Transaction highlights, July 1 - 27 East

Real Estate News

Real Estate News / 1416718

Transaction highlights, July 1

author27east on Jun 28, 2010

26 Merriwood Drive, 
Wainscott, 
$1,965,000

This 2,000-square-foot contemporary is located on one acre, south of the highway on a quiet street.

The house was built in 1976 and consists of three bedrooms, an open kitchen, dining and living area. Seller purchased this house in 2004 for $1,151,000. At that time the wood ceilings and trim gave the house a heavy and dark aspect, and the tan siding was tired and unremarkable.

The seller improved this house by completely renovating the interior: including a chef’s kitchen, finished basement with laundry area, and updated bathrooms, giving the interior a crisp, clean, modern look. On the outside, the appearance was dramatically enhanced with new clear cedar siding, landscaping, Gunite pool with patio, outdoor fireplace and mahogany deck.

Assuming an interior construction cost of $150 per square foot (the typical renovation cost to completely renovate a home whose finished value is $300 per square foot), and adding $50,000 for the basement and $100,000 for outside improvements, seller’s renovation may have cost approximately $450,000. If so, then this sale represents a gross profit of about $365,000, or about 4 percent compounded annually, roughly equal to inflation.

165 Main Street, 
Sag Harbor, 
$3,172,500

This classic Victorian, built in 1865, is a mansard-roofed townhouse in the center of the village. It sits on a tiny .08 acre lot.

In keeping with the prevailing lifestyle of its day, the house has public rooms on the ground floor—living room, dining room, music room and kitchen in the back—and two bedrooms upstairs. There is also a third floor that was originally an attic.

Seller purchased this house in 2005 for $1,425,000 and renovated and furnished each room in a contemporary style. This kind of renovation can be quite costly, and it is difficult to assess seller’s renovation costs, which could easily have been $300 per square foot, or $900,000 for this 3,000-square-foot house.

If the renovation costs were in the $900,000 area, then the seller earned a gross profit of about $850,000, or about 6.5 percent compounded annually, in line with national averages. While this is not an extraordinary return, it is quite impressive considering the inherent difficulty of turning a very old home with small rooms and a layout which is not suited to today’s lifestyles into a very attractive contemporary-styled residence while retaining the essential historic character of the house.

285 Hill Street, 
Southampton Village, $3,200,000

This home near the center of the village was originally constructed in 1848. Like many historic homes, it sits on what has become a busy road.

The house, located on .9 acre, is a classic summer cottage in appearance. And, like other houses of the period, has many rooms that are small by today’s standards where an open floor plan is often favored.

The central, original portion of this house has a music room, sunroom overlooking the grounds, eat-in kitchen and living and dining rooms with fireplaces. There are six bedrooms, including one that is primarily a reading room in an upstairs turret, and a separate wing with game room and art studio.

The grounds contain mature landscaping and a circular pool with pool house. This old house has changed hands twice in the last 15 years, with each owner altering and expanding it to its present 4,500 square feet. Thus, it is difficult to estimate the cost of each renovation and expansion.

But this sale price, which is quite reasonable for a large and interesting home of this quality, illustrates that historic homes can be very good values if one is willing to live in a central and somewhat busy location.

You May Also Like:

Georgica Pond Modern With Storied Past Trades for $22 Million

A minimalist home sitting along the shoreline of Georgica Pond, which was famously at the ... 28 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Online Auction To Offer Dozens of Suffolk County Parcels in December

Approximately 100 parcels will be sold to the highest bidder during this year’s Suffolk County ... by Staff Writer

Sagaponack, Water Mill Rank Among Nation’s Priciest Zip Codes

The East End has done it again. According to PropertyShark’s 2025 list of priciest zip ... 21 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Waterfront Bay Watch Hotel & Marina Hits the Market for $10.5 Million

Have you ever dreamed of owning a waterfront hotel and marina? Now you can, to ... by Staff Writer

Vacant Water Mill Parcels Move for Over $6 Million

In Water Mill, four subdivided lots totaling 5.8 acres recently sold on September 17 for ... 14 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Waterfront Home Sells for $12 Million After 15 Years off the Market

For the first time in 15 years, the home at 501 Meadow Lane in Southampton ... by Staff Writer

Three Sales Close Within Village Business Districts

Three sales within East Hampton’s and Sag Harbor’s business districts closed last month, according to ... 7 Oct 2025 by Staff Writer

Sagaponack Estate Trades Hands for $13.65 Million

Earlier this year, a historic, circa-1899 Sagaponack estate traded hands for $13.65 million. On June ... by Staff Writer

Bridgehampton Home Snapped Up for $10 Million Preconstruction

In the case of 85 Pheasant Drive in Bridgehampton, the 11,000-square-foot home went under contract ... by Staff Writer

Modern Meets Historic: Circa-1775 Sagaponack Home Sells for $9.5 Million

For its 250th birthday, the renovated and restored home at 412 Hedges Lane in Sagaponack ... by Staff Writer