Guldi Sentenced Again, Faces No New Jail Time - 27 East

Guldi Sentenced Again, Faces No New Jail Time

authorWill James on Aug 31, 2011

Former Suffolk County Legislator George O. Guldi last Wednesday was sentenced to one to three years in prison, a term that was laid out in a plea bargain and will add no new prison time to a sentence the ex-lawmaker is already serving for a previous conviction.

Mr. Guldi, a Democrat who represented the South Fork from 1993 until 2003, pleaded guilty in July to 34 counts of grand larceny and one count of scheme to defraud related to his involvement in a massive mortgage fraud ring.

After the sentencing, Assistant District Attorney Thalia Stavrides said she was disappointed the latest sentence would run concurrently with the jail term Mr. Guldi was already serving, rather than being tacked onto the end of it. Ms. Stavrides said she originally argued for a sentence of eight and one-third to 25 years.

Mr. Guldi, who represented himself throughout most of the case, has been in Suffolk County Jail serving a four-to-12-year sentence since March, when he was convicted of insurance fraud and grand larceny for misusing insurance funds after his Westhampton Beach home burned down.

Chris Brocato, an attorney assigned to help guide Mr. Guldi in his defense, said during the sentencing that Mr. Guldi could be moved to a state prison as soon as last Friday.

Mr. Guldi, wearing a suit and sporting a shaved head, spoke with Justice James F.X. Doyle about legal matters related to the sentencing, and showed little emotion throughout the proceedings, smiling occasionally. A Westhampton Beach native, he worked as an attorney but was disbarred as a result of his March conviction.

Justice Doyle did not order restitution payments as part of Mr. Guldi’s sentence, saying that civil court was the proper venue for the banks that were defrauded to be repaid. Demanding restitution, Justice Doyle said, could “cloud” ongoing and future civil cases.

Ms. Stavrides said she would have preferred if restitution were part of the sentence, estimating the cost of the mortgages related to the charges against Mr. Guldi to be $30 million to $40 million.

After the proceedings, Mr. Brocato said some victims have already filed lawsuits against Mr. Guldi.

“Everyone under the sun is suing George right now,” he said. “So there’s no reason to muddy the waters.”

You May Also Like:

Montauk Fisherman Loses Slip After Federal Conviction; Attorney Says East Hampton Town Denied Him Due Process

The East Hampton Town harbormaster has declined to renew a commercial dock permit dating back ... 1 Jul 2025 by Jack Motz

East Hampton Town Planning Board Meets New Condo-Style Affordable Housing Plan With Warmth — and Caution

A private citizen’s novel plan to develop individual condominiums as affordable housing took its first ... by Jack Motz

Colorful History Hangs Over Pitched Nitrogen-Reducing System in East Hampton Town's Only Sewer District

East Hampton Town’s only sewer district could soon get a nitrogen-reducing system, but a colorful ... 25 Jun 2025 by Jack Motz

Absentees Upend Working Families Party Vote, Bump Democrats Off Party Line for November Ballot

Absentee ballots that came in after last week’s primary voting bumped Democratic Party candidate Tom ... by Michael Wright

Thayer Crowley, Barbour Reelected to Sagaponack Village Board in Uncontested Election

Sagaponack Village Trustees Carrie Thayer Crowley and William Barbour were reelected to their positions on June 20, in an uncontested election. Barbour earned a total of 19 votes (18 in person, 1 absentee), while Crowley garnered 16 votes (15 in person, 1 absentee). Barbour was first elected to the Sagaponack Village Board in 2011, as a write-in candidate and will be starting his eighth two-year term. Crowley was first elected in 2021, making this the start of her third two-year term. by Cailin Riley

East Hampton Town Launches First-Ever Mailed Newsletter To Keep Residents Informed

All East Hampton Town residents will receive a newsletter from the town this year, which ... 24 Jun 2025 by Jack Motz

East Hampton Village Board Approves $30.7 Million Budget as Presented

The East Hampton Village Board approved a $30.7 million budget for the next fiscal year ... by Jack Motz

Surfrider Signs Offer Way for Beachgoers To Keep Tabs on Water Quality at Swimming Holes

The South Fork’s ocean beaches, the crown jewel of the region and the main engine ... 18 Jun 2025 by Michael Wright

Judge Rules Village Administrator Does Not Have Authority To Revoke Beach Permit

A Suffolk County Supreme Court justice ended a legal battle for the time being after ... by Jack Motz

East Hampton Zoning Board to Hear Permit Case After Attorney Sues Over Delays

The East Hampton Town Zoning Board of Appeals has agreed to hear a special permit ... by Jack Motz