John Haessler, Co-Founder Of Wainscott's Seafood Shop, Dies At 68 - 27 East

John Haessler, Co-Founder Of Wainscott's Seafood Shop, Dies At 68

icon 1 Photo
Co-chair Dick Bruce at "Art in the Garden." COURTESY FRAN CONIGLIARO

Co-chair Dick Bruce at "Art in the Garden." COURTESY FRAN CONIGLIARO

authorErica Thompson on Feb 23, 2014

John Haessler, father, husband and co-founder of the Seafood Shop in Wainscott, lost his battle with cancer on Friday at the age of 68.

Mr. Haessler, who was born and raised in East Hampton, opened up the shop on Montauk Highway in 1972 with longtime friend Robert Wilford, but sold the store in 2000 to Colin Mather, another close friend. Mr. Mather still owns the store today.

“I started working for John when I was 17,” said Mr. Mather, “He took me under his wing, and from that point on he kept me on the straight and narrow, and did it with a lot of love and care.”

More of a mentor than a boss, Mr. Haessler was known for instilling a work ethic and moral compass in his employees and co-workers. “People flocked toward him,” said Mr. Mather.

Described as quiet but strong, Mr. Haessler had the ability to capture the interest of those who surrounded him, which dated back to his days as a teacher at East Hampton Middle School, said his wife, Polly Haessler.

“He had this ability, like a silent strength,” said Ms. Haessler, who met him during her time teaching at John Marshall Elementary School in the early 1970s. “Every kid wanted to be in his class, and with our own kids, too, he had this empathetic kindness.”

The Haesslers were married in 1976 and had two children, Stacey in 1980 and Lee in 1982.

“He was an outstanding father,” said Ms. Haessler. “Both of my kids learned their work ethic from John. Once you joined a sports team, you had a commitment for the season. Jobs were the same way. He always saw things through to the end.”

Ms. Haessler said her husband came to every one of their kids’ sports games and was always their biggest fan. “He was there. Always, he was there for everything,” she said.

Mr. Mather said Mr. Haessler was an extremely dedicated, hard-working person in both his career and his personal life. “John worked harder than anyone I know,” he said. “But he also was never a boastful man, and that was one of his most attractive features. A lot of people do a lot of chest beating, and he wasn’t one of those people.”

After his retirement in 2000, Mr. Haessler spent most of his days on the golf course in Sarasota, Florida. “He had a wonderful, great 14 years of retirement down there,” Ms. Haessler said. “For John, who loved East Hampton more than anything, for him to find somewhere else he really loved and be able to play golf was so good for him.

“He’d drop the ball maybe 200 yards, but he’d be out on the green for hours,” said Mr. Mather. “It was this steady, even force, and that’s the way John lived his life. Steady as a compass.”

Memorial donations may be made out to East End Hospice, P.O. Box 1048, Westhampton Beach, NY 11978. A memorial service will be held in the spring.

You May Also Like:

Joyce W. Parker of Sag Harbor and Syracuse Dies August 9

Joyce W. Parker (née Wikander) of Sag Harbor and Syracuse died on August 9 at ... 25 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Thomas J. Hand of Sag Harbor and Gainesville, Florida, Dies June 16

Thomas J. Hand of Sag Harbor and Gainesville, Florida, died peacefully on June 16. He ... by Staff Writer

Ilsabe Wahrendorf Wyman of Southampton Dies August 15

Ilsabe Wahrendorf Wyman, 95, passed away peacefully on August 15, 2025, just days before her ... 19 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Jeanne Marilyn Burden Bunce of Water Mill Dies August 3

Jeanne Marilyn Burden Bunce passed away Sunday, August 3rd, 2025, at the Kanas Center for ... by Staff Writer

Pamela H. Thompson of Bristol, England, and Wainscott, Dies August 11

Pamela H. Thompson of Bristol, England, and Wainscott, died on August 11 in Bristol after ... 15 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Richard ‘Rick’ Hartmann of Sag Harbor Dies August 5

Richard “Rick” Hartmann of Sag Harbor, affectionately known as “Big Pro,” died peacefully on August 5 in Sag Harbor. He was 66. Born on December 23, 1958, in Huntington, his life was marked by a passion for golf, unwavering kindness, and a remarkable presence that impacted all who knew him. For 30 years, he served as the head golf professional at Atlantic Golf Club, where he became a guiding force, teacher and mentor. He was a legendary figure in the Metropolitan Golf community and earned numerous accolades, including four Long Island Open titles, four Long Island PGA Championships, two Met ... 9 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Ronald J. Papageorge of Castelton, New York, and Formerly of Southampton Dies July 20

Ronald J. Papageorge of Castelton, New York, and formerly of Southampton, died peacefully at home ... 8 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Vincent Andrew Mauceri of Sag Harbor Dies August 3

Vincent Andrew Mauceri of Sag Harbor died quietly on August 3 while undergoing an MRI ... by Staff Writer

Caroline Grace Fairley of Sag Harbor Dies July 22

Caroline Grace Fairley, affectionately known as “Caro,” passed away unexpectedly in her home in Sag ... 1 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Rose L. Nabel of Southampton Dies July 25

Rose L. Nabel, 94, of Southampton, New York, passed away at Bayshore Medical Center on ... by Staff Writer