East Hampton Historical Farm Museum Hosts 19th Century Inspired Baseball Game - 27 East

Sag Harbor Sports / 2143967

East Hampton Historical Farm Museum Hosts 19th Century Inspired Baseball Game

icon 19 Photos

The baseball - lighter, softer, stitched differently and more akin to a softball - used during an Old Time Baseball Game played using 1864 rules at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

The Mutuals of New York (from the Old Bethpage Restoration) with the Atlantics of Brooklyn (wearing their 1864 championship uniforms, from the Smithtown Historical Society) with their umpire prior to an Old Time Baseball Game played using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

The Mutuals pitcher throws from a shorter 45 feet during an Old Time Baseball Game played between the Mutuals of New York and the Atlantics of Brooklyn using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

The Brooklyn Atlantics second baseman gets the throw too late to cut off the steal during an Old Time Baseball Game played between the Mutuals of New York and the Atlantics of Brooklyn using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

The Brooklyn Atlantics pitcher throws during an Old Time Baseball Game played between the Mutuals of New York and the Atlantics of Brooklyn using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

Umpire Danny Davey - umpires were at the time were not allowed to be on the field - during an Old Time Baseball Game played between the Mutuals of New York and the Atlantics of Brooklyn using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

A Brooklyn Atlantics baserunner is picked off at second - baseball gloves had not yet been invented - during an Old Time Baseball Game played between the Mutuals of New York and the Atlantics of Brooklyn using 1864 rules, hosted by the East Hampton Historical Farm Museum at Herrick Park on Saturday, 6/29/19

Southampton Soccer Club's boys 2005 team is one of three squads it's sending to Sweden to compete in the Gothia Cup later this month.

Southampton Soccer Club's boys 2005 team is one of three squads it's sending to Sweden to compete in the Gothia Cup later this month.

Pierson's Sophia Mancino fights to get a shot off during the Lady Whalers' game against the Port Jefferson Lady Royals as part of Pierson Spirit Night on Friday, 1/25/19

Pierson's Sophia Mancino charges to the hoop during the Lady Whalers' game against the Port Jefferson Lady Royals as part of Pierson Spirit Night on Friday, 1/25/19

The throw comes too late for Pierson's Sophia Mancino to make the tag at home as the Lady Whalers took on the Lady Baymen of Hampton Bays at Mash ashimuet Park on Friday afternoon, 3/29/19

Pierson's Sofia Mancino fields a return during a playoff volleyball match late last year. Michael Heller photo

Pierson's Sofia Mancino fields a return during a playoff volleyball match late last year. Michael Heller photo Pierson's Sophia Mancino fields a return during their Suffolk County Class C Volleyball Final against the Lady Tuckers of Mattituck at Shoreham-Wading River High School on Monday, 11/5/18

Jeffrey Gregor slides in ahead of a throw to home plate. Michelle Malone photos

Jeffrey Gregor slides in ahead of a throw to home plate. Michelle Malone photos

author on Jul 1, 2019
They say that “everything old is new again” and that was certainly the case at East Hampton’s Herrick Park this weekend. On Saturday, a 19th-century throwback baseball game brought out... more

You May Also Like:

Hamptons Youth Triathlon Sees Over 160 Finishers for Second Year in a Row

For the second year in a row, over 160 youth triathletes crossed the finish line ... 15 Jul 2025 by Drew Budd

HBCL All-Stars Defeat the ACBL All-Stars; Southampton's Quintano Named MVP

The Hamptons Collegiate Baseball League All-Stars held on to an 8-5 victory over the Atlantic ... by Drew Budd

Fluke and Bluefins Keeping Rods Bent

There’s plenty of good fishing to be had around the South Fork as we get ... by MIKE WRIGHT

If the Shoe Fits, Should I Buy It for Pickleball?

Pickleball shoes have hit the market, big time, this summer. On the East End, we’re ... by Vinny Mangano

HCBL Stars Set to Battle ACBL’s Finest in Sag Harbor Showdown

The Hamptons Collegiate Baseball League will play its 12th All-Star Game this Saturday, July 12, ... 9 Jul 2025 by Drew Budd

The HCBL's Best Kept Secret: Its Announcers

On a sun-soaked evening at Sag Harbor’s Mashashimuet Park, amid the familiar ambient noises of ... by Drew Budd

Has the Market Peaked for Older Pickleball Players?

Pickleball used to be referred to as the “geriatric Sun Belt sport.” Most of its ... 8 Jul 2025 by Scott Green

Sag Harbor Little League's 10U Baseball All-Stars Fall to North Shore in District 36 Playoffs

A 7-5 loss to the North Shore National Little League All-Stars eliminated the Sag Harbor ... by Drew Budd

An Alternative to the Crowds

Are you looking for an outdoor adventure in the Hamptons where you won’t experience a ... by Marianne Barnett

Sag Harbor's 10U Baseball All-Stars Are Moving On, 12U Team Wraps Up Pool Play

Sag Harbor Little League’s 10-and-under All-Stars have qualified for the single-elimination playoffs in the District ... 2 Jul 2025 by Drew Budd