'Can You Hear Us Now?': Noyac Residents Rally Against Proposed Cell Tower - 27 East

'Can You Hear Us Now?': Noyac Residents Rally Against Proposed Cell Tower

Noyac Residents Rally Against Proposed Cell Tower
icon 1 Video & 3 Photos

Noyac Residents Rally Against Proposed Cell Tower

Neighbors gathered at a Southampton Town Highway Department depot at the end of Club Lane in Noyac to protest the possibility of the site being used for a cell tower. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Neighbors gathered at a Southampton Town Highway Department depot at the end of Club Lane in Noyac to protest the possibility of the site being used for a cell tower. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Noyac residents gathered Sunday to protest a proposal to build a cell tower at the Southampton Town Highway Department property at 30 Club Lane. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Noyac residents gathered Sunday to protest a proposal to build a cell tower at the Southampton Town Highway Department property at 30 Club Lane. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Noyac residents gathered Sunday to protest a proposal to build a cell tower at the Southampton Town Highway Department property at 30 Club Lane. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

Noyac residents gathered Sunday to protest a proposal to build a cell tower at the Southampton Town Highway Department property at 30 Club Lane. STEPHEN J. KOTZ

authorStephen J. Kotz on Nov 23, 2020

As they did two years ago, neighbors gathered in front of a Southampton Town Highway Department barn at the end of Club Lane in Noyac to protest a proposal to build a cell tower there.

About 35 people took part in the protest on Sunday, some holding signs reading “No Cell Tower in Our Residential Neighborhood with Children,” “Just Say No,” and “Fight the Tower.”

Sharon Bakes, who lives at the corner of Club Lane and Wildwood Road, led the group in chants. “No tower in a residential community!” and “No power to the tower!” she shouted, as the rest rejoined, “Cell No!”

Ms. Bakes said earlier this week that the group did not expect it would have to mobilize again to stop construction of a cell tower on the town-owned property. Two years ago, the Town Board scuttled plans to let Elite Communications build a tower at the site. But late last month, SBA Communications, which has an exclusive contract to build cell towers on town-owned land, revived the proposal.

Neighbors protesting this week said the town only canceled the deal with Elite after being informed by SBA that it had the right of first refusal, but Councilman Tommy John Schiavoni, who serves as the community’s liaison on the board, disagreed, telling the Noyac Civic Council on November 17 that the board had heard the community’s objections.

“We heard loud and clear from the immediate community that it was not a suitable site,” he said.

Ms. Bakes said the group opposed the tower for a number of reasons, from concerns about possible health effects, worries a tower could fall onto a neighbor’s house, and belief a tower would lower property values.

Mr. Schiavoni said he, too, was surprised that SBA had proposed a new cell tower for the property, pointing out that when its representatives appeared before the Town Board on October 29, he expected them to present a list of suitable sites for tower construction in the eastern half of the town.

Instead, he said, “They really zeroed in on this piece of property,” citing gaps in service and the convenient location of the town highway property. “This company really believes this is the best place to do it,” he said. “I’m not sure about that.”

The councilman also said he was dissatisfied with the contract the town agreed to with SBA in 2001, calling it one-sided and unfair.

“It’s just shocking that the Town of Southampton can only use one company to put up a cell tower,” he said.

He said the town signed the deal in 2001 and every time it signs a deal with SBA for a new tower, the contract is automatically extended for another 30 years.

He said he found it hard to believe that a decision by a prior town board could tie future boards’ hands for perpetuity.

“They are lucrative,” he said of towers. “They make money for the company and they should make money for the landlord, too.” A typical tower would bring in $120,000 to $130,000 in revenue for the town a year, he said, and it would be in the town’s best interest to solicit several bids for each tower.

Mr. Schiavoni said before the town moves forward with any new towers, it needs to have a better understanding of where they are most needed and what are the best properties to build them on.

He said that both Sag Harbor and North Haven villages have been weighing cell tower proposals, and it would be wise for the town to consult with them so efforts are not duplicated.

Sag Harbor cut a deal with Verizon allowing it to place antennas in the cupola of the Municipal Building. The village also signed off on radio station WLNG’s request to install a mobile cell tower at its property on Redwood Road. The station is also contemplating adding permanent cell antennas when it replaces its aging broadcasting antenna.

North Haven recently began working with cellular carriers as it studies possible locations for a tower.

You May Also Like:

Southampton July 4th Parade Delights Crowd

The Southampton July Fourth parade was held on Friday morning and did not disappoint with ... 7 Jul 2025 by Staff Writer

Beachcomber, July 10

It’s wonderful to be back in Southampton! I never thought I was going to get ... by Alex Littlefield

Ellen’s Run Turns 30 as Foundation Honors Founder and Expands Breast Cancer Mission

One year after Ellen Hermanson died of breast cancer, her sisters Julie Ratner and Emily ... by Hope Hamilton

St. Mark's Episcopal Church Marks 100 Years of Serving Westhampton Beach

St. Mark’s Episcopal Church in Westhampton Beach has been helping residents with matters of faith ... 6 Jul 2025 by Dan Stark

Born in The Hamptons, 'Jaws' Turns 50

It is the summer of “Jaws,” and many are wondering whether 50 years is long ... 5 Jul 2025 by Michael Wright

East End Historical Societies and Museums Join Forces for Long Island History Hunt

Long Island museums and historical societies have teamed up to host the Long Island History ... 4 Jul 2025 by Dan Stark

Southampton Class of 2025 Receives Diplomas

The members of Southampton High School’s Class of 2025 were presented with their diplomas during ... by Staff Writer

John Adams Dix Windmill Dedicated in Westhampton Beach

Local elected officials and village residents gathered on the morning of Wednesday, July 2, for ... 3 Jul 2025 by Dan Stark

Small-Town America at Its Best: Southampton Village's Fourth of July Parade Is a Proud Tradition, More Than 100 Years Strong

When it comes to Southampton Village traditions, there is perhaps none bigger or more beloved ... by Cailin Riley

Elyce Arons Discusses Friendship, Mental Health, and Her New Book, 'We Might Just Make It After All: My Best Friendship With Kate Spade'

Elyce Arons met Kate Spade when the two were just 18 years old, both freshmen ... by Hope Hamilton