East Hampton/Pierson Girls Lacrosse Moves Up to Division I/Class A

icon 13 Photos
East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player.   DREW BUDD

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player. DREW BUDD

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player.   DREW BUDD

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player. DREW BUDD

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player.   DREW BUDD

East Hampton senior Ava Tintle chases a loose ball off a draw with a Hauppauge player. DREW BUDD

East Hampton junior Hailey Welsch pressures a Hauppauge player.   DREW BUDD

East Hampton junior Hailey Welsch pressures a Hauppauge player. DREW BUDD

East Hampton junior midfielder/defense Hailey Welsch.   DREW BUDD

East Hampton junior midfielder/defense Hailey Welsch. DREW BUDD

East Hampton/Pierson head coach Joe DiGirolomo talks with his players during halftime of last week's game against Hauppauge.  DREW BUDD

East Hampton/Pierson head coach Joe DiGirolomo talks with his players during halftime of last week's game against Hauppauge. DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge scores.  DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge scores. DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge picks up a ground ball.   DREW BUDD

Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge picks up a ground ball. DREW BUDD

Lola Eldridge will be a key player for the Bonackers this season.  DREW BUDD

Lola Eldridge will be a key player for the Bonackers this season. DREW BUDD

Lola Eldridge, left, and Ava Tintle go after a loose ball off a draw.  DREW BUDD

Lola Eldridge, left, and Ava Tintle go after a loose ball off a draw. DREW BUDD

Hailey Welsch plays defense on a teammate while Bonackers practice before their nonleague game against Hauppauge on Thursday, March 27.  DREW BUDD

Hailey Welsch plays defense on a teammate while Bonackers practice before their nonleague game against Hauppauge on Thursday, March 27. DREW BUDD

Abby Perello, typically a field player, donned the goalie gear for the East Hampton/Pierson girls lacrosse team while its down a keeper to start the season. DREW BUDD

Abby Perello, typically a field player, donned the goalie gear for the East Hampton/Pierson girls lacrosse team while its down a keeper to start the season. DREW BUDD

Drew Budd on Apr 1, 2025

It’s a bit of a new dawn for the East Hampton/Pierson girls lacrosse program.

After playing in Division II/Class B for the past several seasons, the Bonackers have made the jump up to Division I/Class A due to larger enrollment numbers. The program, which is also combined with Bridgehampton and Ross, though neither of those schools currently have a player on the varsity roster, is playing this season under an enrollment number of 1,165 — all schools with over 1,000 students are considered a large school.

Couple that with the fact that the program graduated a dozen girls after last season, so the team is going to look different in many different ways.

“We do have a good amount back, but we also have a lot of newcomers who are stepping right onto the field with not a lot of experience, so we’re going to take things game by game,” head coach Joe DiGirolomo said. “We also have low numbers this year, so not a lot of subs. We are expecting a couple of them to come back soon. There are some girls who don’t have enough practices yet, but we’ll be working with about five subs, I think, total.”

East Hampton senior midfielder Ava Tintle, entering her fifth year on varsity and set to play at Washington and Lee University next year, is the focal point of the Bonac offense this season. After surpassing the 100-point milestone last season as a junior, Tintle is set to surpass the 100-goal milestone as soon as this week. She scored seven goals in a 19-18 season-opening victory over Hampton Bays on March 25, and then another goal in a 14-4 loss to Hauppauge on Thursday, March 27, so Tintle has 97 goals into this week’s games.

Pierson senior midfielder Cali Wilson is going to be right there alongside Tintle, and so will be Pierson sophomore Lola Eldridge. DiGirolomo is expecting big things from both Sag Harbor players this season. The Bonackers started off the season working without their expected starting goalie, Pierson junior Hannah Salazar Sierra, who DiGirolomo said will return to the team in about a week.

The rest of the roster includes: East Hampton senior Lila Gabbard (defense), Pierson seniors Bella Eldridge (defense), Ani Bedini (defense) and Angely Chaves (attack), East Hampton juniors Carly Fromm (attack), Marykate Hosey (attack), Cassie Ceva (attack), Katie Grande (attack), Hailey Welsch (midfield/defense), Sophia Sanchez-Cleary (attack) and Caeleigh Schuster (goalie), Pierson juniors Abby Perello (attack), Clio Halweil (attack) and Lily Caplin (defense), East Hampton sophomore Samantha Rodriguez, East Hampton freshman Bella O’Connor (attack) and East Hampton eighth-grader Lorelei Briand (attack/defense).

Moving up to Division I means playing large schools such as Patchogue-Medford, Sachem East and North, Middle Country, Longwood and Brentwood. While the larger schools pose different issues than that of the smaller schools, such as large rosters, historically the teams have been a bit a weaker, and so DiGirolomo is hoping to take advantage of that this season.

“We’re going to be playing teams that we feel like we can compete against,” he said. “Our goal this year is to try to go .500. It would give us a shot,” at making the playoffs, he added. “We’re playing a lot of new schools that we don’t really know. At the same time they don’t know us, so it could work to our advantage.”

Bonac is scheduled to play at Pat-Med this Saturday, April 5, at 10 a.m. and then will play at Sachem North on Wednesday, April 9, at 4 p.m.

You May Also Like:

Pierson, Bridgehampton Athletes Earn Spring and Annual Accolades

PIERSON Pierson Baseball All-League & Team MVP Andy Wayne All-League Spencer Cavaniola, Braeden Mott All-Academic ... 12 Aug 2025 by Staff Writer

South Fork Boys Lax Caps Off Season With Big Win Over Bellport

The South Fork Boys Lacrosse Team’s season might not have ended as planned, but the ... 21 May 2025 by Desirée Keegan

Weekly Roundup: Westhampton Beach Girls Lacrosse Earns Three Seed; Fromm’s Buzzer-Beater Leads Bonac Girls Lacrosse; Chekijian Walk-Off Helps Baymen Avoid Sweep

Fromm’s Buzzer-Beater
Leads Bonac Girls Lacrosse Carly Fromm scored the winning goal at the buzzer to lead the East Hampton/Pierson girls lacrosse team (5-10) to an 11-10 overtime win at Walt Whitman on May 14. Ava Tintle scored four goals, Cali Wilson scored twice and had two assists, Katie Grande scored two goals, and Lola Eldridge added two goals and three assists. The Bonackers finished their first Division I season with a 4-10 division record, 5-11 overall, with 75.05 power points. Southampton Softball
Wins Finale The Mariners defeated host Pierson/Bridgehampton, 13-8, at Mashashimuet Park in Sag Harbor on Thursday, May 15, to ... 20 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Corwin Scores Game-Winner for South Fork Boys Lacrosse; Meyers Scores 100th Career Goal in Big Nine-Point Performance

Corwin Tallies
Late Game-Winner James Corwin scored the game-winning goal with 20 seconds remaining in regulation to lead the South Fork boys lacrosse team (6-6 in Division I, 7-7 overall, 96.03 power points) to a 9-8 victory at Walt Whitman Thursday, May 8. He finished with a hat trick and an assist. Slate Glick contributed two goals and two assists and Oliver Edson made eight saves in goal. Martin’s Six RBIs
Lead Whalers Softball Fiona Martin went 3 for 3 with a double and a triple, drove in six runs and scored three times to lead the Pierson/Bridgehampton softball team (2-14 in ... 14 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Meehan Pitches No-Hitter for Bonac Baseball; Bonac Girls Lacrosse Shuts Out North Babylon; McDonnell Records 200th Career Strikeout; Baymen Girls Lacrosse Earns First Win

Meehan No-Hits Hills West,
Leads East Hampton Baseball After losing the series opener, 11-6, on April ... 7 May 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Baseball Sweeps Harborfields; Bees Baseball Heading to Playoffs; Southampton Girls Golf and Boys/Girls Track Undefeated

Bonac Softball Breaks Out Bats Izzy Briand missed hitting for the cycle by a home run, going 4 for 4 with a double and a triple and three RBIs to lead the East Hampton softball team (3-5 in League V, 3-6 overall) to a 15-0 victory at Harborfields on Friday. Alexa Schaffer went 2 for 3 with a double, a triple and two RBIs. Maryjane Vickers went 2 for 3 with three RBIs and Ella Abran struck out four and only allowed three hits in five innings. Tintle Paves Way for East Hampton/Pierson Girls Lacrosse Ava Tintle scored six goals and assisted ... 29 Apr 2025 by Staff Writer

Weekly Roundup: Bonac Girls Track Sets New School Record; Girls Lacrosse Wins First DI Game; Baymen Baseball Net Win Over Greenport

Bonac Baseball
Back in Win Column East Hampton (4-3 in League V) defeated visiting Harborfields, 9-4, on Monday to bring a quick halt to a three-game losing streak after getting swept by Eastport-South Manor two weeks ago. Despite being outhit by the Tornadoes, 9-5, the Bonackers made the hits count when needed, putting up five runs in the third to take a 5-2 lead, then scoring four runs in the fifth to extend that lead even further. Livs Kuplins went 2 for 2 with an RBI and a run scored. Tyler Hansen, Mason Miles, Carter Dickinson and Hudson Beckman each drove ... 22 Apr 2025 by Staff Writer

East Hampton's Ava Tintle Scores Her 100th Career Goal

Ava Tintle cut to the middle of the attacking third, caught a pass from eighth-grade ... 15 Apr 2025 by Drew Budd

Weekly Roundup: Schaffer's Homer Walks It Off for Bonac Softball's First Win; Bonac Girls Track Wins First Dual; Hurricane Boys Lacrosse Has Won Three Straight

Schaffer’s Homer Walks It Off
For Bonac Softball The East Hampton softball team (1-5 overall) won its first game of the season in dramatic fashion on Friday at home. After Lydia Rowan’s triple in the bottom of the seventh scored the tying run, Alexa Schaffer won it with a three-run home run that capped the 13-10 come-from-behind victory for the Bonackers. Schaffer went 2 for 4 with three runs scored and four RBIs. Colleen McKee went 4 for 5 with a run scored and Isabel Briand went 2 for 4 and struck out four in the circle. Bonac Girls Track
Earns First ... by Staff Writer

South Fork Boys Lacrosse Has Regained its Footing After Tough Season-Opening Loss

Since its rough season-opening 16-0 loss at Westhampton Beach on March 28, the South Fork ... by Drew Budd