suffered a 52-6 loss in the opening round of the Suffolk County Division III playoffs last season. Theo Ball threw for 190 yards and three touchdowns, one of them to Jackson Ronick who also rushed for 75 yards and two touchdowns. Charlie Stern caught three receptions for 115 yards and recorded six tackles on defense. Livs Kuplins had six tackles and an interception and caught a 25-yard reception for a touchdown for the ... 23 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bridgehampton Boys Soccer, Hampton Bays Boys Volleyball Picks Up First-Ever Victories; East Hampton Girls Soccer On Fire

Bonac Boys Cross Country
Defeats Harborfields The East Hampton boys cross country team defeated Harborfields, 17-38, in its season opener on its home course on school grounds on September 9. According to head coach Kevin Barry, it’s only the second dual meet loss for the Tornadoes in the last five years. The Bonackers swept the top four placements to win the meet outright. Senior Sean Perez, in his first-ever cross country race, won the 2.5-mile race in 13:52, followed closely by senior Liam Knight (13:59) and sophomores Jasper Samuelson (14:09) and Watts Comly-Bolick (14:13). East Hampton Girls Soccer
Stays Undefeated The Bonackers ... 17 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Talented Pierson Girls Cross Country Team To Face Tough Competition

Pierson girls cross country head coach Yani Cuesta has grown accustomed to having competitive teams ... 10 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Pierson, Bridgehampton Student-Athletes Earn Postseason Awards for Efforts During Fall Season

Pierson Boys Cross Country All-Division Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras, David Kriegsman Both Gonzalez-Nateras and David Kriegsman each qualified for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed First Team All-League Edmar Gonzalez-Nateras Second Team All-League Ben and David Kriegsman, Ben Ezier Pierson Girls Cross Country All-State, Class C/D Individual County Champion, All-County Greylynn Guyer All-League Bennett Greene, Maggie Greenwald, Greylynn Guyer, Josie Mott The girls went undefeated (6-0) in all League IX dual meets to win the league title outright. Greenwald, Guyer, Mott and Sara O’Brien each qualified individually for the New York State Cross Country Championships. — Ed. Pierson Field ... 26 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer

Penelope Greene Earns Second All-American Honors After Placing Third at Nationals

Penelope Greene is now a two-time NCAA Division III All-American after the 2021 Pierson graduate ... 26 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd

Greylynn Guyer Earns All-State Honors at New York State Cross Country Championships

For the first time ever, Greylynn Guyer is an All-State cross country runner. The Pierson ... 19 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd

Guyer Wins C/D County Race, but Girls Finish Behind Port Jeff; Gonzalez-Nateras, Kriegsman Qualify for States

The Pierson girls cross country team was expected to win its sixth consecutive Suffolk County ... 12 Nov 2024 by Drew Budd