Owners Wins Reprieve in Sag Harbor Zoning Battle

authorgavinmenu on May 18, 2016

By Douglas Feiden

A homeowner who has bristled at Sag Harbor’s new zoning code and its moratoriums has won a temporary restraining order from a state Supreme Court judge barring the village from enforcing the ordinances on his property.

At least in the short term, the TRO, issued on May 13 by Justice Gerard Asher, was a victory for Marius Fortelni, who has denounced the zoning amendments and moratoriums and alleged the village blocked him for four years from obtaining a building permit for his property at 14 Bluff Point Road.

The court order requires the village to show cause at a June 8 hearing why an order should not be entered that preliminarily enjoins Sag Harbor trustees from enforcing the new zoning, and residential and wetlands moratoriums and their extensions, on Mr. Fortelni’s parcel.

His attorney Alex Kriegsman has argued the laws and moratoriums are illegal, and that when a more restrictive zoning climate is illegally created, a property owner is covered by the earlier less restrictive zoning.

“We are pleased with the Court’s order as it underscores the strength of our case and the illegal actions by the Village,” the lawyer said. The TRO and expedited June return date indicates a “strong likelihood of success on the merits,” he said.

The village says Mr. Fortelni doesn’t have an active application on file.

“My opinion is, this is complete nonsense,” said Sag Harbor Mayor Sandra Schroeder. She declined to address specifics of pending litigation.

 

You May Also Like:

Sag Harbor Receives $1.8 Million Grant for Sewer Project

Sag Harbor Village has secured a $1,795,219 grant from the Southampton Town Community Preservation Fund’s Water Quality Improvement Plan that will help it cover a shortfall in its funding to extend sewer lines. “Even though the project is already underway, the town has been willing to help,” said Trustee Aidan Corish, who has overseen the grant writing and planning for the sewer expansion project. “They appreciate the fact that the village is committed to the project.” The village has been planning the expansion for several years, with the goal of using excess capacity at the plant, which mainly serves commercial ... 25 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Receives Town Grant for Marine Waste Collection

Along with a nearly $1.8 million grant for sewer line extension work, Sag Harbor Village has received a $78,816 grant from Southampton Town’s Community Preservation Fund Water Quality Improvement Plan to cover the cost of removing the waste collected by pump-out boats from boats visiting the village harbor. “The role and efficiency of the pump-out boat is a key piece of our program to promote clean water and adhere to the no-discharge regulations,” said Village Trustee Jeanne Kane, who oversees the village docks as part of her responsibilities on the Village Board. The village currently contracts with Quackenbush Cesspools Inc. ... 24 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Q&A: Tom Neely, Southampton Town Councilman-elect, Talks Traffic and Trains

Running alone on the Democratic ticket earlier this month, Tom Neely’s mathematical chances were stacked ... 21 Nov 2025 by Joseph P. Shaw

Plastic Cutlery Will Become Scarce in Sag Harbor After Board Approves New Restrictions

Countless kitchen drawers will become less crowded in the Sag Harbor area now that the ... 18 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Southampton Town Will Turn Down State Grant and Fund Noyac Road Sidewalk Project Itself

Even though Southampton Town is poised to pass on $2.93 million in state grant money, ... 17 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor ARB Asked To Consider Demolition of Historic House To Make Space for Affordable Apartments

Michael Trunzo, who is shepherding a proposal on behalf of his relatives to build a ... by Stephen J. Kotz

In Wake of Immigration Detentions, Advocacy Group Is Left With Many Holes To Plug

While the ICE sweep last week that ensnared a dozen immigrants has sparked outrage and ... 13 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Assemblyman Shiavoni To Talk About Critical Issues on 'East End Live'

New York State Assemblyman Tommy John Schiavoni will engage in a conversation about critical issues ... 12 Nov 2025 by Staff Writer

Federal Immigration Sweep in Hampton Bays, Westhampton Beach Sparks Protests

Residents and local officials have issued sweeping condemnations of federal immigration policy this week in ... 5 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Sag Harbor Sewer Extension Project Gets Underway

Contractors this week began work on a major infrastructure project for the Village of Sag ... by Stephen J. Kotz