Owners Wins Reprieve in Sag Harbor Zoning Battle - 27 East

Owners Wins Reprieve in Sag Harbor Zoning Battle

authorgavinmenu on May 18, 2016

By Douglas Feiden

A homeowner who has bristled at Sag Harbor’s new zoning code and its moratoriums has won a temporary restraining order from a state Supreme Court judge barring the village from enforcing the ordinances on his property.

At least in the short term, the TRO, issued on May 13 by Justice Gerard Asher, was a victory for Marius Fortelni, who has denounced the zoning amendments and moratoriums and alleged the village blocked him for four years from obtaining a building permit for his property at 14 Bluff Point Road.

The court order requires the village to show cause at a June 8 hearing why an order should not be entered that preliminarily enjoins Sag Harbor trustees from enforcing the new zoning, and residential and wetlands moratoriums and their extensions, on Mr. Fortelni’s parcel.

His attorney Alex Kriegsman has argued the laws and moratoriums are illegal, and that when a more restrictive zoning climate is illegally created, a property owner is covered by the earlier less restrictive zoning.

“We are pleased with the Court’s order as it underscores the strength of our case and the illegal actions by the Village,” the lawyer said. The TRO and expedited June return date indicates a “strong likelihood of success on the merits,” he said.

The village says Mr. Fortelni doesn’t have an active application on file.

“My opinion is, this is complete nonsense,” said Sag Harbor Mayor Sandra Schroeder. She declined to address specifics of pending litigation.

 

You May Also Like:

One More Marsden Street House Approved by Sag Harbor Regulatory Board

The laborious review of the houses proposed for an undeveloped parcel between Marsden Street and ... 1 Apr 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Routine Sag Harbor Village Budget Presentation Zoom Bombed

A routine meeting of the Sag Harbor Village Board, at which Village Treasurer Charles Bruschi ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Adam Potter's Mixed-Use Development Clears a Procedural Hurdle

Adam Potter’s proposed mixed-use development at 7 and 11 Bridge Street in Sag Harbor cleared ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Shortage of Required Development Rights Makes Building ADUs Difficult in Southampton

Evelyn Ramunno, a Sag Harbor native, is like many Southampton Town residents whose interest was ... 26 Mar 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

With Deadline Looming, Sagaponack Beach Rebuilding Seeks Temporary Exemption From Plover Restrictions

Southampton Town and the dredging contractor that is bolstering a 6-mile stretch of beach in ... by Michael Wright

North Haven Eyes Major Tax Hike as It Begins Budget Review

The North Haven Village Board took its first look Tuesday at a proposed $2.53 million ... 25 Mar 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Southampton Town Board Decides Sand Mine Amoritzation Law Will Not Require an Environmental Impact Statement

The Southampton Town Board on Thursday, March 20, completed a procedural step that means the ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Gobler Presents Annual Water Quality Report to North Haven Village Board

Dr. Christopher Gobler of Stony Brook University probably didn’t surprise anyone on the North Haven ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Pumping From Cellar to Storm Drain Legal in Sag Harbor

A small, two-story Greek Revival house at 57 Howard Street in Sag Harbor has caught ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Village Officials Weigh Changes to ADU Law

A handful of people turned out Saturday afternoon for a workshop sponsored by the Sag ... by Stephen J. Kotz