Third Defendant in Balenciaga Snatch-and-Grab Theft Pleads Guilty

icon 1 Photo
Jamal Johns

Jamal Johns

T. E. McMorrow on Sep 20, 2022

A third defendant in the five-person swarm, snatch and run theft at Balenciaga in East Hampton Village on March 3 has pleaded guilty to grand larceny and possession of stolen property, both felonies.

Jamal Johns, 26, will be sentenced to 3 ½ to 7 years in state prison on October 17 in a deal agreed to on Tuesday by Justice Anthony Senft. Suffolk County Assistant District Attorney James O’Rourke had asked for a 5-to-10-year sentence.

The haul of couture handbags stolen netted the thieves about $94,000 in property, albeit for just a few hours. The three who have pleaded guilty, along with another codefendant, Ali Harris — who is in custody, waiting for his case to be adjudicated — and a fifth, female participant who remains at large, were cornered by police several hours after the crime when their getaway vehicle broke down.

All four of those arrested were from Newark, New Jersey. Police are actively seeking the fifth suspect.

Johns also pleaded guilty Tuesday to a misdemeanor drug possession charge.

Of the four codefendants, Johns had the most extensive criminal background, with multiple prior felony convictions, as well as an open case in Manhattan.

In August, two codefendants, Baseemah Davis, 34 and Wazir Rodgers, 25, pleaded guilty to the same charges as Johns. Davis is to be sentenced to 2 to 6 years next week, while Rodgers will get 3 to 9 years when he is sentenced on October 17. The sentences were what was promised by Senft in exchange for the guilty pleas, as agreed upon between District Attorney Ray Tierney’s office and the defendants and their attorneys.

At about 1:30 in the afternoon on March 3, the female perpetrator who remains at large entered the Balenciaga store wearing a pink ski mask. The store was empty, save for her and a clerk.

She asked an employee to check to see if the store carried a shoe in her size. The moment the clerk left the storefront, the four others rushed in, doing a “snatch-and-grab” of handbags on display. The entire incident lasted about 30 seconds.

East Hampton Village Police officers took up pursuit of the Dodge Durango that the five jumped into on Newtown Lane but broke the chase off when the fleeing vehicle accelerated to speeds over 100 mph, weaving across traffic lanes on busy Montauk Highway.

A State Police trooper spotted the Durango on County Route 111, headed for Manorville and the Long Island Expressway. He pursued the vehicle but broke off highspeed pursuit when it became too dangerous for the public on the road. However, he noticed smoke was coming from the Durango and followed at a safe distance.

The Durango entered the LIE at exit 70, then left the highway one exit later, stopping on the side of the road. The four currently in custody were picked up shortly thereafter, though the fifth alluded the police search.

You May Also Like:

DA: Fourteen Charged in Suffolk Porch Pirate Scheme

Fourteen members of a “porch pirate” ring that targeted many Suffolk County communities, including Sag Harbor and Montauk, have been indicted for enterprise corruption and related charges, District Attorney Ray Tierney announced on Monday. The criminal network used insider tracking data to steal electronic devices from residences and businesses, according to the district attorney’s office, which said the charges stem from a two-year investigation into thefts that occurred between October 2023 and February 2025. “For two years, this alleged porch pirate ring plagued our community and built a criminal enterprise on the backs of Suffolk families and businesses,” Tierney said ... 24 Nov 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Police Seek Public's Help in Looking for Man Said To Have Used Stolen Credit Card

Suffolk County Crime Stoppers and East Hampton Town Police have asked for the public’s help ... 19 Nov 2025 by Jack Motz

Sunrise Highway Westbound Lanes Reopened Tuesday After Five Days of Around-the-Clock Repair Work

Contractors worked around the clock for five days to repair the abutments beneath Sunrise Highway ... 31 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

Shinnecock Hills Man Celebrates 81st Birthday, Thanks Officers Who Saved Him From Roof of Burning House

Harry Fullum said that spending his 81st birthday at the Southampton Center for Rehabilitation would ... by Michael Wright

East Hampton Named in Federal Gambling Charges Involving NBA Coach Chauncey Billups

In its announcement that it had charged 31 defendants with illegally rigging poker games, the U.S. Attorney’s office for the Eastern District of New York said this week that some of the games took place in East Hampton. The defendants include Portland Trailblazers Head Coach Chauncey Billups, a former NBA player, and members of the Bonanno, Gambino and Genovese organized crime families, the U.S. Attorney’s office said. “Earlier today, at the federal courthouse in Brooklyn, a seven-count indictment was unsealed charging 31 defendants in criminal schemes to rig illegal poker games at various locations in New York City, East Hampton, ... 29 Oct 2025 by Jack Motz

Springs Man Faces Felony Charges for Knife Attack

A Springs man was arrested by East Hampton Town Police this weekend after police said he slashed an acquaintance with a knife during a domestic dispute. James E. Wilkins Jr., 45, recently of Springs, was arrested on Friday night and faces multiple charges, including two felonies: assault in the second degree and criminal possession of a weapon. Police said that during a dispute with an acquaintance, Wilkins pulled out a knife, wounding the acquaintance’s scalp and left hand, causing deep lacerations and “disfigurement.” The dispute occurred at a Springs residence, in front of two young children, police said, triggering two ... 27 Oct 2025 by T.E. McMorrow

Update: East Hampton Town Police Say Missing Woman Has Been Found

Update: East Hampton Town Police say that the woman has been located and that no ... 23 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

For Years, 'Montauk Mary' Was a Cold Case, but It Was Never Forgotten by Local Investigators

On a Wednesday in March 1978, the second day of spring, Edward Kenney, a civilian ... 4 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

As 911 Answering Switch Nears in East Hampton, Feud Briefly Reignites

A feud between East Hampton Town and East Hampton Village over 911 call-answering responsibilities reignited ... 24 Sep 2025 by Jack Motz

'Montauk Mary' Cold Case Murder From 1978 Spotlighted by Suffolk DA

Suffolk County District Attorney Ray Tierney’s office this week released a newly created sketch of ... 17 Sep 2025 by Michael Wright