Government / 2138304

Support Emerges for Cromer's Parking Zone Change

icon 1 Photo

author on Aug 15, 2018

If Tony Lawless could get the zoning change he needs at Cromer’s Country Market just based on people’s endorsements of his charitable works and excellent sandwiches, he would probably already have it.

But the Southampton Town Board, which held a public hearing Tuesday on a zoning change for the next-door residential lot where Mr. Lawless is seeking to legalize a parking area used for two decades as employee parking, is poised to tap the Southampton Town Planning Board for some conditions on the approval of that zoning change.

The change would switch the residential zoning (R-40) of the .1-acre property, known as 5 Cedar Lane, to hamlet/commercial (HC) zoning. The small cottage on the property would be used as an office space for the market employees. Mr. Lawless’s attorney, Timothy McCulley, said Mr. Lawless intends to eventually merge the two lots together if the zoning change can be achieved.

Screening for the neighbors and impervious surface area requirements that come with HC zoning are examples of conditions that the planning board may require, according to Janice Scherer, Southampton’s assistant town planner. The conditions would be accomplished through a Southampton Town Planning Board proceeding, Ms. Scherer told the Southampton Town Board on Tuesday.

“It’s pre-existing non-conforming,” she said. “By changing the zoning, you would actually make it conforming.”

During Tuesday’s public hearing, several Noyac residents were on board with the rezoning.

“I’m in support of changing it. It seems like a simple thing to do,” said John Arendt, who also said he hoped more could be done to calm traffic in the area.

Elena Loreto, president of the Noyac Civic Council, called the change “a win-win for all.”

“The town gets to dictate exactly what can be done there,” she said. “It’s a plus for Cromer’s Market. This will allow Tony to improve the building itself. ... He is willing to work with the town. Please grant this change.”

But not everyone endorsed the change. Frank Quatela, a resident of Cedar Lane, said the neighbors are “dealing with increased traffic, runoff, debris and garbage. … We’re asking for a little more consideration.”

Asked by Town Supervisor Jay Schneiderman to respond to those concerns, Mr. McCulley said, “That’s the object of this whole proposal — to straighten this out.”

The Town Board voted to close the public hearing and wait for the planning board’s input in the next 30 days before making a decision on the zoning change.

You May Also Like:

New Law Requires Owners of Historic Buildings in Sag Harbor To Document Historic Features Before Renovation Work

The stories are almost commonplace: People seeing dumpsters full of old windows, doors and trim outside historic houses in Sag Harbor that are being renovated. On Tuesday, the Village Board adopted a proposal that it hopes will help put an end to that practice. It will require the owner of a historic house to complete a construction protocol and preservation plan before undertaking any major renovation. That document could be a few sentences or several pages long, depending on the type of work being considered. The amendment requires that the plan outlines “with specificity the detailed preservation, rehabilitation, restoration and/or ... 10 Dec 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Village Board Authorizes a Flurry of Studies of Key Issues

Members of the Sag Harbor Village Board have long cited the need for objective data ... 9 Dec 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Marsden Lot Clearing Is Jarring, But Legal, Sag Harbor Officials Say

Heavy tree-clearing equipment rolled onto the roughly 4.13-acre lot on Marsden Street in Sag Harbor ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Late-Arriving Permit Means Sag Harbor Dock Replacement To Be Delayed a Year

The good news is that the State Department of Environmental Conservation has issued a permit ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Planning Board Has Questions as Redevelopment of 2 Main Street and 22 Long Island Avenue Come Into Focus

The Sag Harbor Village Planning Board had a number of questions as the board reviewed ... 3 Dec 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Planners Hear Request To Split Potter Application

Adam Potter’s plan for a mixed-use development on property at 7 and 11 Bridge Street ... 2 Dec 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Building Inspector Steps Down; New Police Officers Hired

There was a shakeup this week in the Sag Harbor Village Building Department: Tien Ho So, who has served as the village’s building inspector since March 2024, submitted his resignation to the board at a special meeting on November 25. The resignation takes effect on February 1, 2026, and Mayor Tom Gardella said that So, while not working in the office, would be available to provide assistance as needed up until that date. The village has hired former building inspector Tom Preiato to replace So on a part-time basis as needed for the short term. Preiato, who was East Hampton ... 1 Dec 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Receives $1.8 Million Grant for Sewer Project

Sag Harbor Village has secured a $1,795,219 grant from the Southampton Town Community Preservation Fund’s Water Quality Improvement Plan that will help it cover a shortfall in its funding to extend sewer lines. “Even though the project is already underway, the town has been willing to help,” said Trustee Aidan Corish, who has overseen the grant writing and planning for the sewer expansion project. “They appreciate the fact that the village is committed to the project.” The village has been planning the expansion for several years, with the goal of using excess capacity at the plant, which mainly serves commercial ... 25 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor Receives Town Grant for Marine Waste Collection

Along with a nearly $1.8 million grant for sewer line extension work, Sag Harbor Village has received a $78,816 grant from Southampton Town’s Community Preservation Fund Water Quality Improvement Plan to cover the cost of removing the waste collected by pump-out boats from boats visiting the village harbor. “The role and efficiency of the pump-out boat is a key piece of our program to promote clean water and adhere to the no-discharge regulations,” said Village Trustee Jeanne Kane, who oversees the village docks as part of her responsibilities on the Village Board. The village currently contracts with Quackenbush Cesspools Inc. ... 24 Nov 2025 by Stephen J. Kotz

Q&A: Tom Neely, Southampton Town Councilman-elect, Talks Traffic and Trains

Running alone on the Democratic ticket earlier this month, Tom Neely’s mathematical chances were stacked ... 21 Nov 2025 by Joseph P. Shaw