Planning Board Continues Public Hearing On Possible Southampton Village Courtyard Destruction - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1396136

Planning Board Continues Public Hearing On Possible Southampton Village Courtyard Destruction

icon 9 Photos

Bridgehampton students Ayamma El, Milo Youngerman, Patricia Figueroa and Amoy Webley in the Sprouts garden.   DANA SHAW

Bridgehampton students Ayamma El, Milo Youngerman, Patricia Figueroa and Amoy Webley in the Sprouts garden. DANA SHAW

Kyle and Melissa Lohr at their home in East Quogue on Wednesday morning. DANA SHAW

Kyle and Melissa Lohr at their home in East Quogue on Wednesday morning. DANA SHAW



Volunteers begin demolition on the inside of the home.  DANA SHAW

Volunteers begin demolition on the inside of the home. DANA SHAW

author on Aug 7, 2018

The Southampton Village Planning Board is keeping a public hearing open to allow more discussion on the possible demolition of a retail courtyard on Jobs Lane to make way for a pair of two-story commercial buildings.

After a lengthy conversation with opponents of the plan who packed Southampton Village Hall on Monday night, Planning Board Chairman Alan McFarland said the public hearing’s extension would allow residents and the board more time to review the proposed lot line modification and site plan. Mr. McFarland noted that the review was necessary to potentially rescind the board’s determination that an environmental study under the State Environmental Quality Review Act was not necessary—which it could do.

This will be the second continuation of East End Holdings LLC’s plan to remove the courtyard, which features a fountain, bench seating and six mostly vacant storefronts, and the construction of three new storefronts situated on the lot line in its place. The board originally sought to extend the public hearing after Susan Madonia’s testimony on July 2, indicating she was unaware of the scope of the project next door to her business and needed more time to hire legal counsel.

“And, immediately after the chairman granted Ms. Madonia more time, the board approved SEQRA,” said Jeffrey Bragman, Ms. Madonia’s attorney, at Monday’s meeting. “That’s the ultimate decision [the board] makes when considering its impact.”

Mr. Bragman, who was elected to the East Hampton Town Board last year, said the Planning Board essentially made it impossible for Ms. Madonia to comment effectively as a neighbor by making a SEQRA determination before she had an opportunity to weigh in.

The proposal was classified as Type I under SEQRA, which is reserved for projects that have the potential to have the most impact. With the classification, the board must act on any critique—no matter how minimal—a neighbor has on a project to see if a modification to a site plan is necessary to protect the environment or preserve community character.

Mr. Bragman called on the board to immediately rescind their negative declaration.

Gil Flanagan, the developer’s attorney, contends that the new construction “is not inconsistent with the character of the neighborhood” of the business district on Jobs Lane.

He pointed to a newer two-story, four-storefront building across the street at 58 Jobs Lane, of similar size. The proposed construction would nearly mirror the building’s size and facade—with lesser setbacks than the current courtyard configuration, concurrent with village code. The proposed commercial buildings also will allow access to the rear municipal parking lot, which few businesses on Jobs Lane do.

Mr. Flanagan also touted the project’s “first-of-its-kind advanced sanitary system in the village that will have substantial impact on [Lake Agawam].”

“Septic is going to be required anyway—it’s not a gift,” Mr. Bragman countered. All new commercial buildings in Southampton require sanitary system upgrades.

Ms. Madonia has operated her family’s antiques store on Jobs Lane for more than 30 years. She said she needs to hire an engineer to assess the potential damage the proposed construction at 38-42 Jobs Lane will have on the foundation of Ann Madonia Antiques, which is planned to be dug along a shared lot line.

“I want the best for the future of Jobs Lane development. … But I will be the first store on Jobs Lane to lose light on the second floor,” said Ms. Madonia.

The proposed height of the storefront would block 14 existing windows on the second floor of the neighboring building. Also, the storage of required mechanical equipment is positioned on a shared lot line adjacent to Ms. Madonia’s rear garden, and her store’s electrical service system will need to be relocated.

The Southampton Association echoed Ms. Madonia with the submission of 27 letters on the issue, which generally argue that the project cannot move forward in its current state. Opponents of the plan have called the design of the buildings to be generic and unlike the rest of Southampton Village’s rich history—factors that should have been considered by the board in its SEQRA declaration.

Evelyn Konrad, an attorney who lives in the village, said the construction would impair the important historical and aesthetic resources of the community’s courtyard space.

“The same architectural pattern … is replicated just east of the threatened courtyard, with a small but delightful brick walkway that leads in west to the entrance to Jildor shoe store, at the south to the Tripoli Art Gallery, and in the east to a number of fashionable retail stores and art dealers,” Ms. Konrad said.

Mr. Bragman—calling on his experience on the East Hampton Town Board—speculated that if the village decides that the private space is worth saving, it should work with the Town of Southampton to tap the Community Preservation Fund to purchase some of the privately owned space for the public.

“Over in East Hampton, we are doing our hamlet studies—if you don’t have these spaces, I can’t tell you how hard it is to re-create these spaces in the future,” he said of the walkable pedestrian areas in Southampton Village.

The public hearing will continue at 5:30 p.m. on Tuesday, September 4, at Village Hall. The matter also will be discussed by board members at a work session at 5 p.m. on August 27.

You May Also Like:

Calvin Klein Sells Southampton Estate For $84 Million

It appears that Calvin Klein quietly sold his Southampton Village oceanfront estate back in March ... 5 Jun 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Nearly $6 Million Sale Is Record For West Hampton Dunes Oceanside Home

A newly built oceanfront home on Dune Road in the Village of West Hampton Beach ... 2 Jun 2020 by Staff Writer

Beechwood Unveils The Latch Condominiums For Preconstruction Sales

Preconstruction sales began this week for The Latch Southampton Village, a 20-unit condominium community on ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Rental Scams Prey On People Seeking Housing

In recent months, a variety of rental scams have targeted people looking for housing on the East End. While many renters were able to avoid the schemes after they wised up to what was happening, others have fallen victim. Scammers, who could be from out of state or even in another country, often use online advertisements that make it difficult for authorities to track them down. While police reports are somewhat frequent, arrests related to such scams are rare. As the public and the police catch on to the latest scams, grifters change their tactics. The best defense for renters ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Thiele Votes Against ‘Too Broad’ Eviction Legislation

New York State Assemblyman Fred W. Thiele Jr. of Sag Harbor bucked his caucus last week when he voted against legislation to prevent evictions during the COVID-19 crisis. A member of the Independence Party who caucuses with the Democrats, Mr. Thiele said in a statement Monday that the legislation, which ultimately passed the Assembly, was too broad. “As was the case with the 2019 Housing Act, this legislation fails to make a distinction between primary residences and seasonal rentals,” Mr. Thiele said. “The vagueness in these laws could lead to the possibility that a court will interpret these provisions as ... 1 Jun 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

South Fork Landlords Concerned Eviction Moratorium Is Being Abused

Governor Andrew Cuomo’s moratorium on evictions during the COVID-19 crisis is overlapping with the first summer rental season that landlords are prohibited from collecting rent for a tenant’s entire stay upfront — though whether landlords really cannot get paid in advance is still a matter of debate. Either way, the convergence of the two issues had raised concerns among landlords and brokers alike that laws and executive orders meant to protect renters who are down on their luck can be abused by squatters who have the ability to pay but choose not to. The worry brought about by the state’s ... 26 May 2020 by Brendan J. OReilly

Dune Road Estate In Quogue Sells For Nearly $10 Million

A 2-acre oceanfront estate in the Village of Quogue recently changed hands for $9.85 million, ... by Brendan J. OReilly

Wainscott Residence With Views Of Pond And Ocean Sells For $10.5 Million

A 1.2-acre Wainscott property with a 7,300-square-foot residence that overlooks Wainscott Pond and has ocean views has sold for $10.5 million, according to The Real Estate Report Inc. Built in 1992, the residence at 60 Beach Lane has eight bedrooms and 7.5 bathrooms. The two above-grade levels have a formal dining room, a library, an open kitchen, a dining room and a den. Both the living room and den have double-height ceilings. The finished basement offers a gym, wine cellar and laundry. Also among the amenities are a heated gunite pool and spa. Michael Schultz had the listing for Corcoran. ... 25 May 2020 by Staff Writer

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices To Open Corporate Office On South Fork

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices is opening a corporate office in Noyac on June 1, the first ... 23 May 2020 by Staff Writer

Three-Building Modern Estate In Southampton VIllage Sells For $18 Million

A modern estate in Southampton Village that was completed last year recently sold for $18 million, just $1 million shy of its asking price, according to The Real Estate Report Inc. Three separate structures — a main house, a pool house and a guest house — on 1.9 acres total 9,100 square feet. The main house has five bedrooms and 5.5 bathrooms. A double-height living room with a fireplace, a dining area, an eat-in chef’s kitchen and a den are all light-filled through the wall of glass that overlook the backyard. On the lower level, there’s a bar/lounge area, a ... by Staff Writer

Welcome to our new website!

To see what’s new, click “Start the Tour” to take a tour.

We welcome your feedback. Please click the
“contact/advertise” link in the menu bar to email us.

Start the Tour
Landscape view not supported