Found 'Pollock' Painting Raises More Questions Than Answers - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1346822

Found ‘Pollock’ Painting Raises More Questions Than Answers

icon 3 Photos

author on Mar 31, 2015

He’s considered by many to have been the leading force behind the abstract expressionist movement in the art world. A longtime Springs resident—in the house that now stands as the Pollock-Krasner House & Study Center—Jackson Pollock is, to aficionados, a national treasure.His life was marked by controversy—and, not surprisingly, drama continues to encircle his art.

The recent discovery of a possible Pollock painting in San Diego has sparked debate, while raising the question of whether a masterpiece can ever be authenticated to the art world’s satisfaction.

Mark Palmer of the John Webber Agency in California said the owners of the painting, who choose to remain anonymous, have conducted an extensive authentication of the painting. But some of those processes have come into question by skeptics who doubt their accuracy.

Then again, to the naked eye, the piece certainly looks like a Pollock. And, if it’s real, it could be one of only a little more than 100 Pollocks in the world—and worth upward of $160 million.

“[David] Geffen sold a Pollock a few years ago for $120 million,” Mr. Palmer said. “The price is whatever people will pay for it. This could well be worth $140 [million] or $160 [million]. What’s $20 million between friends?”

According to Mr. Palmer, the circa-1947, drip art-style, 54-inch-by-36-inch canvas was tested in a number of ways—forensic and otherwise. Part of the process inclu-

ed examining its provenance, a partial fingerprint and the signature, as well as human hair, cigarette tobacco and microscopic birch leaf particles found in the painting—the same trees that grow on the studio grounds. Additional scientific testing included biological-image analysis, style comparison and technique comparison.

While the fingerprint was not tested by fingerprint analysts, and the signature was not examined by handwriting experts, Mr. Palmer claimed he has determined provenance. It was donated to an East Village thrift store, he said, and then passed hands from one collector to another, before his clients scooped it up.

Two art experts, Richard David Moore and Joan E. Kellen, have endorsed the authenticity of the painting after visiting the Pollock-Krasner House and laying the canvas on the floor, comparing the splattered paint and the back of the canvas. According to them, they matched.

Mr. Palmer also cites WNDCHRM technology—proprietary software that is capable of identifying Pollocks. Lior Shamir, the creator of the software, however, has voiced his objections with the way the testing was conducted, as color was not factored in. Fractal analysis, in general, when used to authenticate Pollocks, has been widely debated by both art experts and physicists.

Mr. Moore and Ms. Kellen have said they were paid by the painting’s owners. And though they concluded the painting is, indeed, a Pollock, there are skeptics.

“There are many, many purported Pollocks that are being offered on the market that have no known provenance, no known connection between them and Pollock,” according to Helen Harrison, director of the Pollock-Krasner House & Study Center, though she declined to comment on this specific piece. “People would like to discover a major painting worth millions. As far as I know, none have turned up.”

Over the last decade, there have been other dubious cases.

In 2003, filmmaker Alex Matter—whose parents lived nearby and were friendly with Pollock and his wife, Lee Krasner—found 32 potential Pollocks in a storage locker in Wainscott. Despite the favorable provenance, and extensive testing and corroboration of these paintings, there still remains doubt—due primarily to the fact that the pigments used were not available during Pollock’s lifetime.

In 2007, a documentary called “Who the #$&% Is Jackson Pollock?” profiled Teri Horton, a 73-year-old former long-haul truck driver who bought a purported Pollock at a thrift shop for $5, and spent a decade trying to get it authenticated. While her case hinged on a fingerprint match on the painting and in Pollock’s studio, the jury is still out.

Mr. Palmer said the doubts surrounding the authenticity of this particular painting, and perhaps others, is in the mindset of Pollock collectors. “It’s a very elitist club of very rich people,” he said. “There is tremendous resistance to others joining the club. They don’t want an upstart, or someone with a single Pollock, intruding. There’s probably 100 out there,” he continued. “Some are probably genuine. But it’s a rather exclusive club. People who own Pollocks don’t want other Pollocks appearing.”

Pollock and Krasner, an artist in her own right, lived and worked on the East End from 1945 until his death on August 11, 1956. Krasner was in Paris when Pollock sped around a turn on Springs-Fireplace Road and hit a birch tree, tossing his passengers—his mistress, Ruth Kligman, and her friend Edith Metzger—from the car. Ms. Kligman was the only survivor.

Pollock’s work has only grown in popularity and value. To date, Mr. Palmer said the painting’s owners have received “a couple of offers, and Christie’s is looking at it.”

You May Also Like:

Tom Clavin Discusses ‘Tombstone,’ His Latest Book About The Wild West

Tom Clavin’s most recent book, “Tombstone: The Earp Brothers, Doc Holliday & the Vendetta Ride ... 27 May 2020 by Staff Writer

The Bats Have Come Home To Roost

Tucked in the woods off a quiet road in Sagaponack lies Sagg Swamp, a hidden ... 26 May 2020 by Annette Hinkle

Southampton Hospital’s Gala Is In Your Garden This Year

The Southampton Hospital Foundation, (SHF), host of the Stony Brook Southampton Hospital (SBSH) Annual Summer Party, is delighted to announce the 2020, 62ndgala will go ahead, in a new, reimaged format. Due to the novel coronavirus pandemic, the gala, one of the biggest and longest running fundraisers in the Hamptons, will not take place in its usual spot on the fields of Wickapogue Road. Instead, the theme will be “Gala in Your Garden,” with the SHF bringing the party to private homes. The date of the gala will be Saturday, August 1. Working creatively with the local restaurant and florist ... 23 May 2020 by Staff Writer

HTC Productions Moved to Next Season

Due to the extension of Governor Cuomo’s Pause restrictions for Suffolk County, and out of ... by Staff Writer

A Call For Artwork For Long Island Biennial

The Heckscher Museum of Art is now accepting entries for the 2020 Long Island Biennial, a juried exhibition featuring works by visual artists from Suffolk and Nassau counties. The Biennial reflects the area’s thriving art scene by featuring artists representing a considerable number of communities throughout Long Island. The exhibition offers emerging and established artists the opportunity to gain broader public awareness of their work. Inaugurated in 2010, this 10-year anniversary of the Long Island Biennial coincides with The Heckscher Museum’s centennial. In honor of this milestone, this year’s Biennial exhibition, which will open in the fall with exact dates ... by Staff Writer

‘Very Semi-Serious’ Joins DocFest Online

The newest online “Fest Favorite” documentary offering from Hamptons DocFest was the 2015 film “Very Semi-Serious” which was added to the website on Wednesday, May 27. Directed by Leah Wolchok, the film is an offbeat and humorous behind-the-scenes look at New Yorker Magazine as cartooning hopefuls, like graphic novelist Liana Finck and legends Roz Chast and Mort Gerberg submit their work to Cartoon Editor Bob Mankoff. The film won a 2016 Emmy Award for Outstanding Arts & Culture Programming. Films still available via the website, most with Q&As from the directors’ appearances at the film festival in previous years, are, ... by Staff Writer

It’s A Script Writing Competition

The North Fork TV Festival announces the second annual Alfred P. Sloan Science + Tech Pilot Script Competition, which aims to encourage screenwriters to create more realistic and compelling stories about science and technology and to challenge existing stereotypes about scientists and engineers in the popular imagination. Writers are invited to submit pilot scripts for a television series rooted in science and technology. The panel of independent judges includes accomplished television professionals as well as noted scientists and technologists. In evaluating scripts, they will prioritize unique, character-driven material ending with a cliffhanger or twist that invites a series. Award-winning director ... by Staff Writer

Terrie Sultan Will Step Down As Director Of The Parrish Art Museum At The End Of June

Parrish Art Museum Director Terrie Sultan is stepping down from her post of 12 years ... 21 May 2020 by Staff Writer

Put On Your PJs And Round Up The Kids – The Drive-In Movie Is Coming To Southampton For Memorial Day Weekend

UPDATE: Due to expected inclement weather on May 23, this event will take place on ... 20 May 2020 by Annette Hinkle

Artists Find Themselves Inspired In Times of COVID

Kara Hoblin creates art to heal. She creates it to connect. And it was with ... 19 May 2020 by Michelle Trauring

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported