A brilliant Fifth of July" at Bay Street Theatre" - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1371704

A brilliant Fifth of July" at Bay Street Theatre"

icon 1 Photo

author on Jul 13, 2010

There is an abundance of brilliance on stage at Bay Street Theatre in the current, inspired production of Lanford Wilson’s 1978 “Fifth of July,” the second play from Mr. Wilson’s pen but third chronological episode in his Talley family trilogy.

The first brilliance is in dynamic evidence even before the house lights go down and the first line of dialogue is spoken: Paul Gallo’s complex, embracing, detailed and moody set design tells the history of the Talley clan without words and then works as both a silent commentator on and facilitator of the fiery plot that unfolds.

The second is the multifaceted, driving direction by Chicago’s Steppenwolf Theatre co-founder Terry Kinney. The forward motion of the play never falters for a second, and its unspoken undercurrents, the action beneath the action, is palpably there every moment. It’s a masterpiece of digging into and exploring every facet of a playwright’s prose and purpose and form, and it’s downright dazzling.

And the third brilliance is the play itself, proof of Lanford Wilson’s place in theater literature as not a good but a great playwright, one who captures fascinating characters in full, exterior and interior length and depth, and moves them in an uninterrupted arc through constantly varying and revelatory relationships. Set just after the Vietnam War and its protests and terrible aftermaths, it just as well could be taking place today. It has that sort of universality at its core.

It’s a play with more than a heart. Through the angst and the anger, the revelations and retributions of the Talley family, a collective soul is gradually revealed, and it reaches its final, clear voice in the moving closing moments of the play.

There’s such a uniformity of brilliant acting in this production that separation seems a sin. But each character is so clearly defined by this outstanding cast, there is room for some individualizing.

Thanks to the playwright, Kally Duling’s first 15 minutes on stage as the young in age and spirit Shirley Talley mark her as a borderline crazy teenager, and her extended screeching cuts like a knife. But this is fleeting, and as the play deepens, so does she, until she becomes downright embraceable.

Danny Deferrari, likewise, seems like a terminally oddball, motormouthed rock musician in the early moments, but as time progresses his characterization of Weston Hurley, the important musical presence in the business of John and Gwen Landis, grows in stature and statement.

As the stolid in the present but wild in the past June Talley, Kellie Overbey is riveting and pivotal. It’s a quiet, absorbing, immensely satisfying performance.

David Wilson Barnes is a dynamic and driving presence as John Landis, the husband of Gwen Talley Landis, and his strength and impetuousness results in the most tragic and shocking event of the play.

As the wildly successful and wildly behaving Gwen Landis, Jennifer Mudge is a constantly sexy, overbearing yet lovable singer and tycoon who is still a complete Talley no matter how far from the nest she progresses.

Shane McRae, as Jed Jenkins, Kenneth Talley’s lover and a man who is transforming the Talley estate into a botanical showplace, conveys a quiet and enormously effective, anchoring strength in the swirling events of two days in July in Lebanon, Missouri.

Fulfilling and extending her incandescent, Tony winning portrayal of Linda Loman in the 1999 Broadway revival of “Death of a Salesman,” Elizabeth Franz gives a moving, quietly powerful portrait of Sally Talley Friedman, the present cornerstone of the Talley family, whose courtship and marriage with Matt Friedman is the subject of “Talley’s Folly,” Mr. Wilson’s Pulitzer Prize winner, and the reason for the “Fifth of July” gathering of the Talleys.

With serene sturdiness and tenacity, she navigates the roiled waters of the meeting of the Talley clan, and makes of the navigation yet another spellbinding theatrical experience.

Anson Mount delivers a varied, nuanced and sensitive portrayal of the crippled war veteran Kenneth Talley Jr. A furiously conflicted and tortured soul, this character motivates and measures the events and the eventual maturation of the two-day holiday of the Talley family. And Mr. Mount conveys this with quiet and sustained control and power.

Davie Weiner’s sensitive lighting design enhances and empowers the production, and Sarah J. Holden’s costume design is at once arresting and daring, and thoroughly character revealing.

Lanford Wilson’s masterly “Fifth of July” could have no better showcase than the one it’s currently being given at Bay Street Theatre in Sag Harbor. Don’t for heaven’s and your sake let it pass you by.

Peformances of “Fifth of July” are every night but Monday and in Wednesday and Saturday matinees through August 1. Visit baystreet.org or call 725-9500.

You May Also Like:

Four Artists Show at the Water Mill Museum

“Untitled,” a group exhibition featuring the work of four local artists — Adam Bundy, Mary ... 22 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

'Through Her Lens: A Place in Time' at Bridgehampton Museum

Pingree W. Louchheim was the staff photographer, photo editor and darkroom superintendent for The Southampton Press from 1972–1997. During this time, she photographed every aspect of community life, from the mundane and ordinary to pivotal events in Southampton’s history. Now, the photographic work of Louchheim is going on view in “Through Her Lens: A Place in Time,” an exhibition running at the Bridgehampton Museum’s Nathaniel Rogers House from Saturday, July 12, through Saturday, August 16. The show opens with a reception on Friday, July 11, from 5 to 7 p.m. Louchheim’s regular beat included small-town life: Southampton Town Hall, school ... 21 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

The Art of Collecting With Christine Mack at SAC

The Christine Mack Art Collection will take center stage in “Beyond the Present: Collecting for the Future at SAC,” an exhibition that will be on view at Southampton Arts Center from July 26, through September 27. A collector of emerging artists, Mack has built her dynamic collection by seeking out, meeting with, collecting and supporting young voices of our times. Her mission is to collect and holistically nurture these talents through the Mack Art Foundation Artist Residency. Following in the footsteps of her mother-in-law, Phyllis Mack, Christine Mack has forged her path in collecting young American and international talent. This ... by Staff Writer

Round and About for June 19, 2025

Music & Nightlife Mysteries, Deceptions and Illusions Allan Zola Kronzek, a sleight-of-hand artist, will perform ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Interview: Ophira Eisenberg, Host of 'Ask Me Another' and 'Parenting Is a Joke,' Will Perform Saturday at Bay Street Theater

Stand-up comedian Ophira Eisenberg, the host of NPR’s trivia and puzzle show “Ask Me Another” ... 16 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

To Be a Stranger: Whitney White Explores Identity, Migration in New Musical

Born and raised in Chicago, Whitney White took her very first trip abroad to Paris ... by Michelle Trauring

Jazz Loft at Southampton Show To Pay Tribute to Long Island Jazz Legends at Juneteenth Concert

The “Jazz Loft @ Southampton Concert Series” continues with the “Long Island Jazz Legends & ... by Dan Stark

Author Talk at LongHouse Reserve on Gala Dali

On Sunday, June 29, at 4:30 p.m., author Michèle Gerber Klein presents an author talk and book signing at LongHouse Reserve about her book “Surreal: The Extraordinary Life of Gala Dalí.” Gerber Klein’s second book, “Surreal,” the long-awaited, definitive biography of Gala Dalí unmasks this famous, yet little-known, queen of the 20th-century art world, who graced the canvases, inspired the poetry, and influenced the careers of her illustrious lovers and husbands with courage, agency and tenderness. Using previously undiscovered material, “Surreal” tells the riveting story of Gala Dalí, (1894-1982) who broke away from her cultured, but penurious, background in prerevolutionary ... by Staff Writer

'Upside Down Zebra 'at the Watermill Center

This summer, The Watermill Center will present “Upside Down Zebra,” an exhibition exploring the artistic ... by Staff Writer

'An Evening With Betty Buckley & Christian Jacob' Kicks Off Music Mondays at Bay Street Theater

Bay Street Theater opens its 2025 Music Mondays series with legendary Tony Award-winning stage and screen actress Betty Buckley, who will be joined by celebrated jazz pianist Christian Jacob, for a concert on Monday, June 30, at 8 p.m. Buckley’s Bay Street show will be her only appearance on the East End this summer. Hailed as the “Voice of Broadway,” Buckley is a master storyteller whose performances blur the line between song and scene. Joined by the extraordinary Christian Jacob — nine-time Grammy nominee and a pianist of rare emotional clarity — this intimate concert promises a night of depth, ... by Staff Writer