East Quogue Neighborhood Holds Rich History East Quogue Neighborhood Holds Rich History - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1412553

East Quogue Neighborhood Holds Rich History

icon 10 Photos
authorKyle Campbell on Dec 8, 2014

Once used as a private hunting ground by former U.S. Congressman Stuyvesant Wainwright before being sold to developers for less than $300 an acre, Shinnecock Shores—or Pine Neck Point, as it’s referred to on nautical maps—in East Quogue is now home to a thriving community of roughly 270 homes.

Prior to leaving the community last year, Richard Andre, now a resident of North Carolina, was an active member of the Shinnecock Shores Association, as well as the neighborhood’s unofficial historian, having lived there at least part time since his family purchased a quarter-acre lot in the development in 1959. Based on personal experience, as well as research, Mr. Andre knows the neighborhood’s lore inside and out.

The private neighborhood was the brainchild of Mineola-based developers Abraham Peckman and Phillip DeNicola, who purchased the 95.6-acre property for $27,000 from owners Joseph and Elyse Martin in 1952, a rate of less than $283 per acre and $100 per lot, Mr. Andre said. “You couldn’t get your driveway paved for $27,000 today,” he added.

The Martins purchased the land from Mr. Wainwright—whose family owned the property for many years and lived in Wainscott—in 1950, shortly before he ran successfully ran for Congress on the Republican ticket and went on to serve four terms in Washington, D.C. The Martins paid $12,000 for pristine bayfront land, only to more than double their investment two years later, Mr. Andre said.

Almost immediately after purchasing the property from the Martins, Mr. Peckman and Mr. DeNicola, under the company names Marion Construction Inc. and Barracuda Shores Inc., began dredging the five canals that are now the linchpins of the community.

In 1953, the developers began selling off properties one by one; many were vacant, while others were sold with houses already built. Mr. Peckman and Mr. DeNicola even advertised the ready-made homes with a sample home on the corner of Josiah Foster’s Path and Montauk Highway, which remains one of the primary access points to the development today, though the sample home is no longer there.

Vacant properties sold for as little as $3,600, according to the Shinnecock Shores Association’s website, while homes could be purchased for as little as $7,990, according to records from former homeowners association historian Natalie Redleaf, who founded the association with her husband, Gil, in 1956.

Originally, the community was served by a single well on the north side of the neighborhood on a plot of land that is now a community gathering space known as the Waterworks.

In 1967, a group of 30 community members, led by Mr. Redleaf, purchased the Community Water Corporation to provide adequate drinking water for the neighborhood when the well became inundated with salt water. Eight years later, that corporation was absorbed by the Suffolk County Water Authority, which services the community today.

Over time, the community has filled out, with homes on nearly all the lots, most of which are still used as seasonal cottages, while some are occupied year-round.

“I think the biggest change came in the period of the late ’80s and ’90s and beyond,” Mr. Andre said. “That’s when you started to find people who didn’t feel it necessarily had to be a summer-only seasonal community—you could live there year-round, as long as you had a house that could withstand the winter winds coming off the bay.”

You May Also Like:

Neighboring Landowners Object As Sagaponack Farm Proposes Deer Fence

The Fosters say the deer population has grown to the point that they have no ... 15 Nov 2019 by Brendan J. OReilly

Elie Tahari’s Sagaponack Home Now Asks $39 Million

More than two years after it hit the market for $45 million and failed to ... 7 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Peter Matthiessen’s Former Sagaponack Home Could Become Center For Writing, Conservation, Zen

When author and naturalist Peter Matthiessen died in the spring of 2014, uncertainty reigned. His ... 6 Nov 2019 by Hannah Selinger

Attorney Jack Lester Helping OLA Help Renters Wronged By Landlords

For renters on the South Fork who feel that they have been mistreated by their ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Cee Scott Brown, Jack Pearson Join Compass

Cee Scott Brown and Jack Pearson, a duo of associate brokers who are veterans of ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Sagaponack Reserve Property Sells For $4.75 Million

The only available reserve land in Sagaponack, a 10.4-acre parcel, has sold for $4.75 million. ... 5 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Agency News: Saunders Hosts Food Drive; Paulina Keszler Joins Elliman

Saunders Hosts Thanksgiving Food Drive Saunders & Associates is hosting its fifth annual Can-Do Thanksgiving ... by Staff Writer

People Behind LLCs Must Now Be Disclosed When Buying Real Estate In New York

Limited liability companies buying or selling homes in New York State now have to disclose the identities of their owners, managers and agents under a new state law. Governor Andrew Cuomo signed the legislation into law in September and it became effective immediately. It applies to properties with between one and four living units, inclusive of houses, apartments and condos. If the property has mixed residential and commercial uses, such as a retail shop with an apartment on the second story, the law still applies. Names and addresses must be disclosed on the joint tax return that the buyers and ... by Staff Writer

Breakfast Presentation On New State Rental Law’s Impact On The East End Is November 19

The Southampton Business Alliance is hosting a breakfast at the Southampton Inn on Tuesday, November 19, to inform business owners of the impact of new state rental laws on the East End. Esseks, Hefter, Angel, Di Talia & Pasca LLP, Attorneys at Law, will make a presentation, which will be followed by a discussion. The new laws are part of sweeping housing reform that the New York State Legislature adopted in June, The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act of 2019. Though the legislation mainly dealt with protections for New York City rental tenants, it had some statewide implications and ... 1 Nov 2019 by Staff Writer

Hedges Lane Estate Sold For $15 Million After Several Price Cuts

A Sagaponack Village estate on coveted Hedges Lane sold for $15 million in October, according ... by Staff Writer

We are aware of an issue that prevents some people from commenting on articles on the website and are working hard to correct the problem. In the meantime, if you are having difficulty, try using a different web browser or upgrade the version of your current browser. Thanks for your patience.

logo

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported