One Of Five Balenciaga Theft Suspects Pleads Guilty - 27 East

One Of Five Balenciaga Theft Suspects Pleads Guilty

Security Footage Of The Theft
icon 1 Video & 1 Photo

Security Footage Of The Theft

Baseemah Davis was one of four thieves who stole more than $95,000 worth of purses and handbags from the Balanciaga store in East Hampton Village in March. She pleaded guilty to grand larceny on Tuesday.

Baseemah Davis was one of four thieves who stole more than $95,000 worth of purses and handbags from the Balanciaga store in East Hampton Village in March. She pleaded guilty to grand larceny on Tuesday.

T.E. McMorrow on Aug 16, 2022

The first of four defendants in the theft of more than $95,000 worth of purses and handbags from an East Hampton Village store in March pleaded guilty in Suffolk County Court in Riverside on Tuesday, August 16.

Baseemah Davis, 34, pleaded guilty to grand larceny and possession of stolen property, both felonies, related to the theft of the bags from the Balenciaga store on Newtown Lane in East Hampton Village on March 3, as well as a misdemeanor possession of drugs. She will be sentenced on September 23 by County Court Judge Anthony Senft.

Two of her three co-defendants, Ali Harris and Wazir Rodgers, are due in court this Friday. Davis, Harris and Rodgers are currently in custody, as is co-defendant Jamal Johns. All four are from Newark, New Jersey. Davis, Rodgers and Johns have all been in custody since their arrests, unable to make the $50,000 bail Senft set for them on March 16.

While the others have criminal records, Harris did not, and he was ordered released by Senft on supervised release to be monitored by the probation department. In July, the department reported that he violated the terms of his release, causing Senft to set a $50,000 bail amount on Harris, as well. He has since been in county jail, unable to post the bail.

A fifth person involved in the theft, a woman, is still at large and has not been identified by the police. At about 1:30 in the afternoon on March 3, she entered the couture store wearing a pink ski mask. She was the only “customer” there at the moment.

She walked around the store and looked at various handbags, District Attorney Ray Tierney said in a press release, then asked an employee to check to see if the store carried a certain shoe in her size. The moment the employee did so, Davis rushed in, allegedly with her co-defendants, and went on a snatch-and-grab of handbags on display, The entire incident lasted about 30 seconds.

Davis, who admitted her part of the robbery in court when she pleaded guilty, then ran out of the store, allegedly with the other four, all piling into a waiting Dodge Durango and making off with $93,000 in merchandise.

An East Hampton Village Police officer took up pursuit of the Durango but broke it off when the fleeing vehicle accelerated to speeds over 100 mph, weaving across traffic lanes.

A State Police officer spotted the Durango exiting Sunrise Highway toward County Route 111 and Manorville and the Long Island Expressway. He pursued the vehicle, “but that pursuit also had to be terminated due to safety concerns as the Durango was traveling at speeds in excess of 100 mph and was observed veering into oncoming lanes of traffic,” the DA’s press release stated.

However, the trooper saw that smoke was now coming from the Durango and followed at a safe distance.

The Durango entered the LIE at exit 70, only to exit at 69. The now broken down Durango was driven onto the shoulder. Three of the occupants fled, including Davis. They were all picked up after a police search of the wooded area.

If this was a road trip for the Newark residents, it allegedly was not Davis’s first to Long Island.

She has been arrested three times on Long Island since Christmas Eve. All involved felonies. The other two cases are still open in Nassau County.

On Christmas Eve, at about the same time of day as the theft at the Balneciaga store, she entered the Nieman Marcus store in Garden City, took a red jacket off of a mannequin at a Moncler boutique valued at $1,983, and walked out of the store wearing it, police said. She was arrested almost immediately.

Then, on January 20, at the Americana Mall in Roslyn, a Nassau County Police officer made a traffic stop of a 2021 BMW, in which Davis was one of three passengers, police said. The car allegedly had phony temporary New Jersey plates.

Police said they searched the car, finding numerous burglar’s tools, as well as drugs.

In Davis’s handbag, police said, they found a pill jar for a different medication containing 59 tablets of oxycodone.

A search of a toiletries bag police said also belonged to Davis turned up several other drugs requiring a prescription, as well as a pair of sneakers that still had the Manhasset Marshall’s store tags on it, from where they had allegedly been stolen.

Davis is facing a charge of felony narcotics possession with intent to sell, along with two other felonies, along with numerous misdemeanor charges.

You May Also Like:

East Hampton Police Reports for the Week of May 1

MONTAUK — A former Montauk resident who police say is now homeless, Nicholas S. Bustamante, 33, was arrested on two felony charges, burglary in the second degree and criminal mischief in the second degree, the morning of April 23. The house Bustamante was said to have burglarized is one he formerly resided in, it appears from the criminal complaints against him. According to police, they were notified that there was a burglary in progress at the residence, located off East Lake Drive, a little after 5 a.m. Bustamante was found inside the house by officers where he had done extensive ... 7 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Montauk Man Charged With Felony Cocaine Possession With Intent To Sell

East Hampton Village Police arrested a Montauk man, Richard Patrick Daunt, 61, on two felony charges of criminal possession of a controlled substance in the third degree, which are B felonies, at about 9 p.m. on April 29. The controlled substance police say Daunt was in possession of was cocaine. The cocaine was turned up, according to police, after Daunt was initially arrested on misdemeanor DWI charges. Police said an officer approached the 2019 Chevrolet Blazer that Daunt was seated in with another party on an unrelated investigation in the Reutershan parking lot near the Park Place egress to Main ... by T.E. McMorrow

East Hampton Town, Village Spar Over Dispatching Future, End 30-Year Agreement

The East Hampton Town and East Hampton Village governments went head to head over police ... by Jack Motz

Second East Hampton Cocaine Delivery Dealer Pleads Guilty

The second of two men facing dozens of charges related to dealing cocaine in Montauk ... 29 Apr 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

East Hampton Police Officer Arrested, Charged With DWI After Crash in Hampton Bays That Knocked Out Power

An East Hampton Town Police officer was arrested and charged with DWI early Tuesday morning ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Traffic Experiment Showed Big Improvements in Commute Times During First Week; New Changes Tried This Week

By the end of the first week of Southampton Town’s experiment in bypassing the traffic ... 27 Apr 2025 by Michael Wright

East Hampton Town, Police Union Agree on New Contract for Dispatchers

East Hampton Town and the East Hampton Police Benevolent Association finalized an agreement for a ... 25 Apr 2025 by Jack Motz

East Hampton Cocaine Limo Delivery Driver Pleads Guilty

Michael Khodorkovskiy , the 44-year-old Brooklyn man who partnered in a cocaine distribution delivery ring ... 22 Apr 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

East Hampton Village Police Officer Robby Greene Wins Village's First-Ever 'Top Cop' Award

East Hampton Village Police Officer Robby Greene won the village’s inaugural “Top Cop” award, which ... 2 Apr 2025 by Jack Motz

East Hampton Town Police Report 539 Arrests for 2024, With Steady Increase in DWIs

The East Hampton Town Police Department has not held anyone so far this year for ... by Jack Motz