Mother Admitted Killing Twin Toddlers To Police, Will Turn To Insanity Defense - 27 East

Mother Admitted Killing Twin Toddlers To Police, Will Turn To Insanity Defense

icon 2 Photos

authorStaff Writer on Jul 10, 2019

The attorney representing Tenia Campbell, the Medford woman who was arrested in Montauk late last month after she admitted to police that she had suffocated her twin 2-year-old daughters, said that he will focus on his client’s mental health in her defense against the multiple murder charges she faces.

Speaking after Ms. Campbell’s arraignment on first- and second-degree murder charges in Suffolk County Criminal Court in Riverside on Wednesday morning, July 10, her court-appointed attorney, John Halverson, said that the “horrific tragedy” seemed to clearly be driven by the mental disorders her family has said she suffers from.

“I think the act speaks for itself,” Mr. Halverson said. “Any mother alleged to have harmed her children is not in the right state of mind.”

Ms. Campbell’s mother has told police that her daughter was diagnosed as bipolar when she was a teenager and has long suffered from severe anxiety and depression. She said that Ms. Campbell had been particularly unsettled in the days leading up to the deaths of her children.

Court records show that the single mother of three—her 4-year-old son was not with her on the day her daughters were killed—was facing eviction from her apartment in Medford. The father of the deceased twins is estranged from the family and had “no relationship” with the mother, police said.

Ms. Campbell, 24, did not speak in court on Wednesday as Mr. Halverson entered a not guilty plea for her to Criminal Court Judge Richard Ambro.

Judge Ambro ordered her held without bail and kept on suicide watch. He also ordered medical and psychiatric assessments requested by Mr. Halverson.

Ms. Campbell is charged with two counts of first-degree murder and two counts of second-degree murder and faces up to life in prison without the possibility of parole, if convicted on the most serious charges.

She is due back in court again on August 7.

Several members of Ms. Campbell’s family were in the courtroom on Wednesday, but not her mother, Vanessa McQueen, with whom Ms. Campbell spoke on the phone while she drove to Montauk on the day her children were killed.

Ms. Campbell told her mother at the time that she had killed the children and was planning to kill herself but later admitted she couldn’t kill herself and was “going to jail.”

A woman who identified herself as Cindy Campbell, and said she was Ms. Campbell’s aunt, spoke briefly outside the courtroom following the arraignment.

“She’s a beautiful person—she doesn’t deserve this,” Ms. Campbell said. “God allowed what happened to happen for a reason. And all those negative comments that people are making … she’s a good person.”

Assistant District Attorney Kerriann Kelly, the head of the Suffolk County district attorney’s office’s homicide bureau, said that investigators believe that Ms. Campbell suffocated her two toddlers. She then drove to Montauk with their bodies strapped into the car seats in the back of her mother’s minivan, where she was tracked down by East Hampton Town Police officers near the entrance to Montauk County Park on June 27.

“The medical examiner has determined that they were killed with homicidal violence, consistent with manual asphyxia … whether that’s by hand, by pillow or some other manner,” Ms Kelly said in the Arthur M. Cromarty court building in Riverside. “I can only tell you that the defendant herself indicated that she did it with her own hands.”

Ms. Kelly said that Ms. Campbell admitted killing her children in a phone call with police while she was driving, but she could not yet say where she is believed to have been when she killed them. She had told her mother during a phone conversation hours before she was found in Montauk that the girls were already dead.

Ms. Kelly said she believes the facts of the case at this point do not point to someone in a state of mind consistent with an insanity defense.

“I think the facts bear out a woman who knew exactly what she was doing, why she was doing it, and that she did it intentionally, and her statements certainly support that,” Ms. Kelly said.

You May Also Like:

Cops: Drunk Driver Plows Through Montauk Art Fair, Destroying Artists' Inventory

A 23-year-old woman from Farmingdale crashed her car through the Montauk Artists Association art fair ... 29 Jun 2025 by Michael Wright

Petty Pleads Guilty to Armed Robbery in East Hampton Knifepoint Kidnapping Case

Darius Petty, who was charged with kidnapping and multiple robbery counts by East Hampton Town ... 27 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer

Teen Driver in Fatal Springs Crash Indicted

Luis Gonzalo Barrionuevo Fuertes, the 18-year-old Moriches resident accused of being drunk when he was ... 25 Jun 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

Police Charge Three in Montauk With Selling Drinks to Underage Agent

East Hampton Town Police charged three people with selling alcoholic beverages to minors, a misdemeanor, during a compliance investigation on June 19. The investigations saw an underage agent attempt to purchase alcoholic drinks from various establishments without providing age verification. Police charged three, while deeming other businesses that were investigated to be in compliance with local laws. Police arrested John Caravaggio, 64, of Montauk, at Dive Bar Pizza in Montauk, Kate O’Brien, 37, of Woodside, at Surf Lodge in Montauk, and Hanna Rose Clauss, 29, of Lighthouse Point, Florida, at Bounce Beach in Montauk. Police released all three individuals with ... by Staff Writer

Bail Set at $400,000 for Moriches Man Charged With DWI in Fatal Crash That Claimed Life of East Hampton High School Student

An East Hampton Town justice set bail at $400,000 on Monday afternoon for a Moriches ... 16 Jun 2025 by Jack Motz 
and T.E. McMorrow

Hampton Bays Highway Drama May Have Been First Local Immigration Action

Three unmarked cars with flashing lights and a gaggle of law enforcement officers wearing sidearms ... 30 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Mother Weeps as East Hampton Narco Dealer Is Sentenced to 10 Years

The Brooklyn limo driver convicted of dealing cocaine in East Hampton, Michael Khodorkovskiy, 45, was ... 29 May 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

Springs Man Faces 15 Years on Gun Charge

A Springs man is facing up to 15 years in prison after being arrested early Friday morning on Main Street in East Hampton Village by Town Police on multiple charges, including criminal possession of a weapon in the second degree. Kevin T. Weiss, 24, was a backseat passenger in a 2011 Cadillac CTS 4 that had been pulled over by the town officer for multiple traffic infractions at about 4 a.m. According to police, when they conducted a search, they found Weiss in possession of a Taurus PT 24/7 pro .45 caliber semi-automatic handgun. Police said Weiss was also in ... 24 May 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

East Hampton Village Cops: E-Bike Thief Busted

A 30-year-old man with a lengthy criminal record involving numerous thefts was arrested by East Hampton Village Police on Monday afternoon and charged with two felonies — grand larceny in the third degree and criminal possession of stolen property in the third degree. Police said they caught Franklin Alberto Almonte Nunez of Port Jefferson Station in possession of an e-bike, a green and black Super73 valued at over $3,000, which had just been reported stolen from outside the Maidstone Hotel on Main Street six minutes after police first encountered Almonte Nunez on Toilsome Lane. The initial encounter by police with ... 21 May 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

East Hampton Town Leadership Dissatisfied With Tone of Dispatch Negotiations

East Hampton Town officials alleged in a letter a few weeks ago that East Hampton ... 14 May 2025 by Jack Motz