MacPherson Gets 4 To 12 Years For Role In Mortgage Fraud Case - 27 East
logo logo logo logo

Southampton Press / Community / 1608465

MacPherson Gets 4 To 12 Years For Role In Mortgage Fraud Case

icon 2 Photos
Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

Donald MacPherson

By Erin McKinley on Feb 27, 2012

Donald MacPherson was sentenced to four to 12 years in prison Monday morning, having pleaded guilty late last year to multiple felony charges related to an $82 million mortgage fraud scheme targeting the East End that involved former Suffolk County Legislator George O. Guldi.

Mr. MacPherson, 68, also was ordered by Suffolk County Court Judge James F.X. Doyle to pay back $44 million to the lending institutions that he cheated as part of the scam, according to Robert Clifford, a spokesman for Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota. Mr. MacPherson was ordered to pay back the money as part of 34 restitution judgment orders.

“J.P. Morgan Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo and other lenders were swindled by this defendant and his associates who arranged for the filing of mortgage applications that were filled with fraud, specifically false employer information supplied to straw purchasers, forged notary signatures, and falsified powers of attorney and fictional bank balances,” Mr. Spota said in a prepared statement.

“Every one of these mortgages for some 60 homes ended up in default,” he continued. “The defendants’ greed inflicted massive economic damage to the banking industry and the regional economy.”

Mr. MacPherson, the former owner of Magic’s Pub in Westhampton Beach, pleaded guilty in November to 45 felonies, including grand larceny, insurance fraud, possession of a forged instrument and scheme to defraud. Over the summer, Mr. MacPherson, who has homes in both Westhampton Beach and Manhattan, rejected a plea bargain in which he would have served between 28 months and seven years in prison for his role in the crime.

Following his sentencing on Monday, Mr. MacPherson was remanded to the Suffolk County Jail in Riverside. He will eventually be transferred to a prison in upstate New York.

Mr. MacPherson’s wife, Carrie Coakley, pleaded guilty in December to two felony counts of grand larceny and fraud for her role in the scheme. She is expected to be sentenced next Thursday, March 8, pending the completion of a Suffolk County Department or Probation pre-sentencing report.

Mr. Guldi, a Democrat and longtime county legislator, was also a co-defendant in the mortgage fraud case and was sentenced to one to three years in prison last year for his role. That sentence will run concurrently with a four- to 12-year sentence he received last March for an unrelated insurance fraud case in which he was found guilty of misusing insurance funds after a fire gutted his family home in Westhampton Beach.

Related Stories

You May Also Like:

An Awful Noise

People who don’t know, ask: What is that awful noise? And then it stops. A different tree now gradually comes alive; the leaves nearly vibrate as the buzzing builds. The sound of an individual cicada is, of course, not an awful noise — it’s just loud, and the pitch is not designed to attract the human ear. The loud things we generally live with are human sounds: parties, lawnmowers, farm equipment. Yesterday, while harvesting tomatoes in the middle of a 50-acre field, I could hear, in the distance, the distinctive crunch of a house being demolished. But, other times, what ... 16 Sep 2025 by Marilee Foster

Saving the Waterfront

A little over 50 years ago, the Suffolk County Farmland Preservation Program was launched, based on a first-in-the nation concept of sale of “development rights.” Then-Suffolk County Executive John V.N. Klein was pivotal, in 1974, to the inception of that program. This month, the Suffolk County Legislature unanimously passed the Conservation of Working Waterfronts bill, with the current county executive, Ed Romaine, playing a critical role, too. It also involves future development. For centuries, farming and fishing have been at the economic foundation of Suffolk County. Great strides have been made in preserving farming in Suffolk — and keeping Suffolk ... by Karl Grossman

Captain Courageous

Because of a bevy of other headlines, somewhat overlooked earlier this month was the 80th anniversary of the end of World War II. The signing ceremony aboard the USS Missouri on September 2, 1945, was a formality, because the war essentially ended two weeks earlier, when Emperor Hirohito told his people that Japan was giving up. That allowed the Allies to begin liberating the POW camps containing thousands of inmates. A particularly brutal one was Omori, on the outskirts of Tokyo. The following is an excerpt from toward the end of “Running Deep,” which will be published next month. On ... by Tom Clavin

Community News, September 18

YOUTH CORNER Read and Play The John Jermain Memorial Library, 201 Main Street in Sag ... 15 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

School News, September 18, Southampton Town

As Hampton Bays educators prepared their classrooms for the first day of school, they also ... by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Museum's Fall Fundraiser Is at The Bridge

The Bridgehampton Museum will host its fall fundraiser, Cocktails at the Bridge, on Saturday, October 4, from 5 to 7 p.m. at The Bridge golf club in Bridgehampton. This year’s event will honor two longtime museum supporters: past president Gerrit Vreeland and former board member John Millard. According to a press release, their vision, leadership, and perseverance were instrumental in the acquisition and restoration of the Nathaniel Rogers House, the historic landmark that now anchors the east end of Main Street in Bridgehampton. Along with the rest of the board at the time, Vreeland and Millard raised much of the ... by Staff Writer

Sponsorships Available for Golf Outing at Sebonack

The Suffolk Community College Foundation will host its 41st Annual Golf Classic on Monday, October 20, at Sebonack Golf Club in Southampton. While the event is sold out, a limited number of sponsorship opportunities are still available. Proceeds from the Golf Classic will benefit student scholarships and academic programs at Suffolk County Community College. This year’s honoree is Ryan T. Kesner, principal of Ryan T. Kesner Architect PC, a leading architectural firm based in Southampton. A proud alumnus of Suffolk County Community College, Kesner has played a pivotal role in shaping Long Island’s architectural landscape, with more than one million ... by Staff Writer

Big Trucks Coming To CMEE

It’s Big Truck Day at the Children’s Museum of the East End on Saturday, September 27, from 10 a.m. to 12 p.m. The event is targeted for families with children ages 2 to 10 who will have the opportunity to explore and interact with some of the trucks. Tickets are $5 for members and $25 for nonmembers. To register, visit cmee.org. by Staff Writer

Scrap Metal Drive Coming to WHB

Westhampton Presbyterian Church will host a scrap metal drive on Saturday, September 27, from 9 a.m. to 2 p.m. Community members are encouraged to drop off all types of metal — including steel, copper, aluminum, and old appliances — at the church, located at 90 Meeting House Road. For more information, please call 631-288-2576. by Staff Writer

Town To Host Disability Resource Fair in November

The Southampton Town Disability Task Force will host its second annual Disability Services Resource Fair on Saturday, November 1, from noon to 3 p.m. at the Hampton Bays Community Center, located at 25 Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays. This inclusive community event is open to all and aims to connect individuals and families with valuable resources, service providers, advocates, and support groups. Throughout the afternoon, attendees will have the opportunity to explore a variety of informational booths, speak directly with representatives from both state and local organizations, and learn more about services available to people with disabilities. Highlights of the ... by Staff Writer