Benjamin Huntting Foster Of Hampton Bays Dies August 7 - 27 East

Benjamin Huntting Foster Of Hampton Bays Dies August 7

author on Aug 13, 2018

Benjamin Huntting Foster of Hampton Bays, formerly of Southampton, died at home on August 7, 2018, 53 years to the day of meeting his wife, with his family by his side. He was 82 and died of melanoma.

Mr. Foster was born in Southampton Hospital on February 14, 1936—the best valentine his family ever had—and graduated from Southampton High School in 1954. He studied education at Oswego State University earning a bachelor’s degree in 1959; he returned to Oswego to get his master’s degree, graduating in 1970.

He missed all the summer fun in the Hamptons as he would travel to work on his uncle, Walter Betts’s farm in Tuckahoe, New Jersey, where they grew lima beans, peppers, sweet peas, corn and later, sod. He could often be found riding a tractor, singing “Are Ye Able” to the amusement of those around him. He may be most remembered as the son of Mary June Foster, who taught kindergarten in Southampton Elementary School and every Halloween dressed as a witch handing out her famous cookies.

He met his future wife, Yoka, who was visiting from Utrecht, the Netherlands, at a football party held at the home of a friend’s neighbor. His love for his wife was so strong he married her twice; the first time in a civil ceremony on April 7, 1966, in Zuilen, the Netherlands, and a second time at the United Methodist Church in Southampton on May 14, 1966. They continued their love story for 52 years.

In 1960 Mr. Foster started teaching shop class at Southampton Intermediate School, retiring in 1989. For 18 of those years he taught down the hall from his brother, David Foster, who was the physical education teacher. During his time at the intermediate school, he taught thousands of students. Toward the end of his career he had taught more than one generation of some families. He was instrumental in having co-educational shop and home-economics classes, recognizing the importance for both girls and boys to have these skills. Loving sports, Mr. Foster spent many years coaching junior varsity and varsity football, golf and wrestling at Southampton High School. Later he became a baseball umpire.

Survivors said that just like the seagull, he was very light while at the same time very strong and flexible, as well as very tough. He had a light exterior making everyone comfortable but he was stronger than the nails he hammered, he went with the flow but never against his beliefs and morals.

While traveling with one of his teams in the 1970s the team was denied service because of “colored” players, and determined to prove that they were all equal, he brought his team into his home to show they were part of his family. He was a mentor for students and teachers alike.

For about 10 summers he ran the Coopers Beach concession in Southampton Village with his friend and fellow teacher, Jim Wightman. They often employed other young teachers as concession staff and lifeguards. During the 1980s he owned a business called BF Products, selling wooden toys, signs and other items at craft fairs and at home parties, that he had crafted.

Mr. Foster served on the Southampton Village Board of Historic Preservation and Architectural Review for many years. He was a founding member of the Southampton Colonial Militia, which formed during the bicentennial in 1976. He was an active member of the 3rd NY Regiment, serving as treasurer until the day he died. He marched in more than 40 Fourth of July parades, often with his daughters and grandchildren in tow.

Mr. Foster loved camping and fishing. Many summers were spent camping at the Shinnecock Inlet, fishing and watching the seagulls soar. He took overseas guests across the country or headed overseas with his family to camp their way from Belgium to Norway, on one trip, then through Germany to Italy, Switzerland and Austria on another. He was an avid train collector, spending many hours at train meets with his friend, Bill, looking and searching for just the right addition to his collection. He also enjoyed reading about history and mystery, as can be noted by the thousands of books in his home office.

Mr. Foster is survived by his wife Yoka (Arlar) and two daughters, Kristina Foster, her son, Richard Benjamin and fiancée Caitlin, and Jacqueline Robinson, her husband, Christopher, and their children, Megan and Cole. He is also survived by a brother, David Foster and wife Roseann Gentile Foster and their children; a brother-in-law, Sjon (John) Arlar and wife Oddveig from Norway, their children, Oddreider and Peter; sisters-in-law, Ursula and husband Sigmund and their sons, Kristoffer and Martin of Norway, and Felicia and husband Arvid and their daughters, Elisabeth and Isabella of Norway; as well as his “Haguers” and a slew of cousins in Tuckahoe and Woodbine, New Jersey. He was predeceased by his father, Dr. Edward H. Foster and his mother, Mary June Foster (Betts) of Southampton; and his brother-in-law, Jan Arlar of Hampton Bays and Utrecht, the Netherlands.

Services were held at R.J. O’Shea Funeral Home in Hampton Bays.

Memorial donations in his name may be made to the Peconic Land Trust, or to the Shinnecock Indian Nation Cultural Center & Museum, in the name of his friend, Alice Osceola Martinez.

You May Also Like:

A Note From the Editor

Questions were recently raised about the identity of a frequent letter writer, who self-identified as “Jose Reyes of Hampton Bays.” Southampton Democratic Committee officials provided documentation strongly calling into question the legitimacy of the letters. The letter writer has since acknowledged — without revealing his or her true identity — that this was a “pen name,” or an assumed name, and apologized and promised to stop submitting letters using that pseudonym. The Express News Group policy is to require verifiable address and phone numbers with published Letters to the Editor, with the information kept confidential but used to verify a ... 5 May 2025 by Editorial Board

We Need a Choice

I’m a textile artist, one of several convening in Sag Harbor who make art in support of local and pro-democracy causes. You may have seen some of my handmade art “VOTE” banners, which the village removed, and that I personally pulled out of garbage cans along Main Street [“Vote Banners Don’t Last Long in Sag Harbor,” 27east.com, November 5, 2024]. Recently, Mayor Tom Gardella reposted on his only Instagram account the following: “To all the people complaining about Doge! ... F--- YOU.” Many of us who saw the post were shocked. One of my fellow textile artist-friends asked the mayor ... by Staff Writer

Nod to the Past

In deciding to run for reelection as village trustee, I have thought a great deal about what I, as a trustee, have done and can continue to do to preserve and nurture the qualities that make Southampton Village such a special place to live. One is continuity. While a great deal has changed since I was a boy, biking from my grandmother’s to get Dad a newspaper at Silver’s, the essence of this beautiful place remains: the ocean’s omnipresent murmur, Coopers Neck beach, our wonderful churches, and going to the movies, to name just a few. Many thanks to the ... by Staff Writer

Seat at the Table

Last week, I announced my candidacy for mayor of Southampton Village. While there are a number of priorities I hope to address, transparency and public input must be at the center of village government. That starts with restoring public comment at all Board of Trustees meetings. When I was first elected as trustee, one of my first suggestions was that public comment should be allowed at all Board of Trustees meetings, and it should be in a format that allows for the exchange of ideas. Whenever new laws are being proposed or projects that affect all the residents are being ... by Staff Writer

Bad Neighbors

“Good fences make good neighbors,” Robert Frost famously wrote in his poem “Mending Wall.” Frost was being ironic, or at least having a bit of fun at the expense of his neighbor’s fastidious efforts to repair the stone wall along their mutual property line. But, living in a suburban area, I’ve come to think there’s much truth to the old New England maxim. A well-trimmed hedge is a good way to maintain amity between me and my neighbors, and to preserve our respective backyard privacy. Good fences — or hedges — do make good neighbors. The recent action of Discovery ... by Staff Writer

Refuse Surprises

The Noyac Civic Council once again is proud to have many volunteers join in the Great East End Clean-Up. This year, we had a few different surprises as we picked up the usual trash along Noyac Road. We found a five-point deer lying on the side of Noyac Road, no doubt hit by a car. Many thanks to Lucas of the Highway Department, who took care of the carcass. Then we found police handcuffs, an unopened bottle of Patron tequila, a Powerball lotto ticket for April 18, and an autographed New York Yankees baseball cap. Miller Lite seems to be ... by Staff Writer

New Jersey Man Arrested After Woman Claims He Set Up a Spy Camera in Bathroom

A New Jersey man was arrested by Southampton Town Police over the weekend and charged with unlawful surveillance after a woman told police she suspected that he had used a remote camera to watch her in the bathroom. The woman, who police have not identified other than to say she is from Indiana, called police on May 3 and reported that she was staying at an Airbnb house in Water Mill for the weekend with several co-workers. The woman said that one of the co-workers, James Bassett-Cann, told her before she arrived that he was going to plug a “charging ... by Staff Writer

Southampton Village ZBA Chairman Resigns

Luke Ferran, the chairman of the Southampton Village Zoning Board of Appeals, resigned from the ... by Brendan J. O’Reilly

A New Low

The Southampton Town Democratic Committee has shown the town residents what it really is: a political group filled with elitism and character assassination. Voters of other political stripes are paying close attention to your back-and-forth written letters of desperation, filled with venom, printed in this newspaper. Your words really matter and won’t serve you well moving forward to the November election. The dark cloud that looms over the Southampton Town Democratic Party will forever remain, unless you do something positive to lift that dark cloud. Remove the negative elements in your inner circle. Be more inclusive and welcoming. It’s time ... by Staff Writer

Go Underground

While the latest volley of bells, whistles and delayed red-light cycles are welcome in alleviating the South Fork’s colossal bottlenecking problem, any superficial effort to ease the traffic is akin to using a hand bucket to stop the sinking of the Titanic [“Southampton Traffic Experiment Showed Big Improvements in Commute Times During First Week; New Changes Tried This Week,” 27east.com, April 27]. Short of turning all the quaint towns to car-free Amish-type communities, the East End will remain a collision course of cars, trucks, buses, vans, cement mixers, dump trucks, lumber semis, landscaper rigs, construction and professional vans, UPS, FedEx, ... by Staff Writer