Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1344233

Kathleen Madigan: Not Your Average Bartender

icon 1 Photo

authorJack Sullivan on Aug 11, 2015

From tending bar to entertaining millions on Netflix and HBO, Kathleen Madigan has earned her spot in the comedy world, bringing her Irish candor and quick wit to every performance.

The Southampton Press caught up with the comedian before she takes the stage at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor on Monday night.

The Press: How did you first get involved in comedy and when did you know you first wanted make a career out of it?

Kathleen Madigan: I just went to an open mic night in St. Louis for fun one night. I worked at the bar next door, and we went over there instead. Me and this other bartender, Mike, did open mic nights for fun. It just sounded like something fun to do. I didn’t plan on being a comedian.

It was sort of like a goof-off thing. I bartended, which was the same thing, almost, you just poured drinks, too.

The Press: Do you have a writing process?

Madigan: Stuff just happens and I write it on a bar napkin. If you found my purse, you’d think that I was a crazy person. There’s a word on there, like “Amish” or “Flight 370.” Things either happen, or I think of things and then write down the word and remember them later. I am capable [of writing], but I don’t like to do it. I am friends with Lewis Black, and Lew writes books. And I call it writing jail because you’re all alone. I would go crazy. I need to be out doing stuff and around people and see what’s going on. I really don’t love the general public, but I miss them if I’m not around them.

The Press: Who are some comedians who you find particularly inspiring or funny?

Madigan: Lewis Black makes me laugh. Ron White, Daniel Cash, kind of the usual suspects. Jim Gaffigan always makes me laugh. There’s a ton of people. I gotta say, considering all the comedians there actually are who can do an hour and actually get paid for it, I like 70 percent of them. I would pay to go see them. There are only a few who I don’t particularly get, but it’s like music. I don’t really listen to country music, but clearly it’s a popular genre.

The Press: How do you prepare for a show?

Madigan: It’s all in my head. People think, “How can you remember that?” I always say, “If I gave you one sentence to remember, and then next week I said a new one, you could do that. It’s a slow build, but you know it because you do it every night. You just keep adding and adding. I have chunks, and other times if I look at my napkins, I say, “Ok right, right.” It’s a free flowing structure, but there’s no real order.

It’s also depending on where I am, if I’m in the south or someplace offbeat. Eugene, Oregon, is a strange place. There, I start with that. It’s usually just about stuff that I noticed around the area. Oregon is a very strange place. They know they’re weird. The slogan in Portland is, “Keep it weird.” Well, job well done, because it’s just weird.

The Press: Do you know what you’ll talk about during your Sag Harbor performance?

Madigan: I honestly haven't thought about it yet. I'll think about it, probably that afternoon. Maybe there will be stuff about the Republican debate. I'll probably take a look at my napkins.

Kathleen Madigan will perform on Monday, August 17, at 8 p.m. at Bay Street Theater in Sag Harbor. Tickets start at $69.50. For more information, call (631)-725-9500, or visit baystreet.org.

You May Also Like:

‘World War II Radio Christmas Play’ To Run at Southampton Cultural Center

Boots on the Ground Theater at the Southampton Cultural Center will present Pat Kruis Tellinghusen’s “World War II Radio Christmas Play” from December 5 to 14. Performances are Fridays and Saturdays at 7 p.m. and Sundays at 3 p.m. The holiday production recreates the experience of attending a 1940s radio show broadcast on Christmas Eve during World War II. Featuring songs of the era, stories inspired by real veterans, live sound effects, and a full on-stage radio studio, the play transports audiences to another time. Old-fashioned radio sponsors, jingles, and classic Christmas carols round out the performance, offering a festive ... 12 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Guild Hall's 2025 Student Art Festival, 'Rauschenberg 100,' Celebrates Local Artists, Students, and the Legacy of a Legendary Painter

Guild Hall’s Student Art Festival, an annual tradition since 1938, returns on November 15 with ... 11 Nov 2025 by Hope Hamilton

Round and About for November 13, 2025

Music & Nightlife Mysteries, Deceptions and Illusions Allan Zola Kronzek, a sleight-of-hand artist, will perform ... by Staff Writer

At the Galleries for November 13, 2025

Montauk The Lucore Art, 87 South Euclid Avenue in Montauk, is showing “Moment of Motion,” ... by Staff Writer

Get Ready To Laugh: Long Island Comedy Festival Hits The Suffolk on Thanksgiving Eve

The Long Island Comedy Festival returns to The Suffolk on Thanksgiving Eve to kick off the holiday season with a night of laughs on Wednesday, November 26, at 8 p.m. Now in its 19th season, the Long Island Comedy Festival brings together four of New York’s funniest comedians in one night, hosted by Long Island’s own Paul Anthony. The lineup includes Maria Walsh, known as “America’s Naughtiest Mommy” and a Las Vegas headliner; John Santo, a master impressionist performing at Mohegan Sun; Rob Falcone, a national headliner who has appeared on Showtime and HBO; and Chris Monty, a national headliner ... by Staff Writer

Guild Hall’s Student Art Festival, Rauschenberg 100, Launches This Weekend

Guild Hall’s Student Art Festival, an annual tradition since 1938, returns on November 15 with ... 10 Nov 2025 by Hope Hamilton

BCM Autumn Concerts Continue This Weekend

On Saturday, November 15, at 5 p.m., Bridgehampton Chamber Music will present the second of ... by Staff Writer

Sticks & Stones Comedy To Present All-Star Stand-Up Show Featuring D’yan Forest

Sticks & Stones Comedy will present an “All-Star Stand-Up Comedy Show” featuring Michelle Schwartzman, Rob White, Joe Winchell and the Sticks & Stones All-Star Comedy Lineup on Saturday, November 15, at 8 p.m. at the Southampton Cultural Center. Doors open at 7:30 p.m. Fresh from her sold-out show at Joe’s Pub, special guest and Southampton resident D’yan Forest will join the lineup. Forest holds the Guinness World Records title for the oldest working female comedian in the world at age 89. Often called “the naughty Betty White,” she has appeared on “The Drew Barrymore Show,” Time Out New York, The ... by Staff Writer

Sag Harbor’s Julie Keyes To Jury Newport Art Museum’s Members’ Exhibition

Julie Keyes, a Sag Harbor-based art consultant with more than 30 years of experience in the contemporary art world, will serve as juror for the Newport Art Museum’s “Springboard: Members’ Juried Exhibition,” opening Thursday, January 22, 2026. Keyes is founder and principal of Keyes Art, a global art consultancy, and has worked with private collectors, corporations and cultural institutions to acquire and present significant works of art. She brings a unique perspective as both an advocate for emerging talent and a trusted advisor to established collectors. “‘Springboard’ invites artists to put their best foot forward,” Keyes said. “In conversation with ... by Staff Writer

‘Sea Through River’ Opens at LTV Studios

LTV Studios will present “Sea Through River,” an exhibition curated by Haim Mizrahi, on display now through November 30. The exhibition features works by Anahi DeCanio, Josh Dayton, Michael McDowell, Steve Romm, Lenore Bailey, Haim Mizrahi and Zach Minskoff. An opening reception will be held Saturday, November 15, from 4 to 7 p.m. The public is invited to view the exhibition and meet the artists. LTV Studios is located at 75 Industrial Road in Wainscott. For details, visit ltveh.org. by Staff Writer