After Foundation Removed Without Permit, Sag Harbor Homeowner Granted Permission To Put It Back The Way It Was - 27 East


Residence / 1753576

After Foundation Removed Without Permit, Sag Harbor Homeowner Granted Permission To Put It Back The Way It Was

Brendan J. OReilly on Feb 1, 2021

After brick foundation walls on a home in a historic district were removed without a permit, the Sag Harbor Village Historic Preservation & Architectural Review Board voted Thursday, January 28, to permit the owner to resume work for the express purpose of securing the foundation, while telling the homeowner to halt all other changes to the house pending review and approval.

Prior to the vote, homeowner Lynn Chin told the board that the east and south foundation walls had been taken down, but would be rebuilt with concrete plus a brick facade that will “match the front and west of the house, exactly as used to be.” She also requested permission for an egress from the basement in the rear of the house, with a set of doors leading to a recessed courtyard.

“The walls will be rebuilt as they were,” Ms. Chin reiterated. “There will be no changes at all to the original footprint of the house. The walls will go back exactly where they were.”

Ms. Chin originally applied for a certificate of appropriateness to replace or modify the shingles, roof, windows, trim and door at 128 Jermain Avenue. She had also told the board at prior meetings that the foundation was unsafe and sagging. “We are putting cement in the foundation to strengthen it,” she had said, noting that only the interior would be affected.

The board’s historic preservation consultant, Zachary Studenroth, said during recent meetings that he was alarmed to see that work was being done on the foundation.

That work apparently involved more than just adding cement inside the basement — it involved removing about half of the foundation.

“There’s a problem, because I think originally the application as you stated, was only for shingles, roof, windows, trim and door,” board attorney Elizabeth Vail said at this past Thursday’s meeting, “and then what happened was exterior work was done without a permit.”

The foundation work exposed the house to the elements, Ms. Vail said. However, the new foundation plan put before the board asks for more than just putting the foundation back, she pointed out; it asks for a new courtyard and basement egress.

She said the proposed courtyard appears to be offset just 2 feet from the side yard property line, which may require approval from the Zoning Board of Appeals, and “should absolutely get a full plan review by a building inspector before it comes before this board.”

Ms. Vail recommended the board approve the foundation restoration in a very limited extent to secure the house.

“You need to submit a new application that gets reviewed by the building inspector,” she told Ms. Chin. “You just can’t keep adding things piecemeal every week that has not been reviewed by the building inspector for this board’s review.”

Ms. Vail deferred to Mr. Studenroth for his feedback on the foundation.

“The foundation part was obviously a total surprise to me because that was never part of this proposed project, and it was certainly a surprise to see that two of the foundation walls were removed,” Mr. Studenroth said. “That obviously compromises the integrity of the building so anything that could be approved this evening to preserve the integrity of the structure is a priority.”

Where the foundation was, the house is supported by Lally columns, he said.

Historic Preservation & Architectural Review Board Vice Chairperson Bethany Deyermond, agreeing with Ms. Vail, suggested that the board agree on the foundation while setting aside other parts of the application for a future meeting.

Ultimately, the board signed off on putting the east foundation wall back the way it was, while holding off on a decision about the proposed basement egress.

It was also revealed during the meeting that a previous owner had received permission in 2013 to replace the house’s asbestos siding with Alaskan cedar siding. Though the siding was never installed, the permission remains in place.

You May Also Like:

Mark Stumer Receives AIA Long Island Lifetime Achievement Award

Mark Stumer, a founding principal of luxury architectural and interior design firm Mojo Stumer Associates, ... 25 Feb 2021 by Brendan J. OReilly

Sag Harbor ZBA Considers Tesla Solar Roof In Historic District

A Sag Harbor Village homeowner is seeking approval to reroof the house with a Tesla Solar Roof, but the plan may run afoul of a line in the village code that prohibits visible solar systems in the village’s historic district. A 2016 local law amended the code to state, “Solar and alternative energy systems shall not be visible from an adjacent street or from an adjacent property.” However, to what extent that code applies to a Tesla Solar Roof, which is designed to appear like a conventional roof, is in question. The Sag Harbor Village Historic Preservation & Architectural Review ... 23 Feb 2021 by Brendan J. OReilly

Inspect Houseplants For Scale And Mealybugs

With only a month or so until the arrival of spring, the hints of new ... 20 Feb 2021 by Andrew Messinger

Choosing, Raising And Harvesting Basil

You may say bayzil and I may say baa-zil, but I hope that we both ... 16 Feb 2021 by Andrew Messinger

Photographer Larry Lederman Captures Beautiful Landscapes Of New York And Connecticut In ‘Garden Portraits’

From the lush green and flowering landscapes of spring to the blazing yellows, oranges and ... 8 Feb 2021 by Brendan J. OReilly

New Flowers, Books, Apps And Devices For The Garden

I’m sure you’ve seen pots at garden centers with the Proven Winners logo on them. ... by Andrew Messinger

Nilay Oza Of Oza Sabbeth Architects Is New AIA Peconic President

On January 1, Nilay Oza assumed his new role as the president of the Peconic ... 1 Feb 2021 by Staff Writer

Drawdown East End Presents ‘Landscape To The Future’ February 9

Grassroots organization Drawdown East End will share best practices for using less water and reducing pollution in lawn and landscape maintenance during a free online event on Tuesday, February 9, at 6:30 p.m. Mark Haubner and Ellen Bialo will present “Lawn and Landscape to the Future,” offered through Rogers Memorial Library in Southampton. “Information leads to education leads to awareness: Our current lawn and landscaping practices are not sustainable with regard to water quantity or quality and we will be talking about all the best management practices available to us to change this for the better,” Mr. Haubner said. Drawdown ... by Staff Writer

Forcing Cuttings To Bloom Indoors Can Offer A Touch Of Spring During The Winter Months

In the dead of winter, I remember my father suiting up to go out in ... by Andrew Messinger

United States’ First 3D Printed Home To Be Built In Riverhead

A home that’s being marketed as the first 3D printed house in the country was ... by Grant Parpan

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported
Send this to a friend