Homeowner Sues Town After Being Forced To Upgrade Septic System Unnecessarily - 27 East


Residence / 1716035

Homeowner Sues Town After Being Forced To Upgrade Septic System Unnecessarily

icon 3 Photos
Donald Woods at his home in North Sea.   DANA SHAW

Donald Woods at his home in North Sea. DANA SHAW

Donald Woods was required to install a state-of-the-art septic system in his North Sea home.  DANA SHAW

Donald Woods was required to install a state-of-the-art septic system in his North Sea home. DANA SHAW

Donald Woods was required to install a state-of-the-art septic system in his North Sea home.  DANA SHAW

Donald Woods was required to install a state-of-the-art septic system in his North Sea home. DANA SHAW

Brendan J. OReilly on Aug 3, 2020

A California attorney is suing the Town of Southampton after town employees told him his North Sea house lacked a valid certificate of occupancy and he spent tens of thousands of dollars to bring the house up to code — only to find out that there had, in fact, been a certificate of occupancy on file after all.

Donald Woods is seeking to recover the costs of bringing the house up to code and installing a state-of-the-art septic system plus the loss of income for the two summers that he could not rent out the house.

Mr. Woods, a litigator based in Santa Monica, and his wife, Los Angeles real estate agent Mary Beth Woods, purchased the Missapogue Avenue house in 2003, according to a letter he sent to the Southampton Town Council last August. The house had a second floor when they bought it, and they were provided with a 1961 certificate of occupancy, he wrote. But in late 2017, a code enforcement inspection led to them being notified that the second floor was never permitted and the certificate of occupancy was being vacated.

“The Building Department advised us that we could not occupy or rent the house until a new certificate of occupancy was obtained, and we had to bring the entire house and property up to code,” the letter states.

In addition to needing to legalize the second floor and obtain a building permit for it, they were instructed that they needed to install a new septic system to replace a cesspool, and the system needed to be an innovative/alternative on-site wastewater treatment system, Mr. Woods wrote.

A local contractor supervised the installation of the system and the legalization of the second floor in 2019 at a cost of $62,675 while the Woodses were in California for the winter. The vast majority of the cost was for the septic replacement.

Mr. Woods noted that he was made aware of the town’s rebate program for upgrading septic systems, but his household income exceeded the cap to qualify.

“The town has a $20,000 rebate, but it has a $1 million income limitation, which I — unfortunately or fortunately, depending on how you look at it — hit,” Mr. Woods said during an interview this week.

However, Clear River Environmental, the installer, informed him that the same cap would not apply to Suffolk County and New York State rebates of $10,000 each. He received both rebates, but that $20,000 did not come close to covering the total cost.

All the work going on at his property piqued his neighbors’ interest, and he told them that he was bringing it up to code to get a certificate of occupancy. He recalled that his neighbors, who had lived in the neighborhood for decades, assured him that the second floor had been finished for more than 40 years, and they said they would be shocked if it never had a certificate of occupancy.

So Mr. Woods investigated himself at the Building Department and found there was a building permit for the second story and a certificate of occupancy from 1965.

Then-Chief Building Inspector Michael Benincasa confirmed that the department had made a mistake in saying that the second floor needed to be legalized and a septic upgrade was required, according to Mr. Woods.

While the Building Department agreed to refund his $452 permit fee, he has still been subject to an “exceptionally large expense for no legitimate reason,” Mr. Woods wrote. He said Mr. Benincasa suggested that he ask the Town Council to waive the income cap on the septic rebate so he could be eligible for $20,000 in town water quality funds. Mr. Woods said that while $20,000 from the town and $20,000 total from the state and county will not cover all of his expenses, he would “probably” agree to settle the matter on that basis.

Mr. Woods filed a notice of claim — a precursor to a lawsuit — laying out his grievance with the town. Town Attorney James Burke acknowledged receipt of the notice of claim in October 2019 via email and wrote that he would discuss the matter with the town Community Preservation Fund manager to find an appropriate resolution.

Mr. Woods said no resolution came and accused the town of “stonewalling” him.

“I just came to the conclusion after about a year that they have no intention of doing anything about it unless I sue them,” he said.

He filed a formal lawsuit June 27 seeking no less than $80,000 for his expenses, lost rent and court fees.

In an email Friday, Mr. Burke said the town is not and has not stonewalled Mr. Woods.

“I have discussed this matter with Mr Woods on a number of occasions and I have brought his issue to the building department, our CPF office as well as the Town Board,” Mr. Burke wrote. “While I understand his frustrations, and I appreciate his efforts to resolve the matter, there are issues involved that complicate the matter. The town is still actively working on attempting to address the possible settlement for his claim as well as looking at the septic rebate program as a whole to see if there should be some amendments to it that would encourage additional participation so as to have a more significant positive impact on the environment. We are continuing those discussions and hopefully we can come to a proper resolution for Mr. Woods as well as providing an even better septic rebate program moving forward.”

Mr. Woods said that he doesn’t care how he gets paid, whether it be from the rebate program, the town budget or the town’s “errors and omissions” insurance.

“I thought I was entitled to recover my costs, and nobody has ever said … ‘You’re not entitled to that,’” he said.

Historically, he and his wife have rented out the house in the summer and reserved a couple of weeks in August for themselves. But he said they have now built a house on the water in Noyac in the Southampton Shores neighborhood for themselves. This summer, the Missapogue Avenue house has been rented out from March through September due to the COVID-19 pandemic leading people to find refuge on the East End.

The Missapogue Avenue house is an “itty bitty little” Levitown-style house that has only been used in summers with a postage stamp front lawn, according to Mr. Woods, and the property is one house removed from Big Fresh Pond.

“It’s total overkill,” he said of the innovative/alternative septic system that was installed under the front lawn. “Complete overkill. It’s typical of government regulation in my experience.”

You May Also Like:

Start With Quality Bulbs For The Best Spring Blooms

I start getting email notices for spring-flowering bulbs the spring before they’d flower and a ... 21 Sep 2020 by Andrew Messinger

StayMarquis Now Offering Property Management

StayMarquis, a vacation rental company based in Southampton Village, is expanding its offerings with a ... 19 Sep 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Force Bulbs To Flower Indoors

At this time of the year many gardeners are burned out. The hot and dry ... 14 Sep 2020 by Andrew Messinger

Dining Chairs: How To Choose The Best Fit For Your Home

Chairs are, without a question, a favorite of decorators and collectors alike. They often present the most prominent opportunity for infusing personal style within a space, and at a fairly significant scale. They intentionally, by design, take center stage and serve in part as the face of any room. And, our experiences with them are inherently intimate: With some exceptions, people generally spend the majority of their time enjoying any residential interior seated in some way. “Chair” is indeed a very broad category, for which there are seemingly limitless subcategories — lounge chair, armchair, desk chair, etc. But when it ... by Andrew Bowen

‘Landscape Pleasures’ Offers Shelter Island Garden Tour

The Parrish Art Museum’s 36th annual Landscape Pleasures, originally planned for June, is now happening ... 8 Sep 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Inspect Your Houseplants For Insect Damage

Even though the hours, days, weeks and months seem to be blending together, it’s not ... 7 Sep 2020 by Andrew Messinger

Westhampton Garden Club Offers Video Garden Tour

The Westhampton Garden Club was unable to host its biennial Home and Garden Tour this year due to the coronavirus pandemic, but now the club has improvised and is sharing a video tour of three local gardens. “They are beautiful and unique gardens, each with dedicated gardener doing something different,” Nancy Vigorito, the chair of the tour, says in the video tour’s introduction. “From stunning landscape architecture, to veggie growing and composting, to the most fabulous roses in town, I hope you will enjoy.” The tour begins in artist Ina Wijtvliet’s ornamental garden at her late 19th century home. The ... by Brendan J. OReilly

GARDEN NOTES: Prepare This Fall For Next Spring

There are some subtle and not so subtle changes going on in the gardens that ... 2 Sep 2020 by Andrew Messinger

Southampton Landscape Architect Perry Guillot, Fowler’s Garden Center Contribute To White House Rose Garden

The renovation of the White House Rose Garden unveiled last month predominantly features roses that ... 1 Sep 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Water Hogs Of The Hamptons

Until the second half of August, the summer of 2020 was a hot and dry ... by Michael Wright

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported