Sutton Foster brings a few of her ingenue friends for a show at Bay Street Theatre - 27 East

Arts & Living

Arts & Living / 1372088

Sutton Foster brings a few of her ingenue friends for a show at Bay Street Theatre

icon 1 Photo

author on May 25, 2010

It might be tempting for anyone looking at her credits to think of Sutton Foster as some kind of stereotypical ingenue of musical theater.

After all, after starting on Broadway at an early age, she managed to win the ingenue leads in “Thoroughly Modern Millie,” “Little Women,” “The Drowsy Chaperone,” “Shrek, The Musical” and “Young 
Frankenstein”—and win critical acclaim and a slew of awards for her performances.

But Ms. Foster is quite a bit more than the sum of her parts, as theatergoers lucky enough to snag a ticket to her show on Saturday at Bay Street Theatre in Sag Harbor will no doubt be delighted to find out for themselves. In addition to some of her favorite numbers from shows she has done on Broadway, “An Evening with Sutton Foster” will include folk, jazz, musical theater standards and additional selections from her new CD, “Wish.”

And, when the performance portion of the show has concluded, Ms. Foster will reveal more of her many dimensions, joining premium ticket holders at a special after-party event on stage.

As she acknowledged in an e-mail this week, “It’s great to do an evening like this that shows audiences me as a person versus me as a character ... It’s a lot more exposed, but it’s my own expression as an artist.”

Working with music director Michael Rafter, whom she met when she was doing “Thoroughly Modern Millie” in 2001, Ms. Foster, with some writing and directing assistance from Mark Waldrop, put together her first solo show in 2004 as part of the Lincoln Center American Songbook series in New York.

Since that first effort, the three have worked together on creating shows for Joe’s Pub, Feinstein’s and another Lincoln Center show in February that coincided with the release of “Wish.” Her current tour, which has already stopped at more than 10 different cities and includes dates booked through next February, was organized to support the new album, and Ms. Foster has been enjoying every minute.

“It’s been amazing,” she wrote, “to travel and perform this show.”

Part of the fun of doing the show has come from revisiting roles that established her gilt-edged actor-singer-dancer credentials.

“It’s pretty great to revisit a lot of the songs and moments that I had on Broadway, especially characters that I’ll probably never get a chance to play again ... like Millie or Jo from ‘Little Women,’” she wrote, adding that all the characters are getting a little more Sutton Foster than they might have had during the run of the shows. “I am definitely personalizing the songs more in the concert,” she wrote, “bringing more of myself to the foreground, as opposed to jumping from character to character.”

Not that there is anything lacking in the characters she has brought to life on the Broadway stage. She won the 2002 Tony, Drama Desk, Outer Critics Circle and Astaire awards for her work in “Thoroughly Modern Millie,” and has been nominated for Tony, Drama Desk and Outer Critics Circle Awards for her other leads as well, winning the Outer Critics Circle for her portrayal of Princess Fiona in “Shrek: The Musical.”

The reviews for “An Evening with Sutton Foster” and the “Wish” album have been uniformly positive. The show was described by one critic as “charged with emotion and excitement,” and Stephen Holden of The New York Times noted that her songs incorporate “themes of wishfulness, of throwing off cares and dreaming the future into becoming the present.”

She got started on her path to Broadway in a ballet class when she was 4. After moving on to jazz and tap dancing and a role in a community production of “Annie!” as a youngster, she went on, seven years later, to win a slot as the youngest member of the ensemble in “The Will Rogers Follies” on Broadway after answering a dancers call and making it past a callback in New York in front of Tommy Tune and Southampton’s Cy Coleman.

Asked what she would say to a young person who aspires to a Broadway career today, Ms. Foster bluntly cut to the chase in her e-mail: “My first advice is ‘don’t be an asshole.’ Kindness and respect go a long way in this business or any business. I also say, ‘take opportunities ... say


... get hands-on experience ... whether it’s performing, or backstage, or interning, or painting a set. And theatre is


... Go out and get experience wherever you can!’”

“An Evening with Sutton Foster” will be presented for one night only on Saturday, May 29, at 8 p.m. Tickets are $75; premium tickets for the show and post-performance reception with Ms. Foster are $125. For ticket information, call the Bay Street box office at 725-9500, visit, or visit the theater on Long Wharf in Sag Harbor.

You May Also Like:

A ‘Hidden Child’: Erika Hecht Reflects On World War II In New Memoir

On the edge of Sag Harbor Village, Erika Hecht lives in a modest home surrounded ... 22 Jun 2021 by Michelle Trauring

New Project Space Features Ceramics By Rebecca Manson

Fairfax Dorn, principal of Fairfax Dorn Projects (FDP), is currently presenting “An Impulsive Forage,” an exhibition highlighting new work by artist Rebecca Manson in collaboration with Josh Lilley, London, at The Living Room, a project space in East Hampton. The show runs through July 4. It marks Manson’s first U.S. solo exhibition and features ceramic sculptures made in her studio outside New York City. As a master of clay, Manson captures the vulnerabilities of nature. The sculptures on view express the relationship between beauty and decay. She is a graduate of the ceramics department of the Rhode Island School of ... by Staff Writer

G.E. Smith’s ‘Portraits’ Welcomes Telecaster Master Jim Weider

On July 5, G.E. Smith launches his fifth series of “Portraits,” this year for Guild ... by Staff Writer

Market Art + Design Returns For 2021

Market Art + Design, the East End’s premier and longest-running art and design fair, has ... by Staff Writer

Jessica Ambrose Gets Sirius

In early May, SiriusXM Radio announced that “Lunch on the Deck,” a weekly program hosted ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Arts Center Hosts Outdoor Talk With Carl Safina

Conserving nature and tapping into human creativity may not immediately appear to be connected. But ... by Staff Writer

A Trio Of Concerts Curated By Joel Ross For Duck Creek

The Arts Center at Duck Creek will present the first two concerts this weekend in ... by Staff Writer

‘Fish & Men’ Screening And Panel At SAC

As part of its exhibition “EARTH: Artists as Activists,” On Thursday, July 8, at 7:30 ... by Staff Writer

Nelson H. White Retrospective

On Saturday, June 26, the Grenning Gallery in Sag Harbor opens a retrospective exhibition featuring ... by Staff Writer

Guild Hall Is Getting A Make-Over For Its 90th Birthday

Guild Hall, located at 158 Main Street in East Hampton, has launched a $10 million capital campaign, in celebration of its 90th Anniversary (1931-2021), to bring the institution to the next level. As Guild Hall looks to the future, it has engaged the world’s most sought-after minds to match the physical footprint with the caliber of their artistry: Bran Ferren/Applied Minds, Peter Pennoyer Architects, Hollander Design | Landscape Architects, Ben Krupinski Builder, and Jon Maass and Pamela Torres as owner’s reps. At this point, Guild Hall has reached 50 percent of its goal thanks to the support of the Board ... by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend