Sag Harbor ARB, Architect, Joust over Jermain - 27 East

Sag Harbor ARB, Architect, Joust over Jermain

icon 1 Photo

author on Jun 29, 2016

[caption id="attachment_52858" align="alignnone" width="960"]Sag Harbor ARB - Jermain Avenue Plans to expand this 1854 "half-house" in the Sag Harbor Historic District sparked angry words and testy debate at the Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review meeting on June 23. Douglas Feiden photo.[/caption]

By Douglas Feiden

Question: What happens when a strong-willed architect and a strong-willed attorney butt heads with a strong-willed member of the Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review over the future of a 162-year-old home within the confines of the Sag Harbor Historic District?

Answer: A series of sharp and testy exchanges — interspersed with a smattering of choice insults — that underscore the gulf between a board mandate to preserve a historic house and streetscape and the efforts of an expansion-minded homeowner to redevelop and add on to his property.

At issue in the ARB meeting of Thursday, June 23 was a hotly debated proposal to expand the two-story, three-bay frame residence at 136 Jermain Avenue, which the board considers a small-scale Sag Harbor charmer that meshes neatly with the character and historical integrity of the village.

Every element of the existing historic house — from its clapboard cladding, side-gabled roof, six-over-six wooden sash widows, molded door surround and bracketed entrance hood bearing the date “1854” — would be retained under the plan advanced by homeowner Julian Ellison.

But it would get bigger, broader and bulkier: A 1994 description in the National Register of Historic Places calls the structure a “half-house.” Now, it would become a full house, swelling from 1,600 square feet to 2,710 square feet, a size permitted by current zoning, though subject to ARB approval.

Mr. Ellison’s application for a Certificate of Appropriateness, needed to obtain building permits, calls for erecting “additions,” as well as new windows, new foundations, a new driveway, retaining walls, swimming pool and the removal of a back section of the house. “Maintain existing historical structure,” the application says.

But is that visually, aesthetically and architecturally possible in light of expansion? Board members had doubts: They variously described the new additions as “overwhelming,” “burying” or “swallowing up” the old house.

“The rear section completely overwhelms the front section,” said ARB member Christopher Leonard.

“That’s your opinion,” retorted Anne Sherry, a Sag Harbor native and project architect who has designed, restored and built homes on the East End for 30 years.

“Well, it’s not an opinion, I daresay it’s a fact,” Mr. Leonard said.

Ms. Sherry said she “holds true to the square footage” she’s allowed to design by, and that the addition is “tucked behind hedges, and no one will ever see it,” a point Mr. Leonard disputed.

Sag Harbor attorney Alex Kriegsman, who represents the owner, said the proposal conforms to the new code, and that when an earlier version was presented at a prior ARB meeting, the panel objected and suggested it be redesigned to “go straight back,” which is exactly what Ms. Sherry did, to “preserve and honor the existing house.”

Yet the ARB still objected — despite dramatic changes and a complete redesign made to satisfy board concerns, Mr. Kriegsman said.

The scale remains “excessive,” said ARB Chairman Anthony Brandt, adding, “We’re trying to preserve a historic house, trying to keep it from being buried by additions.”

At one point, Ms. Sherry said her “frustration was super-clear.” The fireworks began at another point when she turned to Mr. Leonard and said, “Nothing is good enough.”

“No, it’s not that nothing is good enough,” he snapped. “You just haven’t designed anything that’s good enough.”

Ms. Sherry’s response: “Your arrogance is really, really unbelievable, and you should tone it down a little, Chris.”

“I’m old and cranky,” he said. “Yes, you are,” she said. “I have known the Sherry women for many years,” he said. “Well, this one’s not taking any s-h-i-t anymore,” she said.

Mr. Kriegsman then asked, “Is this a personal thing, do you need to recuse yourself?” Mr. Leonard said he did not.

After a contentious 35 minutes of debate, the owner’s representatives said they’d return with a model of proposed add-ons. The ARB tabled the application.

 

 

You May Also Like:

Organizers Say Southampton Town Officials Want To End Popular Drum Circle Gatherings in Sagaponack

The former Southampton Town supervisor said this week that he feels like the current Town ... 2 Jul 2025 by Michael Wright

WLIW-FM, NPR Stations Challenge Trump Executive Order Amid Growing Threat to Public Broadcasting Funding

WLIW-FM of Southampton has joined in a suit challenging President Donald Trump’s recent executive order, ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Planning Board Closes the Book on Potter DEIS

After having closed a public hearing last month on the draft environmental impact statement for ... 25 Jun 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Thayer Crowley, Barbour Reelected to Sagaponack Village Board in Uncontested Election

Sagaponack Village Trustees Carrie Thayer Crowley and William Barbour were reelected to their positions on June 20, in an uncontested election. Barbour earned a total of 19 votes (18 in person, 1 absentee), while Crowley garnered 16 votes (15 in person, 1 absentee). Barbour was first elected to the Sagaponack Village Board in 2011, as a write-in candidate and will be starting his eighth two-year term. Crowley was first elected in 2021, making this the start of her third two-year term. by Cailin Riley

Some North Haven Voters Say Poll Watcher Crossed the Line

Several people who voted in the North Haven Village election on Tuesday, June 17, have ... 24 Jun 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

North Haven Will Target Litter and Illegal Fishing Under Bridge

On the Sag Harbor side of the Lance Cpl. Jordan Haerter Veterans Memorial Bridge is ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Surfrider Signs Offer Way for Beachgoers To Keep Tabs on Water Quality at Swimming Holes

The South Fork’s ocean beaches, the crown jewel of the region and the main engine ... 18 Jun 2025 by Michael Wright

Boody, Rohn Victorious in North Haven; Incumbents Unchallenged in Sag Harbor

North Haven voters ousted incumbent Terie Diat from the Village Board on Tuesday, while reelecting ... 17 Jun 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Bethany Deyermond Steps Down After 16 Years as Member of Sag Harbor Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review

Bethany Deyermond, the longest-serving member of the Sag Harbor Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural ... by Stephen J. Kotz

On ‘No Kings Day,' Trump Opponents Turn Out In Force

Hundreds of people turned out for the “No Kings Day” rallies in downtown Riverhead, Hampton ... by Denise Civiletti