A Possible Compromise for Pond Lane Park Plans? Southampton Village Board Says One Is in the Works - 27 East

A Possible Compromise for Pond Lane Park Plans? Southampton Village Board Says One Is in the Works

icon 1 Photo
The Lake Agawam Conservancy proposes closing Pond Land to motor vehicle traffic as part of a plan to build a new public park and reduce runoff into the lake.  DANA SHAW

The Lake Agawam Conservancy proposes closing Pond Land to motor vehicle traffic as part of a plan to build a new public park and reduce runoff into the lake. DANA SHAW

authorCailin Riley on Nov 15, 2023

The Southampton Village Board and other stakeholders have been working toward a possible compromise on the proposed plan to close Pond Lane to vehicular traffic and create a world-class public garden on two vacant parcels of land on the street currently owned by the John Paulson Foundation and another adjacent parcel already owned by the Southampton Town Community Preservation Fund program.

The plans, first introduced to the public at a board meeting in September, have animated and divided the community for months, with a group of residents speaking out in strong opposition to the plan, mainly because of the closure of Pond Lane.

Southampton Village Trustee Roy Stevenson laid out what a potential compromise could look like during his comments to the board and those in attendance at the November 9 meeting.

He said he does not want to see the plan fall apart, not only because he believes the conversion of the land into a world-class park — with gardens designed by famed architect and Southampton Village resident Peter Marino — would be a lasting and cherished gift for the community, but also because Southampton Town has already agreed to purchase one of the Paulson lots in order to satisfy a land “swap” that is necessary so the village can install $10 million algae harvesters at another site. He said the algae harvesters, which the village acquired with town and federal grant funds, are crucial in the effort to clean up the long-polluted lake and restore it to its former glory.

Paulson has said he would sell one parcel to the CPF for the same price he paid for it and would donate the other parcel for the project. The Lake Agawam Conservancy, a local nonprofit group, has agreed to fund the construction of the park and gardens, and to create a $10 million endowment to cover the cost of maintaining the park.

Stevenson said that although both Paulson and the town had initially made any deal for the land contingent upon the closure of Pond Lane to vehicle traffic, both parties have indicated in recent weeks that they’d be open to a compromise that would see Pond Lane turned into a one-way street, running from south to north, that would be closed to vehicle traffic entirely on weekends and holidays, which is when the new park and gardens would see the most pedestrian and bike traffic, and closing the road to cars for safety purposes would be the most necessary.

“The town sees this area becoming a broader recreational resource for people,” Stevenson said, adding that if the lake can be cleaned up, it could be used in the future for sailing and kayaking. “I believe, and I believe a strong majority of village residents believe, that the park and the preservation of space is a good thing.” He pointed out, however, that the plan isn’t possible without the land currently owned by Paulson’s foundation.

A group of Southampton residents, represented by local business owner Erin Meaney, who spoke at the board meeting earlier in the night, said they have come up with an alternative plan for the area that keeps Pond Lane open as a two-way street.

Meaney said the residents want an opportunity to present those plans to the public and accused the board of catering to the whims of Paulson rather than listening to what a large group of residents want.

“You are elected officials who are supposed to be making decisions on what is best for the community, not what is best for John Paulson,” she said.

In his comments, Stevenson responded to the accusation that the board cares more about what Paulson wants rather than the residents who oppose the road closure.

“Mr. Paulson is donating over $20 million [in land value],” he said. “Without his money and the town CPF funds, there is no park. If Paulson pulls out, that would be a tragedy and a huge lost opportunity to create something meaningful and wonderful for the citizens.

“So far, none of the people offering alternate plans have been willing to step forward and buy the property,” he added.

You May Also Like:

Southampton Police Reports for the Week of July 3

WESTHAMPTON BEACH — Marcelino Perez-Tax, 56, of Westhampton Beach was arrested on June 29 at 8:36 p.m. and charged with misdemeanor DWI. Village Police said Perez-Tax had a blood alcohol level of .08. He was pulled over after being observed driving on the shoulder and failing to stay in his lane, police reported. His vehicle was seized by police because he had a previous DWI conviction in Southampton Town in November of 2013. SOUTHAMPTON VILLAGE — Village Police received a report of a stolen vehicle from outside a Main Street business at 11 a.m. on June 25. A responding officer ... 2 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

East End Little League Finishes Strong in District 36 Tournament

The East End Little League 12-and-under baseball All-Stars finished strong in District 36, winning their ... by Drew Budd

County Warns of Stepped-Up DWI Enforcement for Summer, Encourages Drivers To Take Ride Shares When Drinking

Suffolk County Sherriff Erron Toulon and County Executive Ed Romaine warned drivers this week that the county will be rolling out a new anti-DWI campaign that will feature stepped-up enforcement of drinking and driving laws and public outreach to discourage drunk driving. The sheriff’s office said that the county will step up patrols focusing on DWI enforcement and on-road sobriety checkpoints throughout the county, starting this coming weekend and continuing throughout the summer. Toulon said his office’s STOP DWI unit is on pace to break a record number of DWI arrests this year and encouraged young adults to turn to ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Moves To Rezone Hampton Bays Gateway, Potentially Halting Cannabis Shop

Southampton Town has proposed rezoning a portion of Montauk Highway leading into the Hampton Bays business district — a planning realignment that was recommended long ago and brought forward now in what appears to be an attempt to derail plans for a cannabis dispensary in an abandoned bank building, which has faced public opposition. The Town Board held a public hearing last week on the proposal to rezone about 26 properties along Montauk Highway to the east of the Hampton Bays hamlet center from “highway business” to “hamlet commercial.” The change would mean smaller-scale development, more green space between structures ... by Michael Wright

New Southampton School Board Member Questions Administrator's Salary

In the wake of Dr. Jaime Bottcher’s recent departure from the Southampton Union Free School District, High School Principal Dr. Brian Zahn has stepped into her role as the new assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction. But it didn’t come without a fiery back-and-forth between Superintendent of Schools Dr. Fatima Morrell and School Board newcomer Rodney “Chip” Pierson, who raised concerns over the new administrator’s $223,000 salary during a Board of Education meeting on Tuesday night. He noted that Bottcher earned $202,000 in the same role. “Now we’re putting a new person in at this position — how do we ... by Michelle Trauring

Southampton All-Stars Finish Up Play in Respective District 36 Tournaments

For the first time in years, Southampton Little League entered three different teams in this ... by Drew Budd

Class of 2025 Leaves Its Mark on Westhampton Beach School District

For Westhampton Beach Superintendent of Schools Dr. Carolyn Probst, the Class of 2025 is special ... by Desirée Keegan

'How Far I'll Go': Southampton Graduates Ready To Soar

Ashley Uruchima stands on the Southampton High School graduation stage, looking out at the audience ... by Michelle Trauring

Hampton Bays Seniors Represent Community With Pride

Hampton Bays High School Principal Christopher Richardt is moved and excited by current and future ... by Desirée Keegan

McClelland, Kapon Lead Bridgehampton Class of 2025

Avery McClelland, who will attend the University of Virginia in the fall, and Sarah Kapon, ... by Stephen J. Kotz