Letters

I am writing on behalf of the Tree Fund of Sag Harbor regarding the upcoming remediation compromise for the removal of the 150-year-old elm on Meadowlark Lane.

It is important to note that the tree was located on village property, meaning it belonged to the entire community of Sag Harbor, not just to the adjacent landowner who removed it.

This action has not only violated the collective ownership of the village’s natural heritage but also disregarded the efforts of the community to preserve its historic green spaces. The elm was a living testament to Sag Harbor’s history, a silent witness to generations who grew up beneath its canopy and sought solace in its shade. Its unauthorized removal calls for immediate attention and adequate replacement value to prevent such incidents in the future.

While complete restitution for the loss of the tree is not possible, we believe that the proposed replacement of a dogwood and three crepe myrtles is insufficient.

After consulting an arborist, we would suggest planting three 10-to-12-foot caliper oaks as restitution.

An oak tree hosts over 1,000 species of insects for feeding young birds and mammals. A mature oak tree absorbs hundreds of pounds of carbon, as carbon dioxide; the deep roots prevent soil erosion, improve soil structure and enhance water retention; fallen leaves enrich the soils with organic matter; the canopies intercept runoff and subsequent flooding. Oaks increase property value, and their acorns are a food source.

Oaks are a symbol of strength and endurance and embody what Sag Harbor represents since 1707, its founding.

We look to the village’s attorney, Justice Court and village residents through their active participation in this important decision, set for July 9, to ensure that this tragedy will not happen again, and that the best possible restitution is made in this case.

Kate Plumb

Sag Harbor Tree Fund