Formerly a Foreclosure, A Sagaponack Estate Sells for $24.5 Million - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 2217364

Formerly a Foreclosure, A Sagaponack Estate Sells for $24.5 Million

icon 1 Photo
n Sagaponack, 219 Sagaponack Main Street sold for $24.5 million.  HARRIS ALLEN

n Sagaponack, 219 Sagaponack Main Street sold for $24.5 million. HARRIS ALLEN

authorStaff Writer on Nov 21, 2023

A 3-acre Sagaponack estate updated by Kristen Farrell & Co. sold this fall for $24.5 million, a significant return on investment.

The property, with pool and tennis, was originally developed between 2007 and 2009, and within a few years earned the dubious distinction of being the first residence in the Village of Sagaponack to be foreclosed on. Farrell saw something special in the distressed property and acquired it to realize its potential.

“You get a feeling about a house even before you can consciously identify what’s drawing you in,” she told The Express News Group this summer. “[This house] gave me that feeling.”

The residence was originally designed by architect Todd Nagy. For Farrell’s recent update, Sag Harbor builder Eric Hagermen served as project manager.

The main house is 17,600 square feet, inclusive of the lower level, and has nine bedrooms, 13 full bathrooms and five half-baths. There are five fireplaces to be found — four wood-burning and one gas. A great room, home office, outdoor living room, wine room, gym, spa, sauna, theater, playroom, five laundry rooms and mudroom are all part of the main house.

The pool house has a kitchenette, den, steam room, shower, bath, powder room, seating area and laundry. A pair of restored 20th century barns with board and batten siding offer a kitchenette, bathrooms, laundry and potential for an art or recording studio or a variety of other uses the new owners might imagine.

The property traded for $10.86 million in 2020, and then Farrell picked it up for $12.05 million in 2022. The newest owner is Sagg Main Sunshine LLC, according to Suffolk Vision Inc.

Christopher Covert, an associate broker and the managing director for Modlin Group Hamptons, had the most recent listing.

“It has been a fantastic experience working with our design and build client, and we are extremely happy for her with the outcome,” Covert said. “We look forward to working together on many more. And while this is a significant price point, it is on par with the other sales MGH has participated in both on- and off-market since opening the Hamptons operations.”

You May Also Like:

Oceanfront East Hampton Estate Sells for $31.5M

An oceanfront estate in East Hampton recently sold for $31.5 million, making it one of ... 16 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Water Mill Modern ‘Italian Masterpiece’ Sells for $9 Million

A new modern Water Mill home with 10,000 square feet of interior living space and ... by Staff Writer

The Gables: New Condo Community Rises in Westhampton Beach

Phase 2 is underway at The Gables at Westhampton Beach, the new 45-unit condominium community ... 10 Sep 2025 by Brendan J. O’Reilly

Noble Black Rejoins Corcoran

Top real estate agent Noble Black and his team, Noble Black & Partners, have joined ... 9 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Modern Water Mill Residence With Panoramic Water Views Sells for $22.5M

An ultramodern waterfront home in Water Mill with a rooftop deck that has panoramic water ... 3 Sep 2025 by Staff Writer

Jennifer Brew and Charlotte Sasso Join Saunders & Associates

Jennifer Brew and Charlotte Sasso, two Hamptons real estate veterans, have joined Saunders & Associates. ... 28 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Village Estate Sells for $16.5 Million

A traditional estate built in Southampton Village in the private community of Pheasant Pond in ... by Staff Writer

Water Mill Compound Sells for $17 Million

An approximately 3-acre Water Mill compound with two legal residences — including one that integrates ... 25 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

Hamptons Real Estate Roundtable August 2025

At the midpoint of summer, The Express News Group asked Hamptons real estate professionals from ... 14 Aug 2025 by Moderated by Brendan J. O’Reilly

CPF and CHF Revenue for the First Half of 2025

The Peconic Bay Community Preservation Fund and Peconic Bay Community Housing Fund brought in nearly ... by Staff Writer