Three Plays Will Grace Bay Street Theater’s Stage This Summer

Bay Street Theater 2025 Summer Mainstage Season is coming to town, bringing with it stories of love from true to twisted.

The season kicks off with the world premiere of “Bob & Jean: A True Love Story” (May 27 to June 15) by Pulitzer Prize- and Tony Award-winner Robert Schenkkan and directed by Matt August; followed by “Deceived” (June 24 to July 20), a new adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s classic psychological thriller “Gaslight,” directed by Sheryl Kaller; finally, the summer wraps up with “Bonnie & Clyde: The Musical” (July 29 to August 24), a fast-paced musical based on the true story of America’s most infamous criminal couple, directed by Bay Street’s own Scott Schwartz.

“We will explore the nature of love with three vivid productions that will bring our audience close to the heat and deep into the human heart,” said artistic director Scott Schwartz of the new season. "We can’t wait to embark upon one of our most passionate seasons ever, and to share the excitement with the whole East End.”

“Bob & Jean: A True Love Story” by Robert Schenkkan - Directed by Matt August, runs May 27 to June 15

Co-produced with Arizona Theater Company, this brand-new play is the true story of a courtship during World War II between an officer and a USO performer. “Bob & Jean: A True Love Story” is a funny, thoughtful play about finding your way together when you are vast distances apart.

“Deceived” by Johnna Wright and Patty Jamieson, adapted from the play by Patrick Hamilton - Directed by Sheryl Kaller, runs June 24 to July 20

What if your own mind was turning against you? “Deceived,” the new adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s “Gaslight,” is a gripping psychological thriller that will leave you questioning reality itself. As whispers echo through the walls and the gaslights flicker in the darkness, one woman struggles to hold onto the truth — before it slips through her fingers. An electrifying ride, filled with haunting twists. Who will you believe and who can you trust?

“Bonnie & Clyde: The Musical” music by Frank Wildhorn, lyrics by Don Black, book by Ivan Menchell - Directed by Scott Schwartz, runs July 29 to August 24

Passion. Danger. Fame. Bonnie Parker and Clyde Barrow were anything but ordinary. She dreamed of Hollywood, he craved a life beyond the law, and together, they became the most notorious duo of their time. As they race toward fame and infamy, their passion burns as hot and fast as their V8 Ford. “Bonnie & Clyde: The Musical” ignites the stage with the fiery romance of America's infamous young outlaws, blending passionate love with rebellion against the backdrop of the Great Depression. This award-nominated musical, in a bold new production, blends heart-stopping action with steamy romance, dark humor and irresistible charm.

Subscriptions for the 2025 season are now on sale at baystreet.org. Bay Street Theater is on Long Wharf in Sag Harbor.