Foodstuffs: Let The Pros Handle Thanksgiving This Year - 27 East

Food & Drink

Food & Drink / 1835844

Foodstuffs: Let The Pros Handle Thanksgiving This Year

authorStaff Writer on Nov 15, 2021

If you’re not in the mood to cook the full Thanksgiving dinner this year, here are some local options for dining in or taking out.


Shippy’s Pumpernickels (36 Windmill Lane. 631-283-0007, will be serving Thanksgiving dinner all month. The complete traditional Turkey dinner is $24.95. They will be closed Thanksgiving Day.

Clamman Seasons of Southampton (235A North Sea Road. 631-283-3354, will be serving its annual Thanksgiving dinner as a three-course meal including seasonal, traditional fares and seafood for $49.95. Children’s plate of chicken fingers and fries for $19.95. Please make reservations. A takeout option is also available. Pick up Thanksgiving day from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m. Delivery is available for an additional fee.

Citarella Fine Foods (20 Hampton Road. 631-283-6600, will be serving a meal for four ($219) that includes a turkey breast, or for eight ($399) with the full turkey, and both meals come with a range of sides. For an additional charge, the turkey can be cooked for you. They also have a la carte options available, see the website for details. Orders will be available for pick-up or local delivery on Tuesday, November 23, and Wednesday, November 24. Citarella will be closed on Thanksgiving Day.

Southampton Publick House (62 Jobs Lane. 631-283-2800, is offering a three-course prix fixe dinner from 1 p.m. to 7 p.m. for $45 per person. For children 10 and under, a two-course turkey dinner and dessert menu is $19.95. Reservations strongly suggested.

Claude’s Restaurant at the Southampton Inn (91 Hill Street. 631-283-6500, will be serving breakfast from 7 to 11 a.m., and from 1 to 5 p.m., a beautiful Thanksgiving feast with all the trimmings, as well as locally baked pies, will be on the menu. Menus can be viewed on the website. Large parties are welcome. Reservations are suggested by calling or emailing

Lobster Roll chef Andrea Anthony is offering her guilt-free apple cranberry crumb pie for Thanksgiving dinner at home. The pie features sautéed spiced apples, a buttery and zesty crumb topping and flavorful bursts of fresh cranberries. The 10-inch deep-dish pie is $32, and will serve six to eight people. Pies are available for pick-up only from Lobster Roll’s Southampton location at 32 Montauk Highway, Southampton, on November 24, with only 50 pies available. Order by emailing Andrea

Sag Harbor

The American Hotel (49 Main Street, Sag Harbor. 631-725-3535, is featuring a special four-course Thanksgiving Day menu that includes all the traditional holiday offerings, as well as several house specialties including sea scallops, Scottish salmon and fresh Long Island duck. The prix fixe menu is $100 for adults and $45 for children.

Schiavoni’s Market (48 Main Street. 631-725-0366, offers family dinners for 8 to 10 people for $349.95, as well as individual dinners for $44.95, including all the traditional fixings. Fresh all-natural and organic turkeys are available. The market will be open on Thanksgiving Day from 7 a.m. to 1 p.m.

Lil’ Birdie (51 Division Street. 631-808-3013, is offering a Thanksgiving pick-up for two for $75 or four people for $140. The restaurant will be taking orders up until Monday, November 22. To order, visit the website, call, or email Pick-up will be between 11 a.m. and 1 p.m. Thanksgiving Day.

Cromer’s Market (3500 Noyac Road. 631-725-9004, is offering individual Thanksgiving dinners along with all your traditional holiday pies — fruits of the forest and many more flavors. Call or visit the website for more information. Please order in advance, all cooked orders must be placed by November 15. Store hours Thanksgiving day are 6 a.m. to 2 p.m.

Lulu Kitchen and Bar (126 Main Street, Sag Harbor. 631-725-0900, will offer a traditional turkey entree on Thanksgiving Day from noon to 8 p.m. The cost is $96 for two people with a children’s portion half price. Regular a la carte menu is also available. Reservations recommended. A takeout package with a fully prepared Thanksgiving dinner is $140 for two, $275 for four. Add-ons available.

Baron’s Cove (31 West Water Street. 844-227-6672, will serve a festive farm-to-table whole turkey dinner for six to eight on Thanksgiving, which includes sides and choice of a pumpkin or pecan pie. Cost is $540 per table. Also available is a three-course pre-fixe Thanksgiving menu for $90 per person ($40 for children). Thanksgiving turkey dinner feeds four and to is $350. Orders must be placed in advance.


Art of Eating (264 Butter Lane. 631-267-2411, is offering a Thanksgiving catering menu to go. Orders placed after Wednesday, November 17, are subject to availability. Pick up is Thursday, November 25, no later than 11:30 a.m. Delivery to most South Fork areas is available, but subject to availability and an additional fee will apply. To place an order, call, or email:

Armin and Judy (970 Montauk Highway. 631-296-8484, will be open on Wednesday, November 24, from 8 a.m. to 1:45 p.m. The restaurant will be closed on Thanksgiving Day, and opens on Friday, November 26, at 8 a.m. to resume regular hours.

L&W Market (2493 Montauk Highway. 631-537-1123, is offering a Thanksgiving catering menu to go. Orders must be placed by November 21 at 6 p.m., with pick up available on Wednesday, November 24, from 3 to 5 p.m. or Thanksgiving Day between 9 and 11 a.m.


Townline BBQ (3593 Montauk Highway. 631-537-2271, is offering a Thanksgiving menu for $39.95 per person. Reservations are available from 1 to 6 p.m. on Thanksgiving Day. For those who prefer to enjoy dinner at home, family style meals are available for takeout. A smoked natural turkey with a quart of turkey apple cider gravy is $155 and serves 12 to 14. Several sides are also available. Pick up is November 24 between 1:30 and 5 p.m. Call to place your order.

East Hampton

The 1770 House Restaurant & Inn (143 Main Street. 631-324-1770, will serve a three-course prix fixe Thanksgiving dinner from 2 to 8 p.m. in the main dining room and downstairs at the Tavern for $125. A special Thanksgiving dinner to go package is $500 and serves from six to eight and must be ordered by Friday, November 19, for pickup on Wednesday, November 24, from 1 to 3 p.m.

Nick & Toni’s (136 Main Street, East Hampton. 631-324-3550, is offering a Thanksgiving at home menu. All orders must be placed by Friday, November 19, at 3 p.m. and pickup will take place on Wednesday, November 24, between 3 and 5 p.m. The menu includes a selection of dishes that feed four. The restaurant will be closed on Thanksgiving.

Hampton Bays

Canal Cafe (44 Newtown Road. 631-723-2155, is offering a Thanksgiving pick-up menu. Place orders by Sunday, November 21. To order, call or email Pick up on Thanksgiving Day, November 25, from 10 a.m. to 1 p.m.

On the North Fork

North Fork Table & Inn in Southold (57225 Main Road. 631- 765-0177, is offering a Thanksgiving larder, with items that can be ordered ahead and enjoyed at home in meals for four or eight, to be picked up from the restaurant on November 24-25. Some of the notable menu items include a carved roasted turkey, stuffed mushrooms, smoked sourdough, and butternut squash bisque. For details, visit

Southold General in Southold (54180 Main Road. 631-458-1275, offers an “Everything but the Turkey” a la carte menu, along with pies by acclaimed pastry chef François Payard, available Wednesday, November 24, including apple crumb with caramel, pecan with mascarpone cream, caramel and bourbon and pumpkin with marshmallow, orange blossom and fennel pollen.

You May Also Like:

Foodstuffs: Weekend Brunch In Montauk And Restaurant Week Returns

Winter Brunch At Gurney’s Gurney’s Montauk has launched one of the hamlet’s first brunch options ... 18 Jan 2022 by Staff Writer

Julie Wilcox’s ‘The Win-Win Diet’ Highlights Healthy Living In The New Year

It’s January, so you know what that means. Time to realign those priorities and kick ... 11 Jan 2022 by Annette Hinkle

The Next Chapter Is About To Begin For Wainscott’s Beloved Breadzilla

This week, the Highway Group announced its upcoming acquisition of the widely celebrated Wainscott bakery, Breadzilla. Located at 84 Wainscott NW Road, the spring 2022 relaunch will become the new home base for the group’s Autostrada Catering, which provides an array of bespoke offerings, from a mobile wood-fired pizza oven to large-scale wedding events. Through this next stage for both Autostrada Catering and Breadzilla, Highway Group strives to preserve the bakery’s prominent offerings and essential staff members. Longtime fans of the Wainscott fixture, the Highway Group team is also behind Highway Restaurant & Bar in East Hampton and Main Street ... 10 Jan 2022 by Staff Writer

Sustainable Living: Good Cow. Bad Cow

There’s this recurring nightmare I had as a child where the McDonald’s “Hamburglar,” staple of ... 3 Jan 2022 by Staff Writer

New Year’s Eve With Cristina Fontanelli

The holiday season has arrived with the new year right around the corner. This season, Claude’s Restaurant at the Southampton Inn is offering awe-inspiring throwback dinner theater shows to close out 2021. Claude’s has been transformed from a casual eatery to a location to enjoy a cabaret dinner and show, unlike anything else on the East End. With a few successful shows already in the books, Claude’s has plenty more offerings leading up to the new year. On New Year’s Eve, Friday, December 31, Claude’s will host special cabaret dinner and show featuring world-renowned award-winning singer Cristina Fontanelli. With her ... 20 Dec 2021 by Staff Writer

Foodstuffs: New Chef At Almond, Holiday Eats And Winter Specials

Almond Restaurant Has A New Chef de Cuisine Jason Weiner, executive chef and co-owner of ... by Staff Writer

Foodstuffs: Lobster Roll In Southampton, Holiday Eats And Feast Of The Seven Fishes

Lobster Roll Opens In Southampton On Friday, December 9, Lobster Roll, the iconic seasonal shack ... 14 Dec 2021 by Staff Writer

Foodstuffs: Winter Prix Fixe, Christmas Dining And Gifts For Foodies

Noodle-Making Demo 
At Sen Sag Harbor Ever wanted to learn to make your own noodles? ... 7 Dec 2021 by Staff Writer

Foodstuffs: Winter Specials And Kosher Cocktails

Weekly Specials At The Bell & Anchor The Bell & Anchor in Noyac is offering ... 29 Nov 2021 by Staff Writer

Get Cooking: ‘Two Jews Making Food’ Debuts On LTV

It’s not exactly who you’d expect to find on the set of a buttoned up ... 19 Nov 2021 by Annette Hinkle

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend