Community Pitches In For Amagansett Mini Barn Raising Community Pitches In For Amagansett Mini Barn Raising - 27 East


Residence / 1386189

Community Pitches In For Amagansett Mini Barn Raising

icon 13 Photos
authorMichelle Trauring on Sep 17, 2012

Covering up a mop of red curls, the back of Ike Fagin’s hat read, “Keep back 200 ft.”

And the young boy’s peers took heed at the first-ever mini barn raising last Saturday on the Amagansett Historical Association grounds. Ike was one of the first kids to grab a wooden mallet.

“It’s fun, being able to hit things,” the 7-year-old said, giving the tool a practice swing.

Under a cloudless sky, about 50 people crowded around David Stiles—owner of East Hampton-based Stiles Design and co-author of 22 building books with his wife, Jeanie—and a timber-frame kit for an 8-foot-by-11-foot barn. It was laid out on the grass in more than a dozen pieces, waiting to be assembled without the help of any hardware.

With four short clangs of an iron triangle at just after 2 p.m., Mr. Stiles welcomed everyone and began.

“This was made by the Amish,” he explained, gesturing to the post-and-beam kit. “Each joint is handmade with a saw, a mallet and a chisel. They sent this down to us and we’re doing a demonstration on how these joints were made years and years back. This was done in the Neolithic times, these joints. Each one took an Amish person about an hour to make. Very time consuming, but you’ll see, once the frame is up, even without pegs, it’s very, very strong.”

He selected six volunteers—all of them grown men—to help master carpenter Toby Haynes build the floor. A handful of children nearly tripped over themselves as they scrambled to assist.

The beams were too large for the small boys and girls, so they settled on hammering the pegs into the first wall. It was mostly their fathers and grandfathers who soon took over, taking a single swing to do what a child accomplished in 20.

“This is so exciting. I don’t know why, but it’s just a whole community thing,” onlooker Nancy Reardon mused. “You feel like you’re in the past somehow. It’s just the coolest thing I’ve done in years, and I’ve done a lot of cool things.”

Fifteen minutes later, the children dropped their hammers and four men stepped in. They yelled “Up!” and lifted the wall off the ground, fitting it into the constructed floor. The crowd erupted in hoots and applause. The first wall was a success.

So were the remaining three.

“You have opposing forces, the joints going in different directions, the triangulation in the corners,” explained Mr. Haynes, who built his own artist’s studio in England. “Each time you add a joint, you add an extra direction. So the rigidity is three-dimensional. One wall is kind of wobbly, two walls is strong, three walls is much stronger, four walls is unbreakable.”

Mallets in hand, a few participants circled the structure, giving some of the pegs a final whack.

“When can I do it?” Ike asked his father, Jay Comella, anxiously reaching for the tool. “When can I do it, Dad?”

“Here,” Mr. Comella said, returning the mallet to its original owner. “You see the building taking shape, Ike?”

“Kinda,” Ike responded distractedly, and then added, pointing up, “I wanna go to the top.”

“I’m not sure. We’ll have to refer to the man with the tool belt. He’s in charge,” Mr. Comella said, nodding to Mr. Haynes. “If there’s any more top work, we’ll do it.”

A few helpers organizing the beams for the roof smiled at the father-son exchange, and several audience members gathered closer to the barn to get a better look.

“They should do this every year. It would get bigger and bigger. Can’t you see that happening?” Ms. Reardon mused. “It’s almost an oxymoron, a barn raising in East Hampton, isn’t it? This opulent place. And everyone’s so thrilled to get down to the nitty-gritty and kind of do something from scratch instead of hiring other people to do it. Look how exciting. They’re doing it themselves.”

She gasped suddenly. “Oh my gosh,” she breathed out. “They’re putting the roof on!”

Collectively, the crowd inhaled and burst into another round of applause as a handful of men installed the finishing touches. And little over an hour later, the barn’s frame was finally complete.

“That was well done. Boy, oh boy,” participant David Yohay said.

“I’ve never seen a barn raising and this whole idea of doing it without nails, it’s extraordinary,” his wife, Ilia, added. “We’ve bought every single one of their books. David is such a superb craftsman that everything he builds is just beautiful. Beautiful, beautiful, beautiful.”

The Stileses are considering auctioning the barn and donating a portion of the proceeds to the Amagansett Historical Association, Ms. Stiles said. The kit usually runs $3,500 plus shipping, she said.

“We figure it’s a great idea for a little cottage in your backyard. You can use it as an artist studio or writer’s retreat, a pool house, home office, meditating, whatever,” she said. “It’s a pure, perfect little space. And I think everybody had a great time building it. Total family participation.”

As the crowd filed out, there was one noticeable straggler lingering behind.

“Do I get to keep this?” Ike asked Mr. Stiles, cautiously holding his wooden mallet up in the air.

“Yes, buddy, you get to keep it,” Mr. Stiles responded with a warm smile.


Ike grinned and skipped off to his father, wielding his prize, held high over his bouncing curls.

For more information, visit

You May Also Like:

Smile Farms Grows Christmas Joy

With Christmas right around the corner — and the demand for poinsettias reaching a seasonal ... 7 Dec 2019 by Stephen J. Kotz

Remove Bittersweet Vines And Gypsy Moths This Winter

The weather seems to be on track if you subscribe to the long-range forecast for ... 6 Dec 2019 by Andrew Messinger

Dan Michels, An Architect Who Knows Plants

Dan Michels worked for landscape designer Edwina von Gal from 2012 to 2014. During that ... by Kelly Ann Smith

A Butler’s Manor Plans Downton Abbey Weekend

A Butler’s Manor, the established bed-and-breakfast in Southampton, will launch its inaugural Downton Abbey Weekend ... 5 Dec 2019 by Hannah Selinger

Bedding, Where Comfort And Style Meet

Bedding is an unavoidable necessity in virtually all homes, but it is arguably one of ... 30 Nov 2019 by Andrew Bowen

Bonsai Is The Slowest-Growing Trend In Gardening

Are you a patient gardener who is willing to wait a while to see the ... 28 Nov 2019 by Andrew Messinger

Water Mill Resident Feuds With Gregor Over Drainage Easement

A Water Mill resident is furious after Southampton Town Highway Superintendent Alex Gregor and his ... 27 Nov 2019 by Greg Wehner

Meet A Gardening Guru

In 1993, landscape designer Frederico Azevedo founded Unlimited Earth Care, Inc. in order to create ... 21 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Robert A.M. Stern, Martin Architects Homes Shine In East Hampton House Tour

Five homes that are significant because of their architecture, their history or a combination of ... 15 Nov 2019 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

‘Sweeten’ Your Lawn And Garden With Lime

Did you know that you can add tons of fertilizer to your garden and lawn, ... 13 Nov 2019 by Andrew Messinger

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported