A memorial is planned for long-time summer resident H. Virgil Sherrill who died in January

icon 1 Photo

author on May 12, 2010

A celebration of the life of H. Virgil Sherrill—a longtime summer resident of Southampton and former president of Shinnecock Hills Golf Course—will be held on Saturday, May 22, at 5 p.m. at the family home at 217 Pond Lane in Southampton.

Mr. Sherrill died on January 20 at his home in Hobe Sound, Florida, surrounded by family.

Mr. Sherrill first came to Southampton in 1952, renting the Gilmartin House on Herrick Road and buying a house on Pond Lane in 1958. The Pond Lane home was built in 1900 by the architectural firm Carrere and Hastings for Secretary of War Elihu Root, husband of Ruth Salem Wales, whose parents were among earliest members of the Southampton summer colony.

Born in 1920 in Merryville, Louisiana, a small town on the Texas-Louisiana border, he lived during his childhood in various other small southern towns until, following his father’s death, his mother settled in Biloxi, Mississippi. In Mississippi, Mr. Sherrill attended the Gulf Coast Military Academy, graduating as the leading cadet in his class. He then attended a post graduate year at the Hill School in Pottstown, Pennsylvania, after which he entered Yale College, graduating in 1942.

Immediately following college, he enlisted in the U.S. Naval Air Service, serving as a pilot on the USS Wasp in the South Pacific. He was an ace, shooting down nine Japanese planes in aerial combat (six in one day), and decimating a Japanese destroyer by dropping a bomb down its stack on a strafing mission, family recalled from the stories Mr. Sherrill would tell. He received the Navy Cross, the Distinguished Flying Cross and four Air Medals.

Mr. Sherrill earned a degree from Yale Law School in 1948 and moved to New York City, where he joined the Wall Street firm Shields & Company, founded by Paul Shields, a summer resident of Southampton. After becoming a managing partner of the firm in 1958, he transformed the company into an international firm with the acquisition of Model Roland International. In 1977 he merged Shields Model Roland with Bache Halsey Stuart Inc., and was named president of Bache Halsey Stuart Shields. Then, in 1982, Bache was acquired by the Prudential Life Insurance Company of America and became Prudential Bache Securities and then simply Prudential Securities, of which Mr. Sherrill was vice chairman and then senior director until his retirement in 2000.

Mr. Sherrill was honored as the B’nai B’rith Wall Street Man of the Year and served as the chairman of the Securities Industry Association.

Throughout his professional career, Mr. Sherrill was also involved in philanthropic activities, serving on the board of managers of Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center and as vice chairman and president of Memorial Hospital. He also served on the board of trustees of the Boys Club of New York, taking a leading role in the creation of the Annual Sports Hall of Fame Dinner, which honored each year’s inductees into the Halls of Fame of major sports. In addition, he was a generous patron to Southampton Hospital and to St. Andrew’s Dune Church.

An avid amateur golfer, he served as president of the Shinnecock Hills Golf Club from 1972 until 1980. He was responsible for bringing the Walker Cup to Shinnecock in 1977 and was instrumental in organizing the U.S. Open at Shinnecock in 1986, nearly a hundred years after it had first been played there. Although unable to play the game of golf in his last years, Mr. Sherrill insisted on retaining his membership at both Shinnecock Hills Golf Club and the National Golf Links of America in Southampton; the Cypress Point Club in Pebble Beach, California; Seminole Golf Club in Juno Beach, Florida; and The Royal & Ancient Golf Club of St. Andrews in Scotland. He was also a member of The Meadow Club and the Southampton Bathing Corporation, as well as the Racket and Tennis Club and the Brook Club, both in New York City.

Mr. Sherrill is survived by his wife Betty Sherrill, the long-time president of McMillen, Inc., the oldest interior design firm in America—her gardens on Pond Lane have been on view for numerous garden tours over the years. He is also survived by a daughter, Ann Pyne and a son, Stephen Sherrill, both of whom maintain houses in Southampton; and five grandchildren, Elizabeth Pyne, John Pyne Jr., Stephen Sherrill Jr., William Sherrill and Katherine Sherrill.

In lieu of flowers, donations to the St. Andrew’s Dune Church, P.O. Box 1245, Southampton, N.Y., 11969 would be appreciated by the family.

You May Also Like:

An American Story

If you, like I, are having a hard time dealing with the ugly spectacle in Washington, D.C., then perhaps you would like to distract yourself with Ken Burns’s documentaries about America. I am loving “The American Revolution.” Wow! I grew up in an extended family that discussed the Constitution and civics on a daily basis. Not so common these days. As a conscientious American, I am having a hard time remaining patient with this insulting government today. I hope you find it interesting to learn how my family came to America. My many times great-grandfather John Conlin, on my mother’s ... 23 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Playing Politics

The Lake Agawam Conservancy has raised and spent millions to begin to clean up Lake Agawam. Our board and supporters consist of residents throughout Southampton Village. Today, thanks to the strong partnership between the conservancy, the village, the town and the State Department of Environmental Conservation, Professor Chris Gobler reports that Lake Agawam is healthier than it’s been in years. In 2024, the conservancy entered into a stewardship agreement to maintain bioswales throughout our village. These bioswales “clean” toxic runoff before it pollutes the lake. At no cost to village taxpayers, the conservancy agreed to install a 1,000-foot bioswale along ... by Staff Writer

National Golf Links Embarks on Historic Restoration of Hilltop 'Windmill'

The National Golf Links of America in Tuckahoe has disassembled its iconic hilltop windmill to ... by Michael Wright

'You Are the Present': Pope Leo XIV’s Message Resonates With Local Catholic Youth

On Friday, November 21, seventh and eighth grade students at Our Lady of the Hamptons ... by Cailin Riley

More Than Prayer: Cantorial Concert Promises Emotion, Classics and Modern Israeli Music

​It’s a tradition 30 years strong. On Saturday, November 29, at 8 p.m., the Hampton ... by Cailin Riley

Westhampton Ambulance Volunteer Water Rescue Squad Set To Host Second Annual Ice Plunge at Rogers Beach

The Westhampton Ambulance Volunteer Water Rescue Squad will host its second annual “Ice Plunge” fundraiser at Rogers Beach in Westhampton Beach on Saturday, December 20, at 12:30 p.m., with check-in starting at noon. Founded in 2022, the squad is a team of certified ocean lifeguards who volunteer their time and are on-call to respond to water emergencies in the area on a year-round basis. Its mission is to “provide an added layer of safety and support to the local communities surrounded by water.” It serves the communities of Eastport, Speonk, Remsenburg, Westhampton, Westhampton Beach, Quiogue, Quogue and Westhampton Dunes, and ... by Cailin Riley

Walgreens Will Move Into Hampton Bays at Former Home of Rite Aid

For Hampton Bays residents who’ve had to endure long lines or making longer drives to have their prescriptions filled, there’s good news. Walgreens is set to take over the space formerly occupied by Rite Aid in Hampton Bays. Southampton Town Supervisor Maria Moore made that announcement at a recent Express Sessions event held at Cowfish in Hampton Bays on November 20. When the Hampton Bays Rite Aid closed for good on June 24 of this year, it left Southampton Town’s most populous hamlet without a major retail pharmacy. For months, the Stop & Shop pharmacy has been the only game ... 22 Nov 2025 by Cailin Riley

WATCH: Local Matters: Hampton Bays | The Express Sessions

The Express News Group presented an Express Sessions panel focused on Hampton Bays and the ... by Staff Writer

Demetrice Lenora Brumsey of Ridge Dies November 19

Demetrice Lenora Brumsey of Ridge died on November 19 in Bayshore. She was 52. A visitation will take place Saturday, November 29, from 10-11 a.m., with a home-going service 11 a.m. at Riverhead Church of Christ. Interment will follow at Southampton Cemetery. Arrangements by the Brockett Funeral Home in Southampton. by Staff Writer

Freedom Experiment

There seems to be no end to the rationalizations for excusing the mass invasion of foreign nationals who crossed our borders without any authority to do so. Amy Paradise [“Define the Problem,” Letters, November 20] listed excuses why we should be sympathetic to their plight: economic opportunity; authoritarian, repressive governments; climate change; exposure via the internet to better situations; drug smuggling; U.S. business welcomes their cheap labor; and our historically benevolent history of welcoming them. Each one, it could be argued, serves our better angels, but Americans seem to discount the cost to scrub each case. Many stand on corners, ... by Staff Writer