An Early Challenger

Autor

Suffolk Closeup

  • Publication: Southampton Press
  • Published on: May 10, 2021
  • Columnist: Karl Grossman

By launching a campaign for the U.S. House of Representatives this month, Suffolk County Legislator Bridget Fleming is moving early and strongly to get the Democratic nomination to run next year.

In recent years, Democratic primary battles have diverted Democratic fundraising and complicated the party’s runs in the 1st Congressional District.

Ms. Fleming is clearly likely to get the Democratic Party’s designation.

At a press conference on May 3, at which she announced that she is running for the seat held since 2015 by Republican Lee Zeldin, Ms. Fleming was flanked by Suffolk County Democratic Chair Rich Schaffer; the presiding officer of the Suffolk County Legislature, Rob Calarco; a bevy of town Democratic leaders; and John Durso, president of Local 338 of the Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union.

If Ms. Fleming ends up winning the 1st District seat, she would be the first woman to represent Suffolk County in the U.S. House of Representatives. The seat was established and first held in 1789 by Declaration of Independence signer William Floyd of Mastic.

If Ms. Fleming, a Noyac resident, wins, she, as an East End resident, will follow Tim Bishop, a Southampton Democrat, who held the seat from 2003 to 2015, and, earlier, Otis Pike, a Riverhead Democrat, who held it from 1961 until his retirement in 1979.

Might gender figure in her run? Women have made gains in being elected to the House. Currently, of its 435 members, 118 are women. That’s a minority — yet it’s more than 50 years ago, when there were just 13 female House members, or 30 years ago, when there were but 19. The numbers have increased in the last several years, going to 72 in 2007.

The two women who ran for House seats from Suffolk County last year — Nancy Goroff in the 1st District, and Jackie Gordon in the neighboring 2nd District, both Democrats — were defeated. The 1st District covers the five East End towns, all of Brookhaven, most of Smithtown, and part of Islip.

Also, being an East Ender could be a liability, as Brookhaven Town is the political gorilla in the 1st District political room — the largest town in area (bigger than all of Nassau County) and the second-most populous (after Hempstead) of New York State’s 932 towns.

In Suffolk County, the vote is typically divided geographically. Mr. Zeldin is from Shirley, in Brookhaven Town, where he has done well.

It seems quite probable at this point that he will get the Republican designation to run for governor of New York next year, also announcing early for that run. In recent weeks he has gotten the endorsement of many Republican county committees. His run for governor would open the 1st District seat. Would the GOP pick another Brookhaven resident to run in his stead? That is likely.

However, Ms. Fleming’s county legislative district encompasses not only Southampton, East Hampton and Shelter Island towns but also includes a section of southeastern Brookhaven. She thus has had visibility in that portion of Brookhaven.

Meanwhile, she will be on the ballot this year for reelection to the legislature.

She has an exceptional public record. Before moving to Noyac in 2001 with her husband, Bob, she was for nearly a decade an assistant district attorney in Manhattan. She served as a member of its Trial Bureau and also Sex Crimes Prosecution Unit, and then was chief of the unit that tackled fraud in public programs.

She was first elected to the Southampton Town Board in 2010 and won a seat on the County Legislature in 2015. Last year, she was edged out of being the Democratic candidate in the 1st District as result of a three-way Democratic primary won by Ms. Goroff; Ms. Fleming finished third.

“For too long, our district has been represented by someone who cared more about his job than he did about those of his constituents, and someone who cared more about his own political future than he did about our future generations,” Ms. Fleming said in her announcement. “That changes the day I’m elected to Congress and that’s why I’m running.”

Mr. Schaffer said: “Bridget Fleming is the champion Long Island families need fighting for them in Congress in this critical moment in our nation’s history. As a tough-as-nails prosecutor, a town councilwoman, and a county legislator, Bridget has the backbone to stand up to both parties in Washington to deliver tax relief for our middle-class communities in Suffolk County.”

Ms. Fleming commented: “This is going to be an expensive race.” Indeed, these days millions of dollars are spent in campaigns for seats in the House. But, she says, it is a “flippable district,” yet a “formidable challenge.”

AutorMore Posts from Karl Grossman

Potential Disaster

It’s back — the federal government’s push to expand offshore oil drilling. The waters off ... 10 Dec 2025 by Karl Grossman

The Nitrogen Threat

“Restore Our Waters” was the title of the invitation. Its subtitle: “Learn How To Switch ... 4 Dec 2025 by Karl Grossman

Another Chance

Will Governor Kathy Hochul sign, or again veto, a bill to protect horseshoe crabs that ... 26 Nov 2025 by Karl Grossman

Warm Air, and Hot Air

There’s a highly threatening and new reality for hurricanes. Unusually, the East Coast of the ... 19 Nov 2025 by Karl Grossman

A Bright Spot

There were strong Democratic victories nationally in last week’s election, led by Mikie Sherrill winning ... 13 Nov 2025 by Karl Grossman

The Truth About Kratom

As the Mayo Clinic describes it: “Kratom is a supplement that is sold as an ... 4 Nov 2025 by Karl Grossman

The Plastics Battle

It started here in Suffolk County in 1988: the passage of one of the first ... 28 Oct 2025 by Karl Grossman

Driving Around

As Suffolk County residents will say, should we take the ferries between Suffolk and New ... 20 Oct 2025 by Karl Grossman

Heeding a Calling

This month marks a new era in medicine on Long Island, in the state and ... 14 Oct 2025 by Karl Grossman

Remembering a Legend

A celebration of the life of Jules Feiffer, the brilliant cartoonist, playwright and screenwriter who ... 5 Oct 2025 by Karl Grossman