Dueling Applications Reflect Conflict Over Sagaponack Property - 27 East

Residence

Residence / 1378220

Dueling Applications Reflect Conflict Over Sagaponack Property

icon 1 Photo
Co-owners of a large oceanfront parcel in Sagaponack have submitted conflicting applications for the property. One proposal calls for a single-family residence in the northeast corner of the property, close to the road and in the middle of an agricultural easement. The second application looks to subdivide the property into four lots along the southern portion of the parcel, near the ocean.

Co-owners of a large oceanfront parcel in Sagaponack have submitted conflicting applications for the property. One proposal calls for a single-family residence in the northeast corner of the property, close to the road and in the middle of an agricultural easement. The second application looks to subdivide the property into four lots along the southern portion of the parcel, near the ocean. DCIM100MEDIADJI_0072.JPG

author27east on Jan 2, 2017

The co-owners of a large oceanfront parcel in Sagaponack have filed separate and apparently conflicting applications to develop the property—the crux of an argument that is expected to go before the State Supreme Court.

The 43.5-acre property, at 451 Daniels Lane, is owned by Sagaponack Realty LLC. Marc Goldman, one of the property owners, has filed a site plan application for a single-family residence on an approximately three-acre portion of the property, which has not yet been subdivided. The other application, from joint owner Milton Berlinski, is to subdivide the property to create four lots—none of which would be where Mr. Goldman proposes to put his house.

Due to the conflict, the Sagaponack Village Board has tabled both applications until its meeting on Monday, January 9.

“All the disagreement is about where the fourth lot should be and getting the subdivision done so the owners can build their houses,” Mr. Berlinski’s attorney, Eric Bregman, said in December.

According to Mr. Bregman, there is a consensus among the owners and the village on the conceptual location of the first three lots—across the southern portion of the property along the ocean. However, the location of the fourth lot has not been agreed upon, at least in part because of an agricultural reserve that would span over 65 percent of the overall property, as well as drainage and concerns about drainage and sight lines.

The site plan application calls for a single-family residence in the northeast section of the property, close to the road and in the middle of the agricultural open space easement already granted to the Peconic Land Trust. At a November meeting, Village Board members said they could not support placing the building lot in the easement.

“This village is not going to approve a plan that defies the Land Trust easement,” Sagaponack Village Attorney Anthony Tohill said in November. “No village would do that. No town. No municipality.”

The subdivision application proposes four lots, with the fourth lot to be placed north of the two lots on the southwestern portion of the property near the ocean, mainly because of drainage concerns. However, Village Board members have repeatedly said they would prefer the fourth lot to be positioned on the eastern boarder of the property behind the third lot.

A different subdivision application was first submitted to the village in 2007 and received preliminary approval, although the plan was never implemented by the property owners. The owners then submitted a site plan application for development of the northern portion property in 2015, but the plan was rejected by the Village Board, whose members cited a desire to keep the land open and visible from the road, as the proposed location for development was in an open space easement area. Under the LLC, joint owners Mr. Goldman, Michael Hirtenstein and Mr. Berlinski then filed a lawsuit to challenge the decision, and the lawsuit was later dismissed in court.

Now, with applications for the same property with conflicting locations for the fourth lot, the Village Board said it cannot make a determination.

“The board does not want two applications pending at the same time,” Mr. Tohill said at a December 12 meeting.
“You’re asking us to approve something we can’t approve,” Sagaponack Village Mayor Don Louchheim told both applicants regarding the question of who the proper applicant was.

The attorney for Mr. Goldman, Brian Descesa, argued that only the managing partner of the LLC—Mr. Goldman—had the authority to submit applications for approvals. However, Mr. Bregman said his client, Mr. Berlinski, did not agree with that interpretation.

Mr. Descesa said that he hopes by the next Village Board meeting, only one application will be before the board, as the State Supreme Court may have decided who has the right to apply to the village by then.

At a November board meeting, Mr. Louchheim noted that board members had expressed for several years that they preferred all four of the residential lots to be in the southern portion of the property. He said it was extremely unusual for a site plan to be proposed, particularly on a portion of the property that was protected by a land easement.

“Since [the site plan] isn’t part of an overall [subdivision] plan, the board, our attorney said, cannot approve a site plan where the site of a residence is in an area where residences are prohibited,” the mayor said, referring to the protected land.

The property was the subject of conflict in 2015 when the owners planted thousands of sapling Christmas trees on the property, screened by a perimeter of larger evergreens tracing the boundary of an agricultural easement on the property—and blocking the public’s view. Some believed the plantings to be an act of retaliation for the village’s denial of the subdivision application, but the trees were said to be a legitimate use in an agricultural easement.

You May Also Like:

Hampton Designer Showhouse Kicks Off July 19

The Hampton Designer Showhouse will return to Southampton this summer to benefit Stony Brook Southampton ... 1 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

Holiday House Hamptons Opens With White Party on July 12

Holiday House Hamptons will return to the South Fork on Saturday, July 12, for its ... by Staff Writer

East Hampton Art & Design Days Runs July 11-13

The inaugural East Hampton Art & Design Days, running July 11 to 13, will present a lecture series at Guild Hall on Sunday, July 13, featuring interior designers and landscape designers in conversation. The day will begin with a book-signing hour, followed at noon by Aerin Lauder in conversation with David Netto about her new book, “Living With Flowers,” which explores the role of florals in “interior design, inspired living, and timeless style.” “Designing Iconic Interiors and Architecture” begins at 1:15 p.m., with panelists Brian Sawyer, David Kleinberg and Victoria Hagan moderated by Jacqueline Terrebonne of Galerie. The designers will ... by Staff Writer

Marders Hosting Garden Talks Series Covering Range of Garden-Related Topics

Marders, a nursery and garden center in Bridgehampton, is hosting the Garden Talks series, covering a variety of topics relating to garden maintenance and caring for plants. These talks take place on Sunday mornings at Marders at 120 Snake Hollow Road in Bridgehampton, from 10 a.m. to 11 a.m. and are free to attend. Paige Patterson, a plant ambassador at Marders, has been running talks for over 10 years. The talks grew out of Patterson receiving questions relating to misconceptions about plants, as well as other aspects of gardening that she was unaware of when she first started. “I never ... by Dan Stark

East Hampton Historical Society To Host 19th Annual Antiques & Design Show Benefit

The East Hampton Historical Society is hosting its 19th annual Antiques & Design Show Benefit ... 30 Jun 2025 by Dan Stark

Fireflies Are Back for Summer — or Are They?

Like Fourth of July fireworks, cooling swims and relaxing vacations, fireflies are a sign of ... 26 Jun 2025 by Melissa Morgan Nelson

Gourds Are a Great Growing Project for Curious Kids — and Adults

It’s not too late to plant a few seeds that can be a great project ... by Andrew Messinger

David Harber and Michael Derrig Present 'A Celebration of Art in the Garden'

The David Harber studio in Oxfordshire, England, is bringing its outdoor sculptures to East Hampton ... 24 Jun 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Salvatore Piazzolla and Grant Wilfley Find Comfort in Southampton

Salvatore Piazzolla and Grant Wilfley found solitude when stumbling upon what inevitably was their dream ... 20 Jun 2025 by Tristan Dyer

Free Tuesday Webinar on 'Case Studies of East End Near-Zero and Net-Zero Residential Properties

Jean-Pierre Clejan, a renewable energy integrator specializing in zero-energy building, will host a free, live webinar, “Case Studies of East End Near-Zero & Net-Zero Residential Projects,” on Tuesday, June 24, at 4 p.m. The two-hour sustainability-focused continuing education unit program, with PDH, AIA HSW and GBCI/LEED credits available, showcases the ways architects have achieved net-zero and near-zero energy for their Long Island clients by incorporating energy efficiency, specifying hyper-efficient electric HVAC and optimizing roof/site plans to maximize solar production. In each case study, Clejan will review the embedded technology, key design elements, and real-world energy/financial performance of the built project. ... 18 Jun 2025 by Staff Writer