Nazi Shadows on Long Island: A Forgotten Front in the War for America - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 2402006

Nazi Shadows on Long Island: A Forgotten Front in the War for America

icon 2 Photos
Christopher C. Verga's book

Christopher C. Verga's book "Nazis of Long Island, Sedition, Espionage & the Plot Against America.”

Author Christopher C. Verga.

Author Christopher C. Verga.

Jeffrey Dumas on Oct 28, 2025

The Second World War, the war to end all wars, ended in 1945, 80 years ago, yet a strange fascination about the Nazis persists, including on eastern Long Island.

Christopher C. Verga, a Bayshore-based historian and teacher of victimology and the politics of terror, is the author of “Nazis of Long Island, Sedition, Espionage & the Plot Against America” (Arcadia Publishing, 176 pps. $24.99). His book details why the Nazis found Long Island to be a valuable target, serving as a base to help spread their ideology and identify collaborators and supporters among the American public. While Long Island served as a launch pad for spies entering the United States as well as a bustling hub of military production and scientific advancement, a youth camp in Yaphank became a thriving breeding ground for furthering Nazi propaganda during World War II, playing a key role in cultivating the so-called American Nazi.

“It can happen again,” said Verga in a telephone interview when asked about the periodic preoccupation with Nazi ideology around the world. “It started with politicians blaming minorities. Rhetoric led to a surge of paramilitary and other like-minded groups.”

Global leaders also played a role in stoking the flames of hyper nationalism, much of which led to World War II.

“This was the time of the rise of dictators like [Benito] Mussolini, [Josip] Tito and [Joseph] Stalin,” Verga said. “They helped to spread a we’re-the-victims cult.”

The German-American Bund was an extremist organization dedicated to raising support for Nazis among German-Americans. Camp Siegfried in Yaphank became Ground Zero for spreading the ideals of an “American Reich” largely among young people with the ultimate goal of having personnel in position to support a fascist overthrow of Washington.

“It was indoctrination through youth camps,” said Verga.

Bund members swore a loyalty oath to German Chancellor Adolf Hitler. Nationwide, there may have been as many as 25,000 U.S.-based, dues-paying Bund members at its peak during the late 1930s. Membership was strongest in the northern and eastern United States. Many historians describe the Nazi-based activities in Yaphank, as one of the greatest hidden threats to war efforts of the United States. As word spread, however, local opposition groups countered the proliferation of Nazi propaganda in and around New York City and Long Island.

The Nazis’ focus on Long Island went beyond spreading ideology, however, as there were also geographic and technical interests. Hundreds of miles of sparsely guarded coastline provided easy landing spots for spies to infiltrate Long Island’s factories or gain entry to New York City via the Long Island Railroad.

“There was a lot of transition taking place on Long Island during the time leading to the Second World War,” said Verga. “It was changing from an agriculture and tourism neighbor of New York City to an industrial area.”

Jutting eastward from New York City, Long Island was home to numerous defense plants largely engaged in various aspects of the aviation industry, a railroad that dependably shipped food, supplies and troops, plus numerous small ports. On its western tip was the Brooklyn Navy Yard, where literally thousands of boats of all sizes were designed, built and launched as part of the war effort. On the eastern tip, a large government facility was built on Fort Pond Bay in Montauk to test torpedoes to be used against German U-boats. Similarly, the New London, Connecticut submarine base and Plum Island-based Fort Terry, which stood guard at the mouth of Long Island Sound, were each only a few nautical miles away.

On the evening of June 13, 1942, a U.S. Coast Guard seamen on patrol in Amagansett happened upon four suspicious-looking men walking on the beach shortly after midnight in violation of the curfew, claiming to be local fishermen who had run aground. It was actually their U-boat which had run aground on a sandbar about 100 yards off the coast. The men had come ashore in a rubber boat with explosives, cash and tools as well as intentions to travel by Long Island Rail Road to New York City to infiltrate the East Coast and sabotage American war efforts. By June 19 they were each taken into custody. The same railroad also delivered thousands of supporters to the gigantic pro-Nazi rally at Madison Square Garden organized by the German American Bund in 1939, an event many today are surprised to learn actually occurred.

“Aviation was widespread on Long Island. There was a lot of groundbreaking innovation taking place in the labs and factories here,” Verga said. “Sperry developed advanced bomb sights for planes and autopilot technology. Many aviation advances were developed on Long Island. The Nazis wanted access to these secrets.”

The P-47 Thunderbolt, nicknamed the “Jug” was a workhorse World War II fighter plane produced by Farmingdale-based Republic Aviation from 1941 through 1945 and ironically was partially designed by Russian refugee-scientists. The Thunderbolt introduced the famous “bubble” canopy as well as “water injection” for increased engine power. Later versions featured a “dorsal fin” for better stability at high altitudes. Technical advancements such as these helped win the war and many of them were created in part or in full on Long Island. Other companies like Columbia Aircraft and Grumman also had a large presence on Long Island; each contributed technical advancements. Grumman produced several Navy fighters, such as the F4F Wildcat and F6F Hellcat, as well as the TBF Avenger torpedo bomber. Columbia, based in Valley Stream, produced the J2F-6 Duck, an amphibious biplane for the Navy.

Mass production, however, required its own “army” of skilled workers, not all of whom were thoroughly vetted.

“They needed a lot of people and it was impossible to thoroughly investigate each one,” Verga said. “Some spies slipped through the cracks. Many also worked as double-agents. It’s hard to estimate how much damage Nazi espionage caused, but spying cost U.S. lives and most spy rings consisted of Bund members.”

On January 3, 1944, the USS Turner, a battleship built in the Brooklyn Navy Yard, suffered a series of mysterious, internal explosions in its ammunitions storage area and sank off Ambrose Light near Rockaway Point, close to New York Harbor. Rescuers pulled 153 sailors from the freezing waters while 139 of the 292-man crew were declared “missing in action.” The tragedy received limited media coverage due to government censorship. In January 1942, a Nazi U-boat sank the British supply tanker Coimra 60 miles off Montauk Point, killing 36. The ship, which was carrying lubricating oil, had departed from Bayonne, New Jersey and was heading for Halifax, Nova Scotia.

While the U-boat terror across the Atlantic was real, crews needed information to know when targets would be available and what type of cargo they would be carrying. U-boats sank hundreds of ships off the East Coast, more than 200 by 1945.

“Things like maps, port timetables and shipping information were very valuable,” Verga said. “During blackout drills, Nazi crews could see U.S. landmarks. Events like the sinking of the Turner, so close to New York City, did more than kill men and destroy material. It hurt morale, made people fearful.”

In his book, Verga also spends considerable time discussing how quickly Nazi infiltrators mastered the U.S. media in order to sway public opinion to their cause. While rallygoers were often met by hostile crowds in New York City as news of their movement spread, the amount of support such groups received from sympathetic organizations that turned a blind eye to their atrocious activities is alarming.

You May Also Like:

Auditions Set for Female Lead in 'I Do! I Do!' at Hampton Theatre Company

The Hampton Theatre Company will hold auditions by appointment for the role of Agnes in the musical “I Do! I Do!” on Monday and Tuesday, November 10 and 11, from 7 to 9 p.m. at Quogue Community Hall, 125 Jessup Avenue, Quogue. Directed by Rosemary Cline with music direction by Dee Laveglia, “I Do! I Do!” is a two-person musical that chronicles the 50-year marriage of Michael and Agnes, from their wedding night in 1898 through to 1948, as they experience the joys, challenges and changes of a shared life. The role of Agnes is a female lead, mezzo-soprano, age ... by Staff Writer

Emma's Revolution Brings Protest and Activism to the UU Stage

For nearly 25 years, Emma’s Revolution, the California-based singing/songwriting duo Pat Humphries and Sandy Opatow ... by Annette Hinkle

All That Brass: REEB! Opens Free Jazz Jam in Southampton

East End Jazz, in collaboration with the Southampton Cultural Center, will present the next installment ... by Staff Writer

Equine Artist Suzanne Nielsen Comes to Bridgehampton

Coco & Cat will host an artist reception for equine painter Suzanne Nielsen on Friday, ... by Staff Writer

Grave Matters: Conversations With a Modern Mortician

What is it about our fears that partly fascinate us? That compelling urge to seek ... by Jennylynn Jankesh

East End Cinema Series To Celebrate Long Island’s Film Legacy

The Southampton Playhouse will present East End Cinema, a new film series running November 4 through November 12, celebrating the East End of Long Island’s rich history in film and the unique stories, people and locations that define the region. From seaside romances to tales of eccentric families in sprawling mansions, the East End has long served as a backdrop for some of cinema’s most memorable moments. East End Cinema aims to honor that legacy while fostering a broader conversation about how the area can continue to attract film productions in the future. The series opens with a special Monday ... by Staff Writer

Spanish-Language ‘Dracula’ Screens at Southampton Playhouse

Southampton Playhouse will present a screening of the 1931 Spanish-Language film “Dracula,” directed by George ... by Staff Writer

Tommy Sullivan ‘A Life in Music: Eighty Years on Earth, Sixty-Eight Onstage’

Join East Hampton Library favorite Tommy Sullivan as he celebrates his 80th birthday with a special 90-minute concert on Saturday, November 1, at 2 p.m. Titled “A Life in Music: Eighty Years on Earth, Sixty-Eight Onstage,” the concert will feature songs from Sullivan’s years with the original Brooklyn Bridge, as well as covers of music by some of his biggest influences — including the Beatles, the Beach Boys, Motown legends and more. Sullivan promises an energy-filled performance that proves age is just a number, with a set full of timeless hits and crowd favorites. The concert is free and open ... 27 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Guild Hall’s 2025 Student Art Festival: ‘Rauschenberg100’

East Hampton’s Guild Hall will present the “2025 Student Art Festival: Rauschenberg100,” on view from Saturday, November 15, through Sunday, January 26. A long-standing tradition on the South Fork, the Guild Hall Student Art Festival celebrates the imagination and artistic achievements of students in kindergarten through grade 12. The exhibition is developed in close collaboration with local schoolteachers, school districts and professional artists. This year’s festival is held in conjunction with “Rauschenberg100,” an international initiative commemorating the centennial of artist Robert Rauschenberg’s birth. Guild Hall will partner eight public schools with 10 East End artists to explore Rauschenberg’s legacy and ... 26 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Guild Hall Welcomes National Theatre Live’s ‘Mrs. Warren’s Profession’

National Theatre Live will broadcast “Mrs. Warren’s Profession,” Bernard Shaw’s classic play, on Friday, November ... by Staff Writer