East Hampton Field Hockey Has Sights Set on Getting Back to Playoffs, County Championship - 27 East

East Hampton Field Hockey Has Sights Set on Getting Back to Playoffs, County Championship

icon 7 Photos

Ava Tintle  MARIANNE BARNETT

Ava Tintle MARIANNE BARNETT

Hailey Welsch  DESIREE KEEGAN

Hailey Welsch DESIREE KEEGAN

Kerri O'Donnell  DESIREE KEEGAN

Kerri O'Donnell DESIREE KEEGAN

Melina Sarlo   DESIREE KEEGAN

Melina Sarlo DESIREE KEEGAN

Drew Budd on Aug 30, 2023

What can the East Hampton field hockey team do as an encore to last season’s Cinderella season?

That’s the big question, not only on the East End, but around Suffolk County. Seeded 11th in the county going into last season, the Bonackers went 10-3-1 to earn the three seed in the Suffolk County Class B playoffs, eventually reaching the county championship for the first time since 2003 — where they lost in overtime to Rocky Point.

East Hampton and its coaching staff, which got a little bit of a shakeup during the offseason, are well aware that they won’t have the luxury of being that unknown team this fall — and that’s fine. Danielle Schuster has taken over as head coach of the Bonackers after Samantha James stepped down in the offseason. Nicole Ficeto, a very familiar face to the girls, is Schuster’s assistant, along with Erica Sanniola, who will continue to coach JV, and volunteer assistant Aimee Geehreng.

“I think it’s going to be a really positive season,” Schuster said Monday night after a scrimmage against Patchogue-Medford. “The girls put lot of hard work in the preseason. We just finished doing doubles, and today was a great turnout against a Class A school. I think it’s going to be a really great season.”

“We basically have a goal to continue to improve each game and really take each game one at a time,” Ficeto added. “With this league, it’s so tight, you never know what’s going to happen, so we have to keep the girls calm, keep them confident in their skills and develop strong communication skills on the field. When it’s game time, we need to do less talking as coaches, and that has to come from them as more of a unit. If they attain that, I think they’ll be able to do some creative things.”

Numbers are good with 40 players overall spread out between varsity and JV. Schuster said 23 of those 40 will play on varsity. Included in that group are six seniors, 10 juniors and seven sophomores. Four of those six returning seniors are starters in Emma McGrory, Melina Sarlo, Aly Schaefer and Siena Link-Morse. Ava Walters, who didn’t play last season, has returned to the team, and Ava Tintle will continue to lead the defense. Kerri O’Donnell, who played forward for much of last season, is moving back to defense. Caeleigh Schuster, the head coach’s daughter who won Division II Goalie of the Year honors last season as a freshman, is returning in goal and will continue to be a part of the team going forward. And Hailey Welsch is also a key returning player.

Outside of offense and defense, both Ficeto and Schuster don’t like to give out specific positions, but just about every player on the team is so versatile they can really play just about anywhere, and some players will do just that.

“Our girls know they can wind up playing anywhere,” Ficeto said. “They all adjust very well and they’re willing to go wherever we put them. We went into this season kind of building that back line and developed the team really off of that, so there will be a lot more fluidity between the mids and forwards — so a lot of them are finding their home right now. There has been a bit of a shakeup in the line since last year, but it can all be flipped throughout the season.”

To be able to do such things, there has to be a level of trust between the players and coaches, and Schuster said there certainly is.

“They know that if one of these changes doesn’t work for them, they can’t do it, or if they don’t feel comfortable, they can always check in with us and say, ‘I don’t feel like it’s working,’” she said. “We’ve also been working on camaraderie building with them. With field hockey, we’re trying to make it a family and really tie varsity and JV together and constantly building on those basic skills where the older girls and younger girls are invested in each other.”

East Hampton will continue to play as a Class B team in Division II, where it will need to finish with a .500 record or better to gain an automatic playoff spot. East Hampton started its season against neighboring district Pierson/Bridgehampton this Thursday, August 31, at home at 4 p.m.

You May Also Like:

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Soccer, Westhampton Beach Girls Soccer Earn First Wins; Southampton Field Hockey Defeats West Babylon

Calle’s Hat Trick Leads to
Bonac Boys Soccer First Win The East Hampton boys soccer team defeated Huntington, 6-3, at home on October 8 for their first victory of the season. Eduardo Calle scored a hat trick and had an assist, while Esteban Diaz scored two goals and assisted on two others. Bryan Pillco scored the other goal for the Bonackers (1-10-2 overall) and Adrian Arango made five saves in goal. Bonac Boys Volleyball
Defeats Central Islip The East Hampton boys volleyball team took down Central Islip in three straight sets, 25-17, 25-9, 25-13. The Bonackers are 4-5 overall. Strong Second Half
for ... 15 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Boys Golf Hands Westhampton Beach Its First Loss; Pierson Boys Soccer, Field Hockey Earn First Wins; Alvarez's Two Goals Lead Mariner Boys Soccer

East Hampton Boys Golf Hand ’Canes Their First Loss Charlie McMillan shot a match-low 33 to help lead the Bonackers to a 7.5-1.5 victory over previously unbeaten Westhampton Beach at the Amagansett Golf Club on Monday. East Hampton outshot the Hurricanes, 199-208. Zach Berger shot a team-low 38 for the ’Canes. Though both teams still had to finish out the rest of their regular season schedules this week, if they win out, East Hampton and Westhampton Beach will share the League VIII title this season. Bonac Swimmers Lose Tight Meet to Ward Melville Down two points going into the final event, ... 8 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

A First for East Hampton Athletic Hall of Fame

Homecoming Weekend typically includes the annual induction of a brand new class into the East ... 1 Oct 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Early Lapse Doesn't Hurt Bonac Girls Swimmers; Hampton Bays Girls Volleyball Back in Win Column; Paga's Header Leads Hurricane Boys Soccer To Big Win

East Hampton Field Hockey
Stops Losing Streak Merritt Bistrian-Emptage had a goal and an assist and Sabrina Texis added a goal to lead East Hampton (4-5 in Division II) to a 2-0 victory over Southampton at the Hon. Fred W. Thiele Jr. Recreational Facility on Stephen Hand’s Path on Thursday, September 25, snapping what had been a three-game losing streak. Brynley Lys added an assist and Izzy Briand made two saves in goal. Alexis Trotman made six saves for Southampton. Despite Early Troubles
Bonac Swimmers 
Win Another Meet The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton girls swim team defeated Northport/Commack, 99-69, in their final nonleague meet ... 30 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Football Avenges Last Year's Playoff Loss at Hills West; Cook Leads Mariners Cross Country to First Win; Hampton Bays Girls Soccer Tallies Two Wins

Bonac Football Avenges
Last Year’s Playoff Loss The East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton football team defeated host Half Hollow Hills West, 35-10, on Saturday afternoon, on the same field the Bonackers suffered a 52-6 loss in the opening round of the Suffolk County Division III playoffs last season. Theo Ball threw for 190 yards and three touchdowns, one of them to Jackson Ronick who also rushed for 75 yards and two touchdowns. Charlie Stern caught three receptions for 115 yards and recorded six tackles on defense. Livs Kuplins had six tackles and an interception and caught a 25-yard reception for a touchdown for the ... 23 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Has the Corner Been Turned for East Hampton Field Hockey? Stay Tuned

Has East Hampton’s field hockey team turned the corner? Still too early to say, said ... 10 Sep 2025 by Jack Graves

Weekly Roundup: Torres Leading Bonac Girls Soccer Early On; Southampton Girls Soccer Picks Up First Wins; Atkinson Scores OT Game Winner in East Hampton for Hurricane Boys Soccer

Bonac Boys Volleyball
Splits First Two Matches The East Hampton boys volleyball team welcomed host Hampton ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Field Hockey Gears Up for a Promising Season

After a tough 1-0 loss to East Islip in the opening round of the Suffolk ... 3 Sep 2025 by Drew Budd

Let There Be Light: Bonac Athletes To Play Night Games at New Stephen Hands Path Field

East Hampton High School athletes will have the chance to play under the lights this ... 29 Jul 2025 by Jack Motz

Bonackers Earn Postseason Awards for Efforts This Past Fall

East Hampton Boys Cross Country All-League Benson Edman, Liam Knight, Jasper Samuelson, Wyatt Smith East Hampton Girls Cross Country All-Division Laura Martinez All-League Danett Gonzalez, Heidi Jimenez Bustos, Laura Martinez, Zion Osei East Hampton Field Hockey NFHCA All-Region, All-State, Suffolk County Division II Goalkeeper of the Year, All-Tournament Caeleigh Schuster All-County, Exceptional Senior Award, All-Academic Ava Tintle All-County Honorable Mention Kerri O’Donnell, Hailey Welsch All-Classification Katherine Grande All-Division Addison Barletta Unsung Hero Yvonne Geehreng The Bonackers also earned an All-Academic Team Award. — Ed. East Hampton/Pierson/Bridgehampton Football All-County Alex Davis All-Division Theo Ball, Bowie Pipino, Livs Kuplins Honorable Mention All-Division ... 26 Feb 2025 by Staff Writer