Atlantic Golf Club Housing Plan, 'Outrageous,' Neighbors Say - 27 East

Atlantic Golf Club Housing Plan, 'Outrageous,' Neighbors Say

icon 1 Photo
The proposed staff housing at Atlantic Golf Club.       Courtesy Land Use Ecological Services

The proposed staff housing at Atlantic Golf Club. Courtesy Land Use Ecological Services

Kitty Merrill on Jun 7, 2021

Neighbors are concerned that a proposed residential building to house staff at the Atlantic Golf Club on Scuttle Hole Road in Bridgehampton could morph into a party house, or maybe even something else. Speaking at a public hearing on the proposal last month, they raised the specter of boisterous after-work parties, with one neighbor worrying that as many as 48 people might end up in the house’s 16 bedrooms.

Neighbors also are concerned about the potential environmental impacts to nearby Shorts Pond, as well as the loss of a vista cherished as among the most scenic in Southampton Town.

If approved as proposed, the 6,500-square-foot building would have 16 en suite bedrooms, 10 on the first floor and 6 on the second. The house would be built on a field located to the north of Shorts Pond, right on the road.

Presenting the application during the May 13 public hearing, Tony Panza of Rogers McCragg Architects pointed out that properties adjacent to the proposed site have houses with larger footprints, and while they may have only five or six bedrooms, they could accommodate up to 12 people.

Mr. Panza made mention of the number of guests a nearby residence could host in rebuttal to a point raised by neighbor Catherine Prewett. “When I heard of this project, I was taken aback,” said the neighbor who has lived in the area her entire life. Describing the building as a “behemoth,” she said it was unbelievable such a huge structure would be put right on Scuttle Hole Road

“Golf Club employees work hard and play hard,” she continued. Ms. Prewett predicted parties and noise, music and garbage, adding that if there were 16 bedrooms, on a Friday night there could be as many as 48 people on the site. She also listed the building being vacant a portion of the year among her concerns. Employees are seasonal and work when the club is open, from April to October.

Mr. Panza countered that in all its years, there have never been any complaints about club staff, not from neighbors, nor police.

The plan calls for some grass parking spots because, Mr. Panza said, some of the staff don’t need cars.

That part of the proposal is ridiculous, Charles Bowman of Land Use Ecological Services, speaking on behalf of the neighborhood group, Short Pond Associates, said. “No one’s going to have visitors and everyone’s going to be on bicycles?” he said. He wondered how the club would “police” the housing to make sure it doesn’t morph into 36 people.

There is already some onsite housing, Mr. Panza said, and there is a “strict rule” of one person per bedroom. There is a supervisor who oversees the staff, he said.

Several speakers made note that the club has over 200 acres, and yet, their planners picked the part of the property that would be the greatest burden on the public and the least on the golf course. Put the housing on a putting green, Crosby Renwick suggested. If the club wants to save money on rent elsewhere, it should make a sacrifice, he theorized.

Speaking on behalf of the club, Dennis Suskind, the president of the club and a former Southampton Town Board member said, “For clarification, this is not saving money, this is costing us money.”

“The plan was to be as light on the land as possible,” Mr. Panza clarified, pointing to the existing field that would serve as the housing site.

“This is the obvious location for housing our employees,” Mr. Suskind said.

From its inception, the Atlantic Golf Club has been very concerned about the land, very dedicated about water quality and very concerned about the vista, Mr. Suskind said. He and Mr. Panza both reproached speakers for labeling the building a transient motel. They refuted the notion repeatedly.

Still, members of the Bridgehampton Citizens Advisory Committee worried the facilities could be used for other purposes that might be difficult to monitor, CAC Chairwoman Pamela Harwood said last week. The en suite bedrooms, each with its own bathroom, raised brows about a potential transformation into another use, but also about the potential impact on the wetlands nearby.

“You have 200 acres, do you really have to put it on Shorts Pond?” Mr. Bowman queried. He asked for data relating to the project’s potential impact on the groundwater. Beyond the impacts of 16 bathrooms, he questioned the kitchens and laundry facilities.

Brian Matthews, of the law firm Matthews, Kirst and Cooley said he was speaking on behalf of a neighbor, Maryann Garbrielle, whose property is “immediately to the north of this transient motel.” Berating the application as “so far out of whack for the neighborhood,” he wondered how it had progressed to the point of a public hearing.

Multifamily dwellings are expressly prohibited in a residential zone, Mr. Matthews said, arguing that fact alone should exclude the application. And, the lawyer continued, while a building inspector determination allowed staff housing as an accessory use at golf clubs, there was no such determination for the Atlantic Golf Club specifically. The Town Board allows staff housing for agricultural uses and restaurants under certain circumstances, but the Atlantic proposal, “goes against every zoning tenet there is,” he said. “It’s our view this proposal is completely prohibited and should not go forward.”

Nevertheless, Mr. Matthews pointed out that other golf clubs with housing “tuck it way up in the woods,” not on a scenic road like Scuttle Hole, where it will place an “outrageous burden” on his client.

Jane Held’s family has owned its nearby property since the mid-1980s. She recalled her family preserved a large piece of land to protect the pond when they developed. The club is doing everything it can to minimize the impact on its own property while maximizing the impact on neighbors, Ms. Held said.

The Planning Board adjourned the May hearing and scheduled a second session for Thursday, June 10.

You May Also Like:

Bringing Art to Life: Esly Escobar’s Mission to Inspire Young Creatives in Guatemala

Standing in front of a group of curious students, Esly Escobar held up a potato ... 15 Feb 2025 by Michelle Trauring

Candidates To Debate On February 25

The Hampton Bays Civic Association will host a debate/forum for candidates running in the special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The debate/forum will be held on Monday, February 24, at Hampton Bays Middle School, 70 Ponquogue Avenue in Hampton Bays, from 7 to 8:45 p.m. Former Southampton Town Councilman Rick Martel will face John Leonard in the March 18 special election for the open seat on the Southampton Town Board. The winner will serve until the end of this year, completing the term vacated by Tommy John Schiavoni, who was elected to the New York ... by Staff Writer

Construction Career Scholarship Applications Being Accepted

The Construction Career Charitable Fund has opened applications for its 2025 scholarship program. High school seniors from Westhampton to Montauk, who are planning careers in the construction trades industry immediately after graduation, may apply. With awards of up to $10,000, the CCCF is dedicated to supporting local students with a passion for the trades, providing both financial assistance and career resources. In addition to scholarships, CCCF offers mentorship and job placement assistance, connecting students with leading area contractors in fields such as carpentry, electrical work, plumbing, and more. By partnering with local school districts and top-tier trades professionals, CCCF ensures ... by Staff Writer

Hurdles To Clear

It was a culinary and historic disaster: bird flu striking the Crescent Duck Farm, the last duck farm on Long Island. Some 99,000 ducks, the farm’s entire flock, had to be euthanized because of bird flu. The future of the Crescent Duck Farm involves several thousand eggs. Not only is Crescent Farm the last of what had been many duck farms on Long Island, it has produced — and I think many would agree — the finest ducks to eat, certainly in the nation and probably in the world. “Crescent Duck was started by Henry Corwin in 1908 in Aquebogue ... by Karl Grossman

No Good Reason

Donald Trump always begins with a big lie, which becomes viral through X and Fox News. His newest big lie: The federal workforce is the Deep State, bloated, filled with waste and fraud, pushing useless regulations, with employees sitting home not working. It needs to be dismantled. None of this is true. But Trump and Elon Musk want the public to believe their lie and turn a blind eye to the destruction of the federal government. America needs to wake up before Trump/Musk gut the regulations and federal agencies that keep us safe. It should be noted, many of the ... by Staff Writer

Constant Churn

Kevin Menard said he would like to solicit help from a business school to undertake a study of business conditions [“Sag Harbor Businesses Say They See More Visitors, but Fewer Customers,” 27east.com, February 5]. May I suggest a simple way to evaluate the problem? Buy a Jenga game. The tower of blocks where play is simply pulling one block out, turn by turn, until one is pulled out and the entire tower collapses. Label the bottom four blocks “poverty.” Label the top four blocks the “20 percent.” Everything else is the middle class. Need I make further explanation? The tower ... by Staff Writer

Enforce Zoning

People purchasing property have the expectation that the Town of Southampton’s zoning laws protect the area’s scenic beauty and rural charm. These laws aren’t just promises, they’re commitments to preserving the character and identity of this cherished community. When my wife and I bought our house in Water Mill almost 20 years ago, we paid a premium for the beautiful, unrestricted views and felt reassured that the property next door came encumbered with an easement whose purpose is to “protect the scenic, open space and rural character of the town and to protect the town’s resort and agricultural economy.” The ... by Staff Writer

Meets the Criteria

I am writing to recommend John Leonard for the Southampton Town Council, for the opening to be voted on in the special election on March 18, for the position Tommy John Schiavoni vacated when elected to the New York State Assembly. We all know it is hard to decide on whom to support for leadership in our democracy, especially after watching the selection of the cabinet for our president. What do we look for in a candidate? I think the best criteria should include intelligence, career choices and relevant experience in government. These are the best predictors of success — ... by Staff Writer

The Perfect Place

On behalf of our mother, Dorothy Brown, we would like to thank the staff at Kanas East End Hospice for the lovely care she received over the past few weeks. The Kanas Center, located in Westhampton, is situated on a creek in a beautifully wooded area. The facility is bathed in light, and the doctors, nurses, aides and volunteers were so caring and loving, making sure that Mom was comfortable and not in pain. It was the perfect place for our mom as she transitioned from this world to join our father and be greeted by the Lord. We will ... by Staff Writer

Falsehoods

John Leonard’s rebuttal [“No Bullying,” Letters, February 13] contains numerous falsehoods and further demonstrates his retaliatory and unhinged behavior. The National Labor Relations Board, after hearing both sides, found that two employees of the Evelyn Alexander Wildlife Rescue Center were fired in retaliation for an email they sent to the board of directors. This email brought up, among other things, issues that related to John Leonard. The timing of the firings, right after the email was sent, debunks his preposterous claim that they were carried out for any other reason. Additionally, these firings were done without the consent or knowledge ... by Staff Writer