Guldi To Appear In Court September 13 For Ruling On Prosecution's Appeal - 27 East

Guldi To Appear In Court September 13 For Ruling On Prosecution's Appeal

authorKate Riga on Sep 6, 2017

Former Suffolk County Legislator George Guldi will return to Suffolk County Court in Riverhead on September 13 to determine whether he will remain free, return to custody or face a new trial.

Prosecutors have appealed the court’s decision on July 12 to overturn Mr. Guldi’s March 2011 conviction on felony grand larceny and insurance fraud charges, due to the presence of a possibly biased juror. The decision resulted in his release from prison.

Mr. Guldi will appear before State Supreme Court Justice Mark Cohen after eight weeks of freedom, the most he’s had since his imprisonment in 2011. He spent the time living at a cousin’s house in Suffolk County, according to prosecutors.

If the prosecution’s appeal is denied on Wednesday, September 13—meaning his conviction would remain overturned by the higher court—Mr. Guldi could be re-arraigned on the two felony counts and face a new trial, according to previous statements of intent from Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas Spota’s office.

However, the D.A.’s office also could opt not to re-try Mr. Guldi if the appeal is denied, due to the passage of years since he was originally convicted and the length of the sentence he has already served—six and a half years of a four-to-12-year sentence at Marcy Correctional Facility in upstate New York.

If the prosecution’s appeal is upheld and the original conviction affirmed, Mr. Guldi likely will go back to jail for an undetermined length of time.

“All I/we can say is that we are waiting to hear if the Court of Appeals will be granting leave to hear the case,” his attorney, Michael Scotto, said in an email on Wednesday.

Robert Clifford, a spokesman for the D.A.’s office, declined to comment.

In the March 2011 conviction that was overturned, Mr. Guldi had been found guilty of misappropriating more than $860,000 in insurance money that was supposed to be used to rebuild his home on Griffing Avenue in Westhampton Beach after a fire.

The conviction was thrown out after Mr. Guldi’s appeal was upheld; the appeal stated that despite his pre-trial challenge, one of the jurors who remained on the case was an employee for the American International Insurance Company, or AIG, the company that supplied the funds Mr. Guldi was supposed to use to rebuild his home.

He submitted another appeal at the time, attempting to have nearly three dozen counts of intent to fraud and grand larceny dismissed on the same grounds. But the appellate court denied his motion, stating that he had waived his right to appeal those charges when he accepted a plea deal while being prosecuted on a separate $82 million mortgage fraud scheme that targeted dozens of homes, most on the East End.

Mr. Guldi has also already served the maximum three-year sentence for the mortgage fraud conviction concurrently with the four-to-12-year sentence for the March 2011 insurance fraud that is the subject of the pending judgment.

You May Also Like:

A Leadership Pipeline

There’ll be a question for voters on the election ballot in November on whether the terms should be extended, from the present two years to four, for the 18 members of the Suffolk County Legislature, of which most of the major government officials in Suffolk County in the last five decades have been members. One was Republican John V. N. Klein of Smithtown, the first presiding officer of the legislature. He brought continuity between it and the centuries-old Suffolk County Board of Supervisors when the legislature replaced the board in 1970 as the county’s governing body. It was determined in ... 9 Sep 2025 by Karl Grossman

Not Over Yet

A heron departing the wetlands flies up and across the morning sun. With each wingbeat it grows closer to silhouette: white, then silver, then black. Then the bird has risen directly into the sun’s path, and you must drop your watch of this or be blinded. You close your eyes to recover. September — they say summer is over. That position does not give summer much credit. How could she just end? Something so vibrant and desirably warm, the season of fruit, green grass and fresh vegetables, does not die in a day. September is the culmination of summer, the ... by Marilee Foster

Does the New York City Mayor’s Race Matter Here?

2025 is what political pundits call an “off-year” election: There is no election for president or governor. It is the most local of the four-year election cycle, with only local town and county races on the ballot. Yet, just 100 miles to our west is a high-profile election to choose the next mayor of New York. It has drawn national attention since an unknown state assemblyman turned the political world upside down by winning the Democratic primary. His name is Zohran Mamdani. Why was this a political earthquake? Well, first of all, he is an avowed Democratic Socialist who, just ... 8 Sep 2025 by FRED THIELE

Community News, September 11

YOUTH CORNER Circle of Fun The John Jermain Memorial Library, 201 Main Street in Sag ... by Staff Writer

Rescue Center's Resident Groundhog Dies

The staff at the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center is mourning the loss of a ... by Staff Writer

The Church Open House for Educators Set for Next Month

On Thursday, October 23, from 5 to 7 p.m., The Church in Sag Harbor will welcome East End educators and school leaders for a special Open House dedicated to expanding arts enrichment in local schools. This free event is an opportunity to learn about existing arts programming available to students and schools, as well as details on how to apply for The Church’s new Arts, Creativity, and Education Pilot Program for the 2025–26 school year. Through this initiative, five selected applicants will receive a $5,000 budget each to support a yearlong arts education partnership with The Church. Throughout the evening, ... by Staff Writer

Lighthouse Project Returns to Sag Harbor Cinema

Sag Harbor Cinema continues its commitment to mental health awareness through The Lighthouse Project, a year-round film and discussion series designed to spark meaningful conversations within the community. On Sunday, September 14, at 11 a.m. the series returns with a free public event focusing on a topic that resonates deeply with many families: adolescent anxiety in the age of social media. The morning will begin with a screening of two films that examine the emotional landscape of today’s teenagers. The first is Bo Burnham’s critically acclaimed 2018 feature, “Eighth Grade,” which follows a 13-year-old girl as she navigates the last ... by Staff Writer

The Retreat Golf Outing at Noyac on September 22

Supporters of The Retreat will tee off for a meaningful cause on Monday, September 22, during the organization’s annual Golf Outing at the Noyac Golf Club in Sag Harbor. The day begins at 11 a.m. with registration and a relaxed lunch before players head out for a noon shotgun start on the stunning 144-acre course. Designed by Ross Forbes, the club offers a scenic and challenging layout of rolling parkland that promises an enjoyable experience for golfers of all skill levels. After the tournament, guests will gather at the clubhouse for an evening of celebration, featuring cocktails and appetizers, followed ... by Staff Writer

'Boathouse Bash' Will Benefit North Sea Maritime Center

The North Sea Maritime Center invites the community to celebrate and support local maritime heritage at its first-ever Boathouse Bash on Saturday, September 27, from 6 to 9 p.m. Held at a private residence in Water Mill, the evening will raise funds for the restoration of the historic Tupper Boathouse — a key piece of East End waterfront history. Guests will enjoy live music by The Surfcasters and a curated menu featuring crowd favorites like lobster rolls, sliders, burrata, tuna tartare, and mini desserts. The event will also feature an art and gold auction, offering attendees a chance to bid ... by Staff Writer

Town Grants Avaialble for Nonprofits Offering Some Services

The Town of Southampton is now accepting applications for its 2026 Community Service Grants, offering financial support to certified 501(c) nonprofit organizations that provide essential services to residents across the town. These grants are available in several key areas, including human services, cultural arts and recreation, hamlet services, and community programs. Human services grants are designed to assist organizations that offer social and financial support, such as counseling, psychotherapy, health care, childcare, and educational programs. Cultural arts and recreation grants help groups that present visual and performing arts or organize recreational activities. Hamlet services grants target organizations providing services directly ... by Staff Writer