Budget Passes, Bennett, Fay and Neumaier Win Seats on School Board in Westhampton

Desirée Keegan on May 22, 2024

The Westhampton Beach Board of Education will look different next year now that newcomers Daniel Bennett, Ryan Fay and Dr. Jennifer Neumaier have been elected to the board.

While Westhampton Beach voters came out Tuesday in support of a tax cap-compliant $64,879,213 budget for the 2024-25 school year, 549-129, voters had a more difficult choice selecting three of six candidates seeking a spot on the board. Fay earned 363 votes, while Bennett and Neumaier each received 303.

With current board President Suzanne Mensch and Trustee George R. Kast Jr. choosing not to seek reelection, it left incumbent Joyce Donneson being challenged by the three winners, and business owner Bryan Beasley and attorney Robert Macedonio, who collected 279, 286 and 174 votes, respectively.

“I am thrilled and honored to have been elected to the Westhampton Beach School District Board of Education,” Neumaier said. “First, I want to extend my heartfelt thanks to all of my fellow candidates for an exciting last three weeks and for the relationships we’ve built. With so many incredible choices and such an impressive turnout from the community, it is clear that there is a shared dedication to ensuring our district continues to thrive and provide an exceptional education to every student.”

Residents approved the budget, a 2.99 percent, or $1,884,862, increase from this current year’s spending plan, and also supported Proposition 2, 532-146, which authorizes a $2,633,248 library budget that is a 3.26 percent, or $83,055, increase from this current year’s spending plan.

“I would like to thank the community for its overwhelming support in the school budget and election,” Fay said. “It just reinforced what I’ve always believed about our community: that it’s dynamic, engaged and that it cares deeply about our kids. I can’t wait to start working with my colleagues on the board, and I look forward to supporting our students, teachers, staff and the taxpayers of this incredible district.”

Residents also gave Proposition 3 the green light, 519-163. It authorizes a $100,000 Greater Westhampton Historical Museum budget. The funds help the organization, formerly the Westhampton Beach Historical Society — which serves the communities of Westhampton Beach, West Hampton Dunes, Westhampton, Quiogue, Remsenburg, Speonk and Eastport — expand to have a year-round presence and increases the number of programs it will offer to both schools and the community at large.

“The turnout was amazing and shows this community cares about the future of this district,” Bennett said. “I feel blessed and excited to have this opportunity. I look forward to working with and for the community and being a strong voice for the students, and I’m looking forward to making positive changes and sharing in the successes of the students, faculty, staff and new Board of Education.”

Besides recognizing the community support, Bennett also thanked the outgoing board members for their years of service. Neumaier added that she can’t wait to work with colleagues new and old.

“I am deeply grateful for the community’s trust in me and look forward to representing your needs. I am committed to open dialogue, listening to your concerns and making sure they are addressed effectively. I am also eager to learn from the experienced members of the board who have given so much to this community; their knowledge is invaluable,” she said. “Most importantly, I want to thank the community, our students and the people who make this district incredible, our amazing and talented teachers, for their support. Together, we will continue to work toward a bright future for our district.”

You May Also Like:

East Quogue Engineer's Dazzling Light Show Brings Joy and Raises Money for St. Jude Children's Hospital

​When Joseph Commisso was a child, growing up in East Quogue, he remembers making a ... 12 Dec 2025 by Cailin Riley

Southampton Awards $630,000 Grant to Housing for Autistic Adults

Autistic adults, their families and supporters burst into applause Tuesday afternoon when the Southampton Town ... 10 Dec 2025 by Michael Wright

Flanders Big Duck Is Lit for the Holidays

With the help of Santa and friends, the Flanders Big Duck was lit for the ... 8 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Southampton Town Police Announce 2026 Civilian Academy

The Southampton Town Police Department will launch its 2026 Civilian Police Academy on January 15, ... 5 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

A Surprise Every Morning: Sunrises Are Southampton Photographer's Specialty, and He Shares Them Daily on Instagram

Every day he’s in Southampton, Eric Nastri does the same exact thing. And yet, he ... 4 Dec 2025 by Cailin Riley

Ground Broken for Westhampton Community Center; Long-Awaited Resource Could Open in 2026

Southampton Town officials held a ceremonial groundbreaking on the long-awaited Westhampton Community Center project next ... by Michael Wright

The Start of a New Era at The Express News Group, With a New Website and Focus on Digital Media, and Leadership Changes

The end of the year will be the start of a new era at The ... 3 Dec 2025 by Cailin Riley

'Parade of Lights' Kicks Off Southampton Holiday Season

The annual holiday “Parade of Lights” and tree lighting in Agawam Park ushered in the ... 1 Dec 2025 by Staff Writer

Feeding Southampton: Heart of the Hamptons Responds to Rising Need | 27Speaks Podcast

The staff and volunteers at Heart of the Hamptons Food Pantry work hard year-round to ... 30 Nov 2025 by 27Speaks

‘Good for Everyone’: ACCESSforALL Helps Arts Groups, Businesses Push Forward on Inclusion

In Brian O’Mahoney’s eyes, “disability” does not need to be an intimidating word. But for ... 26 Nov 2025 by Michelle Trauring