SANS Communities Seek Special Zoning Designation From Sag Harbor Village - 27 East

Sag Harbor Express

SANS Communities Seek Special Zoning Designation From Sag Harbor Village

icon 3 Photos
Errol Taylor, the president of the Ninevah Beach property owners association, called for the creation of a special overlay zoning district for Ninevah Beach, Sag Harbor Hills, and Azurest. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Errol Taylor, the president of the Ninevah Beach property owners association, called for the creation of a special overlay zoning district for Ninevah Beach, Sag Harbor Hills, and Azurest. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Lisa Desamours, president of the Sag Harbor Hills property owners association, supported the creation of a special zoning district for the three historically Black beachfront communities, Azurest, Ninevah Beach, and Sag Harbor Hills. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Lisa Desamours, president of the Sag Harbor Hills property owners association, supported the creation of a special zoning district for the three historically Black beachfront communities, Azurest, Ninevah Beach, and Sag Harbor Hills. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Although many modest houses remain in Azurest, many, like this one on Milton Avenue, are being renovated and expanded. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Although many modest houses remain in Azurest, many, like this one on Milton Avenue, are being renovated and expanded. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

authorStephen J. Kotz on Aug 10, 2022

Representatives of Sag Harbor’s traditionally Black beachfront communities appeared before the Village Board on Tuesday, August 9, to make their case for the creation of a special zoning overlay district for the Azurest, Sag Harbor Hills and Ninevah neighborhoods.

They believe the move will help protect both the character of their communities and the property rights of homeowners without the restrictions that a historic district could impose.

Errol Taylor, the president of the Ninevah Beach Property Owners Association, said the proposal to adopt zoning restrictions for the neighborhood to limit house sizes and the number of accessory structures was supported by more than 95 percent of residents, who voted 204-10 in favor of establishing an overlay district in a recent survey.

He said the proposal was honed by the Tri-Community Working Group, made up of the three developments’ presidents and 14 other residents, over the last year and a half. The committee looked at similar communities. “We met with everyone who would meet with us,” he said. “We did our homework.”

Although the board has yet to schedule a formal hearing on the proposal, it heard detailed explanations from Taylor and Lisa Desamours, president of the Sag Harbor Hills Improvement Association. Steve Williams, president of the Azurest Property Owners Association, also took part in the effort, although he did not speak at Tuesday’s meeting.

The board also heard a rebuttal from Georgette Grier-Key, the director of the Eastville Community Historical Society, who urged the board to continue to weigh the advantages historic district protection would provide.

Grier-Key also read a letter from Renee Simons, a Sag Harbor Hills resident and member of the SANS organization, who has been a strong advocate for a historic district.

Mayor Jim Larocca, who had placed the item on Tuesday’s agenda for discussion, said the board would consider both requests.

The effort to create the overlay district grew out of an earlier push to have the three neighborhoods added to Sag Harbor’s historic district, or made into a new historic district, largely because of their cultural significance as places where Black people were able to buy property and build vacation houses in the post-World War II era, often self-funding their efforts because of racist lending practices.

Calls to protect the neighborhood with a historic district began when speculators began to target the neighborhoods because they could find inexpensive houses to tear down and replace with much larger ones.

Although the neighborhoods have received state and federal historic designations, they have yet to be designated as a village historic district. That was derailed after some residents voiced fears that such status would restrict their ability to replace or renovate their homes and unlock the value of their underlying real estate.

When the neighborhood associations sponsored public forums on preservation efforts, “not a single person said it was the architecture, not a single person said it was about saving the bungalows dotting our neighborhoods,” Taylor said. Instead, he said, their interest was directed at finding ways to protect the character of their neighborhoods, where people enjoy a comfort level that comes with knowing their neighbors.

Desamours said the overlay district would be built on three pillars: stabilization, enforcement, and representation.

To stabilize the community, the overlay district would impose a strict 4,000-square-foot size limit on house size, no matter how large the lot, and limit to two the number of accessory structures that could be built, no matter how large the lot size. Special uses, such as a bed-and-breakfast, would be prohibited, and clearing restrictions strictly enforced.

To help with enforcement, applications for variances or other village review would require that property owners notify their neighbors, as is the case now, but if the steps were not taken in a timely manner, the board hearing the application would be required to postpone the application to a future meeting.

Residents would be permitted to submit photographs of alleged violations to village enforcement officers to trigger an investigation, and the association presidents would meet quarterly with village enforcement officers, to foster a working relationship.

Finally, although Desamours acknowledged that a growing number of residents from the neighborhoods have been appointed to village regulatory boards, she said the time had come to codify the practice.

Not everyone was in agreement that the overlay district would be the best course to follow.

Grier-Key read a lengthy letter from Simons, an early champion of the historic district, outlining efforts to protect the character of the community dating to 2016.

She argued that the overlay approach, based largely on existing code, ignored the ability of a historic district to prevent “erasure or elimination of an area over time,” would allow unlimited demolition, and would not be permanent and could be undone by a future board.

In her own remarks, Grier-Key said as state certified local government, the village was required to move forward with efforts to protect historic resources and asked why the village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review had failed to act on the SANS request.

Sarah Kautz, preservation director for Preservation Long Island, also spoke, saying that the organization supported the idea of an overlay district but adding that the village’s ability to create historic districts could achieve the same, if not better, results.

You May Also Like:

Sag Harbor Village Police Reports for the Week of July 3

SAG HARBOR VILLAGE — Village Police arrested Kherly C. Rivadeneira Juela, 26, of Hampton Bays at about 6 a.m. last Thursday on misdemeanor DWI charges after an officer said he found her sleeping behind the wheel of a 2020 BMW on the side of the road on Main Street, engine off. The officer reported rapping on the window several times, until Rivadeneira Juela woke up. According to police, at that point, Rivadeneira Juela started the engine. The officer spoke with Rivadeneira Juela, whom he said in his report, “was not making sense.” She appeared intoxicated and failed sobriety tests, police ... 2 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

County Warns of Stepped-Up DWI Enforcement for Summer, Encourages Drivers To Take Ride Shares When Drinking

Suffolk County Sherriff Erron Toulon and County Executive Ed Romaine warned drivers this week that the county will be rolling out a new anti-DWI campaign that will feature stepped-up enforcement of drinking and driving laws and public outreach to discourage drunk driving. The sheriff’s office said that the county will step up patrols focusing on DWI enforcement and on-road sobriety checkpoints throughout the county, starting this coming weekend and continuing throughout the summer. Toulon said his office’s STOP DWI unit is on pace to break a record number of DWI arrests this year and encouraged young adults to turn to ... by Staff Writer

Student Clothing Designers Take Their Cue From History

Last year, the summer exhibit at the Annie Cooper Boyd House, “Sag Harbor Summers: 1882-1907,” ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Archeological Dig Literally Uncovers History Below Our Feet

Attendees of the Sag Harbor Historical Museum’s annual gala on July 12 have been asked ... by Stephen J. Kotz

A Long Gone Fort Is Focus of Sag Harbor Historical Museum Quest

Randy Croxton has a good view of the Old Burying Ground next to the Old ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Basseches and Campomar Are Headliners of Impressive Pierson Graduating Class

It’s hard to imagine two students more accomplished than Kai Basseches and Milla Campomar. The ... by Cailin Riley

Gold Stars and Dunce Caps

GOLD STAR: To the Group for the East End, for continuing efforts to bolster the osprey population on the East End, one of the greatest conservation success stories. The Group has worked for more than 30 years to help the raptor’s recovery and has been assisted by The Nature Conservancy, Eastern Long Island Audubon, North Fork Audubon, and Seatuck Environmental Association, among other groups. Likewise, credit to PSEG Long Island for a proactive effort to protect utility poles while providing nesting opportunities and relocating nests when necessary. The fish hawk was an endangered species in New York State in the ... by Editorial Board

Organizers Say Southampton Town Officials Want To End Popular Drum Circle Gatherings in Sagaponack

The former Southampton Town supervisor said this week that he feels like the current Town ... by Michael Wright

WLIW-FM, NPR Stations Challenge Trump Executive Order Amid Growing Threat to Public Broadcasting Funding

WLIW-FM of Southampton has joined in a suit challenging President Donald Trump’s recent executive order, ... by Stephen J. Kotz

Sag Harbor's 10U Baseball All-Stars Are Moving On, 12U Team Wraps Up Pool Play

Sag Harbor Little League’s 10-and-under All-Stars have qualified for the single-elimination playoffs in the District ... by Drew Budd