Historic Sagaponack House Faces Threat Of Demolition - 27 East

Historic Sagaponack House Faces Threat Of Demolition

icon 9 Photos
An aerial view of the 3.2 acre lot at 414 Hedges Lane

An aerial view of the 3.2 acre lot at 414 Hedges Lane

 in Sagaponack.     COURTESY OF DOUGLAS-ELLIMAN

in Sagaponack. COURTESY OF DOUGLAS-ELLIMAN

The Deacon Hedges House in Sagaponack

The Deacon Hedges House in Sagaponack

 circa 1900.   COURTESY BRIDGEHAMPTON HISTORICAL MUSEUM

circa 1900. COURTESY BRIDGEHAMPTON HISTORICAL MUSEUM

The front door of the Deacon David Hedges House is now emblazoned with a memorial plaque.      BEN KAVA

The front door of the Deacon David Hedges House is now emblazoned with a memorial plaque. BEN KAVA

The Deacon David Hedges House

The Deacon David Hedges House

 at 414 Hedges Lane

at 414 Hedges Lane

 is for sale

is for sale

 listed at $11.95 million.     BEN KAVA

listed at $11.95 million. BEN KAVA

Ben Kava on Jul 2, 2018

In the more than 360 years since its founding, Sagaponack has retained much of its core. Its one school and one store have charmed residents and visitors for years—and so have its small, rustic and certainly historic homes.

One of those homes, 414 Hedges Lane, is now in apparent danger of demolition.

A pre-Revolutionary farmhouse built in 1775, the home was once owned by Deacon David Hedges, for whom the Sagaponack Village street is named. While residing there, Hedges served as a delegate to the state convention of New York responsible for ratifying the Constitution, and served as a supervisor for the Town of Southampton for 22 years. Living at the house with him were a “big family of slaves,” Sally Spanburgh says in an “inventory of historic resources” outside the National Register Historic District that was prepared for the village in 2017. The house has been described as a rare treasure.

The property boasts a separate barn space, a wooden replica of a Union flag attached to a picket fence—and, perhaps most noticeably for potential buyers, 3.2 acres on which to expand.

In a neighborhood that has seen perpetual modernization, the property is one of a small number that have remained unchanged. The colonial-era home, sold on February 27, 2017, now faces the threat of a demolition proposed by its latest owners.

On June 14, Deacon David Hedges LLC filed an application to demolish the house, which sits just east of the intersection of Hedges Lane and Fairfield Pond Road. The house was recently purchased by the LLC for just under $3 million. It was previously owned by John, Walter, William, Kate and Jean Hedges.

According to Sagaponack Village records, John, Walter and William Hedges transferred the house for no consideration to the Deacon David Hedges Corporation, while Jean Hedges and Kate Hedges received the multimillion-dollar compensation for the property.

Before a demolition application was presented to the village, two separate proposals had been drafted by Deacon David Hedges LLC. The first, filed on March 15, 2017, requested a use variance for the property, asking for permission to build a second residential structure on the property. The application was withdrawn without prejudice on June 9, 2017.

The second application, filed on May 31, 2017, asked the village for an area variance to allow the owners to divide the 141,464-square-foot parcel into two distinct lots—the first, a small lot of 36,764 square feet, and the second, a much larger lot of 104,700 square feet, which would have allowed two separate buyers to split the property.

The application was scheduled to be discussed on July 14, 2017, but the discussion was postponed by the LLC. According to village officials, representatives of Deacon David Hedges LLC said when they requested the postponement that they were “working on something else behind the scenes.” The application was eventually withdrawn in early January 2018.

Ever since its construction 243 years ago, the Deacon David Hedges home has remained in the Hedges family. The home, which sits on a street once occupied all by Hedges houses, allowed Deacon David Hedges to walk from Sagaponack to Wainscott on his own land, according to “East Hampton History” by Jeannette Edwards Rattray. Now on the market for $11.95 million, it may end up in the hands of a buyer outside the family for the first time.

Paul Brennan of Douglas Elliman, one of three brokers representing the property, said there has been some interest from prospective buyers. He said the new owner will likely be a “real vintage house aficionado,” though he noted that a renovation of the home’s inside is probably needed. “The house needs work,” he said, “but it’s a piece of history.”

How much work an eventual buyer will be able to do is yet to be determined. Zoning laws put in place in 1957 restrict Sagaponack properties from housing two dwellings on the same lot. The only exception, said Village Building Inspector Jon Woudsma, is if a multi-dwelling property pre-dates that zoning regulation. In some cases, he said, properties with more than one habitable structure have tunnels that connect them, resulting in what is basically a single, connected residence.

On July 20, the Sagaponack Village Architecture and Historic Review Board will review the demolition application.

Though he could not comment on whether the board is likely to approve the application, Mr. Woudsma offered the following sentiments: “Everyone on the Village Board is looking to preserve that house. If that means making accommodations, I guarantee all of that will be entertained.”

The listed taxpayer for the property, John Hedges of Charlottesville, Virginia, could not be reached for comment.

You May Also Like:

Fill A Truck To Support Room To Grow Initiative

Room to Grow will hold its summer donation drive with family-friendly activities, raffle prizes at its Fill-A-Truck donation event on Friday, July 11, at the Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum, 200 Main Street in Sag Harbor, from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. The nonprofit invites local residents to drop off new or like-new baby and toddler essentials — including clothing, toys, books, and more — to support nearly 600 under-resourced families raising young children in New York. This event will feature kid-approved games like cornhole and frisbee, a lemonade stand, coloring activities, raffle prizes from local businesses, and more. ... 30 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

School News, July 3, Sag Harbor & East Hampton

Sag Harbor Students Connect With Community and Culture Pre-k students from the Sag Harbor Learning ... by Staff Writer

Tickets On Sale for Authors Night at East Hampton Library

Tickets are now on sale for the East Hampton Library’s 21st annual Authors Night fundraiser, set for Saturday, August 9, in Herrick Park. Authors Night features 100 authors across all genres. “As we celebrate the 21st anniversary of Authors Night, we’re excited to once again bring this beloved event to the heart of East Hampton Village,” said Dennis Fabiszak, director of the East Hampton Library. “The funds raised at Authors Night allow us to continue offering essential programs and services at the library — completely free of charge — to our diverse community all year long.” The evening begins at ... by Staff Writer

Summer of Wellness Event, Sponsored by Southampton Hospital Foundation, Is Set for July 19

The Southampton Hospital Foundation’s third annual Summer of Wellness will be held at Southampton Youth Services on Saturday, July 19. The event opens with a spin class with Analisa Johnson and a mat Pilates class with Leisa Taylor, both at 8 a.m. A pickleball tournament will start at 8:30 a.m., divided into recreational and advanced player time slots. DanceBody’s Sculpt with Courtnay Mariani is at 8:45 a.m., and Hatha yoga with Kelly DeRoches is at 9 a.m. Learn about food as medicine in “Taste The Season” at 9:30 a.m. Andrew Fornarola will lead the Elements Barre Fitness’s Barre + Sculpt ... by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor Community Band Kicks Off Summer Series

A free summer concert series featuring the Sag Harbor Community Band starts next week, on July 8, and continues every Tuesday through August 26. The concerts start at 8 p.m. at Marine Park on Bay Street, marking the 67th summer season of the series. The opening concert theme is “Americana.” Led by musical director David Brandenburg, the program will feature patriotic favorites, including marches by John Philip Sousa and Henry Fillmore, along with other selections from the band’s repertoire. All concerts are free, open to the public and family-friendly. Attendees are encouraged to bring folding chairs or blankets. Among the ... by Staff Writer

SOFO Gala Celebrates 'Champions of the Wild: A New Generation'

Liev Schreiber will serve as the honorary chair for the South Fork Natural History Museum’s 36th annual Summer Gala Benefit, “Champions of the Wild: A New Generation,” on Saturday, July 12, at the museum in Bridgehampton. The event will benefit SOFO’s educational and environmental programs and initiatives, which empower families to be responsible stewards of the planet. Honorees for the evening will include SOFO board trustees and committed supporters of the museum Ray Iwanowski and Erica Noble; Joshua Fox, director of the Brady Hunter Foundation, headquartered in Miami, Florida; and Jeff Corwin of the “Extraordinary World with Jeff Corwin,” which ... by Staff Writer

Ribbon Cutting for New Outdoor Patio at School

East Hampton Union Free School District’s Board of Education recently led a ceremonial ribbon cutting ... 29 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

James Elected To Helm CCOM

At its recent annual meeting, the Concerned Citizens of Montauk (CCOM) announced the election of Jessica James as the new board president. James takes the helm from David Freudenthal, who has successfully guided the organization since 2021, continuing its mission to protect Montauk’s unique environment through education, advocacy, and citizen action. CCOM’s board of directors is a group of volunteers elected by members to provide leadership and support to the organization’s staff. Together, they work to preserve Montauk’s natural beauty and ecological health. James, as a CCOM board member for 15 years, brings a longstanding commitment to the organization. She ... by Staff Writer

Sculpting Workshop With Peruvian Artist at LTV

LTV Studios is offering a workshop with Peruvian sculptor Rocio Snyder on Wednesday, July 9, from 6 to 9 p.m. In “Form and Flow: Sculpting the Intuitive Object,” participants will learn and apply the foundations of sculpting clay while enjoying wine and traditional Peruvian “light bites.” The workshop is appropriate for all levels of artistry. All materials and tools are included. While working with their hands and tools to explore the possibilities of clay, participants will learn more about Peruvian art, cuisine, and culture in a fun, social, and relaxing setting. Snyder studied at the School of Fine Arts in ... by Staff Writer

Luncheon and Conversation Event To Benefit East Hampton Emergency Department

The Southampton Hospital Foundation has announced the return of its East Hampton Emergency Department Luncheon, ... by Staff Writer