Save It First - 27 East

Opinions

Save It First

Editorial Board on Oct 4, 2022

Couples experience it all the time: You agree on the big picture but can’t stop arguing about the details. It can take a wonderful thing — a Hawaiian vacation, a kitchen remodel — and turn it into sheer agony.

Sag Harbor Village has a terrific opportunity, full of prestige and community benefit, to pay tribute to the brightest star in the village’s literary firmament. It’s an idea everyone loves. But if there’s anything that will drag it down, it’s fighting over how to make it happen.

Preserving the Sag Harbor home where Nobel Prize-winning author John Steinbeck spent much of his late life, and wrote a beloved chronicle of an American expedition, as well as a novel set in a very familiar waterfront town, has almost everyone’s support. Despite the eight-figure price tag, since the modest Steinbeck abode sits on land that has soared in value, a dogged group of local residents have taken bookstore co-owner Kathryn Szoka’s idea and run with it. With the involvement of Southampton Town and its Community Preservation Fund, plus a state grant, and interest from the University of Texas, it’s plausible that it might be preserved as a writer’s retreat.

Mayor James Larocca has jumped on the bandwagon, and rocked it a bit. The mayor’s enthusiasm for the project is sincere — his appreciation for Steinbeck was a youthful obsession — and he has pledged the village’s help in getting the job done. But he’s also been critical of details about how the preserved property might be managed, and how the community can most benefit.

Village support is essential, and there’s no reason for things to turn adversarial when everyone is pulling in the same direction. The mayor’s best play is to set aside any concerns and turn his focus instead to helping the purchase across the finish line. It’s going to be in the neighborhood of $15 million, and the town’s CPF won’t be able to pay that much — a cold appraisal of the property doesn’t consider who lived there — so until enough money is raised and an offer is accepted, all the chatter about how the property might be used is premature. It could, sadly, be for naught.

A discussion last week of Steinbeck’s time in Sag Harbor brought Richard Hart, a retired professor at Bloomfield College in New Jersey and a member of the editorial board of The Steinbeck Review, to town. Standing comfortably sheltered from any local ill winds, he said this week, “I am so very hopeful that the purchase of the Bluff Point property reaches a successful outcome. I strongly suspect it is what Steinbeck would have wanted, particularly inasmuch as it will provide writers a place of quiet and reflection and bring school kids and others into the literary world of one of America’s truly great writers.”

Kathryn Szoka has called the property “a jewel in our midst” — there’s plenty of time to talk about how best to polish it. First, let’s save it.

You May Also Like:

Standing Firm

Even South Fork residents who have issues with U.S. Representative Nick LaLota’s positions on some important issues should give credit where it’s due: In one respect at least, the Republican 1st District congressman has stuck to his guns on an issue that deserves bipartisan attention — the unfair cap on state and local tax deductions on federal tax returns. SALT, in short, has been a talking point for LaLota since he emerged as the GOP’s successor to Lee Zeldin for the House seat, even as much of his other rhetoric has toed the line drawn by Republican leaders in Washington, ... 21 May 2025 by Editorial Board

The Toll on Veterans

This Memorial Day, as we honor those who sacrificed all for the country, it’s also important to take stock of how well the nation cares for our living veterans. Cuts already made to the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, and further cuts that the Trump administration has floated, make clear that we are not giving our all, and perhaps not enough. In fact, the federal government under Donald Trump is running fast in the wrong direction. Elon Musk’s so-called Department of Government Efficiency saw to it that 2,400 probationary VA staff members were laid off, and the Trump administration set ... by Editorial Board

The Bounty That Surrounds Us

When the Community Preservation Fund gets its well-earned accolades for the good it has done for the East End in the past quarter century, the focus often is on the preservation of land, keeping it from being developed and thus protecting the region from becoming too intensely suburban. Without question, that effort to maintain the region’s rural appeal is a significant, historic accomplishment. But sometimes we forget the importance of the CPF in keeping agriculture alive as a major contributor to the region’s agroeconomy, which has quality-of-life benefits of its own for both farmers and those who live among their ... 14 May 2025 by Editorial Board

'Solving' the Traffic

It’s not fair to suggest that the last two weeks, when Southampton Town, with Suffolk County’s blessing, tested some various strategies for managing the flow of traffic westward in the afternoon rush hours, will be enough to “solve” anything. This is a Gordian knot, but Charlie McArdle is no Alexander the Great, sword in hand, ready to cut the snarl free. At best, the town’s highway superintendent is diligently picking at various parts of the heap, hoping to loosen it a tiny bit. Suffolk County officials were active participants this time, which is helpful, and they will be sitting down ... 7 May 2025 by Editorial Board

The Downtown Dilemma

Last week, an Express Sessions event in Sag Harbor focused on the village’s shopping district and explored a puzzle: If last summer was the busiest ever, and the streets of Sag Harbor were, by all accounts, packed on most every day and evening, why were the owners of shops on Main Street and elsewhere in the business district reporting a down year? The answers are elusive, complicated — and, in many ways, universal to every downtown shopping district on the South Fork, from Montauk to Eastport: Southampton, Bridgehampton, East Quogue, Westhampton Beach, Water Mill, Amagansett, East Hampton, Quogue, Hampton Bays. ... 30 Apr 2025 by Editorial Board

Shining Examples

A glimpse back in time to the 19th century would reveal, in most of the East End’s hamlets and villages, small general stores, often containing a local post office, where people living in the neighborhood could purchase groceries and necessary supplies — and, later on, gasoline for a growing number of automobiles. Over the years, many of those general stores disappeared, making way for larger business districts and developments, especially as the South Fork grew into a flourishing tourist destination. Big-box stores eventually arrived, challenging even those downtown shopping destinations. But it was those general stores, mixed with a thriving ... 23 Apr 2025 by Editorial Board

Staying Alive

And, in the same vein, Sag Harbor Village’s holiday weekend “Keep It Local” shopping event was a success, and it’s a model that should be repeated more frequently in the village — and in every other village and hamlet shopping district on the South Fork. It was the Sag Harbor Chamber of Commerce that undertook the very simple campaign to encourage people not just to walk the streets of Sag Harbor but to cross the threshold and actually spend some money. Because the village has no issue with foot traffic these days, but its merchants are struggling. That’s the theme ... by Editorial Board

Under Attack

Democracy is under attack, and calling out the shifty, shady ways political parties are taking choice away from voters is essential. It’s very much an issue at the national level, for so many reasons. Not least of which, the House of Representatives — with the full support of Republicans, including 1st District U.S. Representative Nick LaLota — approved a measure last week called the Safeguard American Voter Eligibility Act, or the SAVE Act, which would make it much harder for any American to register to vote. Seeking to weed out ballots cast by noncitizens — something that happens so rarely ... 16 Apr 2025 by Editorial Board

A Deeply Felt Loss

Gladys Barnes, an early resident of the historically Black SANS communities — the Sag Harbor Hills, Azurest and Ninevah Beach subdivisions in Sag Harbor — made a monumental impact during her 96 years on Earth. When she died last month at her home in Ninevah, Sag Harbor mourned a towering figure in the local cultural and arts scene and one of the people who forged the bonds that make a community a vibrant, welcoming place. Barnes and others lost in recent years have left a legacy in Sag Harbor that is deeply appreciated by those who will continue to enjoy ... by Editorial Board

Cuts That Hurt

If you poll most Americans of all political stripes, you’d find a general agreement that there’s likely waste and fraud in the massive amount of federal spending, and that identifying and eliminating it would be a worthwhile task. What’s happening, though, in the first 100 days of the second Donald Trump administration is drawing criticism, and it’s because the cuts are being made with a chainsaw — Elon Musk’s symbolism, not ours — instead of a scalpel. Surgery was needed, but the intervention appears far worse than the ailment the nation came in with. One piece of evidence to support ... 9 Apr 2025 by Editorial Board