Judge Says Sand Highway Lake Mine Is Not An Expansion, Sidesteps Previous Ruling To Contrary

icon 2 Photos
Key components of East Hampton Town’s legal challenge to the extension of the mining permit at a sand mine in East Hampton that would allow the mine to be excavated down another 110 feet, creating a 6-acre, 100-foot deep lake of exposed groundwater were dismissed by a state judge.  MICHAEL WRIGHT

Key components of East Hampton Town’s legal challenge to the extension of the mining permit at a sand mine in East Hampton that would allow the mine to be excavated down another 110 feet, creating a 6-acre, 100-foot deep lake of exposed groundwater were dismissed by a state judge. MICHAEL WRIGHT

The sand pit on Middle Highway in East Hampton known as Sand Highway. A state judge this week ruled that allowing the mine to dig down 150 feet, creating a 6-acre lake of exposed groundwater, does not constitute an expansion of the mine. But another state court ruled in May that a similar proposal in Noyac was, in fact, an illegal expansion.

The sand pit on Middle Highway in East Hampton known as Sand Highway. A state judge this week ruled that allowing the mine to dig down 150 feet, creating a 6-acre lake of exposed groundwater, does not constitute an expansion of the mine. But another state court ruled in May that a similar proposal in Noyac was, in fact, an illegal expansion. Michael Wright

authorMichael Wright on Jul 14, 2021
A state judge last week dismissed key components of East Hampton Town’s legal challenge to the extension of the mining permit at a sand mine in East Hampton that would... more

You May Also Like:

Growing Wellness: New Community Garden at Stony Brook Southampton To Offer 'Produce Prescriptions'

Since its creation, the Food Lab at Stony Brook Southampton has been committed to studying ... 14 Nov 2025 by Cailin Riley

Scallop Season Opens, but Scant Few Scallops To Be Found

The bay scallop harvest on the South Fork opened in Southampton and East Hampton waters ... 11 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Montauk Infrastructure Work Abounds as Dredge Oyster Bay Gets To Work

For the past week or so, heavy machinery has dotted the west shoreline of Lake ... by Jack Motz

Lawsuit Alleges East Hampton ZBA Denial Could Put Marine Boulevard Home in the Hands of Nature

An oceanfront homeowner on Marine Boulevard in Amagansett has sued the East Hampton Town Zoning ... 5 Nov 2025 by Jack Motz

Dredge Oyster Bay Arrives for Long-Awaited Lake Montauk Operation

Dredge Oyster Bay arrived in Montauk on Monday morning for the long-awaited Lake Montauk Inlet ... 3 Nov 2025 by Jack Motz

After Cellphone Ban, Group for the East End Encourages Kids To Get Outside and Explore

Earlier this month, Jen Skilbred, the assistant director for environmental education with the Group for ... 26 Oct 2025 by Cailin Riley

Funding FIMP: East Hampton Poised To Spend $27.6 Million Over 30 Years for Montauk Beach Nourishments

The East Hampton Town Board is poised to spend $27.6 million via a 30-year agreement ... 15 Oct 2025 by Jack Motz

Leader of Othodox Christians To Visit Southampton, Bless Shinnecock Bay

The religious leader of Orthodox Christianity, His All-Holiness Ecumenical Patriarch Bartholomew, will visit the East ... 19 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

East Hampton Town Takes First Look at Proposed Tree Protection Law

As it lags behind statewide, East Hampton Town is looking at becoming the latest East ... 17 Sep 2025 by Jack Motz

Group for East End Osprey Survey Shows More Nests but Fewer Fledglings

Ospreys, or fish hawks, the birds whose population was decimated by the use of the ... 15 Sep 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz