Amagansett School District To Receive A Piece Of Educational History - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1413057

Amagansett School District To Receive A Piece Of Educational History

icon 2 Photos

authorErica Thompson on Oct 24, 2014

The Amagansett School District will receive a piece of history next month as the recipient of a 19th-century schoolhouse donated by longtime residents of the hamlet, Huntington and Adelaide Sheldon.

The district plans to use the historic building as a “museum-type” resource for both students and the community, said Amagansett Superintendent Eleanor Tritt.

“We thought it was a wonderful opportunity for the children and community to preserve the building on our site,” Ms. Tritt said by phone this week. “So we’ve been working out the plans for what would be required to move the building, and we’re hoping it will be done sometime in the next month or so.”

The schoolhouse was built in 1802 by Samuel Schellinger and was originally located in the center of Main Street, according to East Hampton Village’s historic preservation consultant, Robert Hefner.

“Samuel Schellinger’s ancestors had been woodworking craftsmen in East Hampton for a number of generations,” Mr. Hefner wrote in a history of the Pantigo Windmill in East Hampton Village. Mr. Schellinger’s father, Jonathan, was a furniture maker and carpenter, and one of Mr. Schellinger’s first relatives in the area, William Schellinx—the Dutch spelling for Schellinger—had furnished the town prison in 1698.

A well-established builder during the early 1800s, Samuel Schellinger was responsible for building the Pantigo Windmill, originally on Mill Hill in East Hampton Village and the third windmill to occupy that site; and the Beebe Windmill, originally in Sag Harbor and now located in Bridgehampton, according to an engineering report prepared by Mr. Hefner.

In 1864, Mr. Schellinger’s Amagansett schoolhouse was moved to Atlantic Avenue near the cemetery, Mr. Hefner said. In 1881, a new school was built on the corner of Atlantic Avenue and Abrahams Landing Road near the present-day tennis courts. The old one Mr. Schellinger had built was auctioned off for just over $200 to Marcus Hand, who in turn sold it to Captain Joshua Edwards. Capt. Edwards placed the structure in his backyard on Atlantic Avenue, according to the Amagansett Library. He used the former schoolhouse as a place to store whaling gear, Mr. Hefner said.

After the captain died, the property, including the schoolhouse, was sold to Magda Merck Sheldon in 1938. The building has stayed in the Sheldon family ever since,

Inside is an original bench and desk made of pine boards. “It’s very nice, and very rare, to have something within a structure that’s been preserved like that,” Mr. Hefner said.

Ms. Tritt said the entire community is grateful for the donation and looking forward to the new addition to the school property. “It’s probably the only, or one of the very few, districts around the state that has the opportunity to house such an old building,” she said. “We’re all very excited.”

You May Also Like:

Vacant Water Mill Parcels Move for Over $6 Million

In Water Mill, four subdivided lots totaling 5.8 acres recently sold on September 17 for ... 14 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Waterfront Home Sells for $12 Million After 15 Years off the Market

For the first time in 15 years, the home at 501 Meadow Lane in Southampton ... by Staff Writer

Three Sales Close Within Village Business Districts

Three sales within East Hampton’s and Sag Harbor’s business districts closed last month, according to ... 7 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Sagaponack Estate Trades Hands for $13.65 Million

Earlier this year, a historic, circa-1899 Sagaponack estate traded hands for $13.65 million. On June ... by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Home Snapped Up for $10 Million Preconstruction

In the case of 85 Pheasant Drive in Bridgehampton, the 11,000-square-foot home went under contract ... by Staff Writer

Modern Meets Historic: Circa-1775 Sagaponack Home Sells for $9.5 Million

For its 250th birthday, the renovated and restored home at 412 Hedges Lane in Sagaponack ... by Staff Writer

D.A. Pennebaker's Sag Harbor Home Sells for $1.7M in Lightning-Fast Trade

When Linley Pennebaker Hagen sells a historic home in Sag Harbor, she knows it has ... 30 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Shelter Island Modern Waterfront Closes at $12.85M, Nearly Setting New Record

The $12.85 million sale of 1 Pandion Road now marks the second-highest price ever achieved ... by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Land Sells for $13.4 Million

A 3.4-acre property in Bridgehampton that had a house on it already, but was marketed ... 23 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Oceanfront East Hampton Estate Sells for $31.5M

An oceanfront estate in East Hampton recently sold for $31.5 million, making it one of ... 16 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer