Owners Wins Reprieve in Sag Harbor Zoning Battle

authorgavinmenu on May 18, 2016

By Douglas Feiden

A homeowner who has bristled at Sag Harbor’s new zoning code and its moratoriums has won a temporary restraining order from a state Supreme Court judge barring the village from enforcing the ordinances on his property.

At least in the short term, the TRO, issued on May 13 by Justice Gerard Asher, was a victory for Marius Fortelni, who has denounced the zoning amendments and moratoriums and alleged the village blocked him for four years from obtaining a building permit for his property at 14 Bluff Point Road.

The court order requires the village to show cause at a June 8 hearing why an order should not be entered that preliminarily enjoins Sag Harbor trustees from enforcing the new zoning, and residential and wetlands moratoriums and their extensions, on Mr. Fortelni’s parcel.

His attorney Alex Kriegsman has argued the laws and moratoriums are illegal, and that when a more restrictive zoning climate is illegally created, a property owner is covered by the earlier less restrictive zoning.

“We are pleased with the Court’s order as it underscores the strength of our case and the illegal actions by the Village,” the lawyer said. The TRO and expedited June return date indicates a “strong likelihood of success on the merits,” he said.

The village says Mr. Fortelni doesn’t have an active application on file.

“My opinion is, this is complete nonsense,” said Sag Harbor Mayor Sandra Schroeder. She declined to address specifics of pending litigation.

 

You May Also Like:

UPDATE: Protesters Line Highway in Hampton Bays To Decry ICE Raids

UPDATE: Friday, 10 a.m. Dozens of protesters lined the streets of Hampton Bays across from ... 5 Nov 2025 by Michael Wright

Sag Harbor Sewer Extension Project Gets Underway

Contractors this week began work on a major infrastructure project for the Village of Sag ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Funding Source Still Matter of Debate for Noyac Sidewalk Project

Plans for pedestrian enhancements, including sidewalks and crosswalks, for Noyac Road should come into sharper ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Cate Rogers, Ian Calder-Piedmonte Hold East Hampton Town Board Seats; Michael Hansen Elected Next Clerk

Incumbent Democratic East Hampton Town Board members Ian Calder-Piedmonte and Cate Rogers will retain their ... 4 Nov 2025 by Jack Motz

Welker Retains Seat; Doroski Ousts Stark; Suffolk County Term Limits Proposition Passes

Incumbent Democrat Ann Welker rolled to an easy victory in her quest for a second term representing the 1st District in the Suffolk County Legislature on Tuesday, while fellow Democrat Greg Doroski, who is currently a Southold Town councilman, edged incumbent Republican Catherine Stark to capture the 2nd District seat. Welker, whose district covers all of East Hampton and most of Southampton Town, collected nearly 70 percent of the vote to defeat her Republican challenger, Raheem Soto. Welker, who also ran on the Working Families Party line, received 11,716 votes, according to unofficial results obtained from the Suffolk County Board ... by Stephen J. Kotz

With Streets and Sidewalks Being Dug Up, Sag Harbor Is Something of a Mess

The pending expansion of the Sag Harbor sewer system is not the only infrastructure project ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sunrise Highway Westbound Lanes Reopened Tuesday After Five Days of Around-the-Clock Repair Work

Contractors worked around the clock for five days to repair the abutments beneath Sunrise Highway ... 31 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

A Sneak Peek at the Election Day Ballot in Southampton Town

The Election Day ballot for Southampton Town voters contains the races for Suffolk County legislator, Southampton Town supervisor and two council seats, the Southampton Town clerk, all five members of the Southampton Town Trustees, the highway superintendent and one of the four town justice seats, as well as uncontested elections for Suffolk County district attorney and Suffolk County sheriff, and two ballot propositions. Early voting polls remain open daily at Windmill Village in East Hampton, Stony Brook Southampton campus in Southampton and at St. Mark’s Episcopal Church in Westhampton Beach until this Sunday, November 2. On Election Day, polls will ... 29 Oct 2025 by Michael Wright

Sag Harbor Panel Tackles Parking Problems, Business Impacts at ‘Local Matters’ Discussion

Parking, or the lack thereof, which has become a perennial issue in Sag Harbor, was ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Planning Board Hears Update of Trunzo Affordable Housing Proposal

The Sag Harbor Village Planning Board on Tuesday revisited the application of the estate of ... by Stephen J. Kotz